YOB: c1844 A.D.
Weapon: Spanish Cavalry Sabre
Status: Dead (Duncan MacLeod, 1994)
An ex-boxer from Ireland who became a boxing coach. He resorted to hurting and sometimes killing those those who got in his way or tried to do things differently in fight matches. He killed a man who was trying to lure his prized boxer away from him, and when his boxer eventually left, Sulley killed him too. Sulley's old friend Duncan MacLeod, who suspected him of doing this before in the past, confronted him about it again in present day.