Co-Starring: Andrea Brooks (Katie), Brent Chapman (Ed the Landlord), Stephen Aberle (H.H. Holmes), Chris Eastman (Tourist), Lisa Marie Caruk (Teresa Ellis)
Written By: Matt Witten
Directed By: Kim Manners
Ep: 29
The Usual Suspects
Special Guest Star: Linda Blair (Detective Diana Ballard)
Guest Starring: Jason Gedrick (Detective Peter Sheridan)
Guest Starring: Samantha Ferris (Ellen Harvell), Chad Lindberg (Ash), Sterling K. Brown (Gordon Walker), Katharine Isabelle (Ava Wilson)
Co-Starring: Bill Mondy (Dr. George Waxler), Richard De Klerk (Scott Carey), Levi James ( ), Tom McBeath (Mr. Carey), Jason Benson ( ), Monique Ganderton ( )
Co-Starring: John R. Taylor (Sherwin), Brenda McDonald (Grandma Rose), Jonathan Bruce (Larry Williams), Rob Bruner ( ), Talia Williams ( )
Written By: Matt Witten
Directed By: Charles Beeson
Ep: 34
Nightshifter
Guest Starring: Chris Gauthier (Ronald Reznick), Charles Malik Whitfield (FBI Special Agent Victor Henrikson)
Co-Starring: Stephen E. Miller ( ), Alison Matthews ( ), Sanjay Talwar ( ), Holly Hougham ( ), Georgia Craig (Sherri), Roman Podhora ( ), Kurt Max Runte ( ), Emy Aneke (Sampson), Brad Turner ( )
Written By: Ben Edlund
Directed By: Phil Sgriccia
Ep: 35
Houses of the Holy
Guest Starring: Denis Arndt (Father Reynolds), David Monahan (Father Gregory)
Co-Starring: Heather Doerksen (Gloria), Dan Mellor (Pedophile), Wesley Salter (Zach Smitt), Sean Rogerson (Rapist), Zara Taylor ( ), Brent Fidler (TV Evangelist)
Written By: Sera Gamble
Directed By: Kim Manners
Ep: 36
Born Under a Bad Sign
Guest Starring: Jim Beaver (Bobby Singer), Alona Tal (Joanna "Jo" Beth Harvell)
Co-Starring: Philip Granger (Manager), Richard Kahan (Clerk), Vince Murdocco ( )
Written By: Cathryn Humphris
Directed By: J. Miller Tobin
Ep: 37
Tall Tales
Guest Starring: Jim Beaver (Bobby Singer), Richard Speight, Jr. (Janitor), David Tom (Curtis)
Co-Starring: Barclay Hope (Professor Cox), Tara Wilson (Co-ed), Emma Lahana ( ), Desiree Loewen ( ), Elena Esovolova ( ), Neil Grayston ( ), Chad Hershler (Research Scientist), Matreya Fedor ( ), Angela Case ( ), Mashiah Vaughn ( )
Co-Starring: David Quinlan (Lawyer), Patrick Currie (Kurt Mueller), Brad Dryborough (Glen), Caroline Carter ( ), Rob Hayter (Cop), Teryl Rothery (Coroner), Lindsay Maxwell ( ), Yasmine Vox ( )
Written By: Sera Gamble
Directed By: Kim Manners
Ep: 40
Hollywood Babylon
Guest Starring: Gary Cole (Brad Redding), Don Stark (Jay Wiley), Regan Burns (McG), Michael B. Silver (Martin), Elizabeth Whitmere (Tara Benchley), Ben Ratner (Walter Dixon)
Co-Starring: Andrew Francis ( ), Morgan Brayton ( ), rnelsonbrown (Gerard St. James), Torrance Coombs (Mitch), Alycia Purrott (Kendra), Graeme Duffy (Dave), Patricia Nudd ( ), Gerry Rousseau ( ), Julie Patzwald ( ), Leah Graham ( )
Written By: Ben Edlund
Directed By: Phil Sgriccia
Ep: 41
Folsom Prison Blues
Guest Starring: Charles Malik Whitfield (FBI Special Agent Victor Henriksen), Bridget Ann White (Mara Daniels), Jeff Kober (Randall), Garwin Sanford (Guard Deacon)
Co-Starring: Kurt Evans ( ), Robert Parent ( ), Andee Frizzell ( ), Alistair Abell ( ), Steven Cree Molison (Lucas), Clif Kosterman (Tiny), James Michalopoulos ( ), Chris Nowland ( ), Byron Lucas ( )