| First Team | Pts | Second Team | Pts | Third Team | Pts | |
| SP | Mark Prior (Andy) | 626 | Pedro Martinez (Tom) | 564 | Roger Clemens (Jim) | 468 |
| SP | Roy Halladay (Jerry) | 622 | Kerry Wood (Andy) | 561 | Hideo Nomo (Tommy) | 465 |
| SP | Jason Schmidt (Tommy) | 607 | Tim Hudson (Charlie) | 550 | Bartolo Colon (Rick) | 458 |
| SP | Estaban Loaiza (Jerry) | 587 | Kevin Brown (Andy) | 547 | Jamie Moyer (Doug) | 450 |
| SP | Javier Vazquez (Andy) | 566 | Mike Mussina (Jerry) | 518 | Curt Schilling (Jerry) | 450 |
| RP | Eric Gagne (Charlie) | 684 | Billy Wagner (Tommy) | 545 | Mariano Rivera (Jerry) | 465 |
| RP | Keith Foulke (Doug) | 576 | John Smoltz (Jerry) | 503 | Eddie Guardado (Dan) | 440 |
| C | Javier Lopez (Rick) | 512 | Ivan Rodriguez (Andy) | 425 | Jason Varitek (Charlie) | 381 |
| C | Jorge Posada (Doug) | 433 | Jason Kendall (Tom) | 392 | Mike Lieberthal (Rick) | 378 |
| 1B | Todd Helton (Rick) | 617 | Carlos Delgado (Jeff) | 597 | Jim Thome (Dan) | 573 |
| 2B | Alfonso Soriano (Andy) | 589 | Bret Boone (Dan) | 577 | Aaron Boone (Tommy) | 474 |
| SS | Alex Rodriguez (Jeff) | 622 | Nomar Garciaparra (Dan) | 588 | Rafael Furcal (Tommy) | 511 |
| 3B | Albert Pujols (Jim) | 660 | Aubrey Huff (Rick) | 551 | Scott Rolen (Tommy) | 507 |
| OF | Gary Sheffield (Doug) | 619 | Carlos Lee (Charlie) | 545 | Carlos Beltran (Jeff) | 511 |
| OF | Vernon Wells (Tom) | 611 | Garrett Anderson (Charlie) | 541 | Luis Gonzalez (Jerry) | 505 |
| OF | Preston Wilson (Jeff) | 570 | Magglio Ordonez (Tommy) | 531 | Ichiro Suzuki (Dan) | 501 |
| OF | Manny Ramirez (Jim) | 558 | Andruw Jones (Andy) | 522 | Barry Bonds (Rick) | 499 |