Political Institutions:

State, War, and Politics


 

Pratt Institute Spring 2004 SS. 205.01 Thursday 2:00 -- 4:20


Ric Brown

Office: Dekalb 419

Office Phone: 1.718.636.3567, ext. 2709

Office Hours: Monday 1:00pm-1:55pm and 4:30pm-5:30pm, Tuesday 1:00pm-1:55pm and by appointment

Email: brbrowniii@earthlink.com

URL: http://geocities.datacellar.net/Athens/7364

_______________________________________________________________________

Catalog Description
 

 

SS 205.01 POLITICAL INSTITUTIONS
 

 

This is a an examination of the theory and operation of the major types of political systems. The course focuses on the question of power as it extends from the state to daily life. Both formal and informal, sanctioned and unsanctioned modes of political expression will receive attention.
 

 

Course Description

When I last offered this course, the subject matter addressed the origins of political institutions and developed an understanding of that political institutions are not just the obvious ones, but that the family, community, even the individual should also be considered political institutions. In part, that emphasis was determined by the prevailing politics of the day, which centered on family values on the conservative side and the emphasis by moderates on obligation to community.
 

 

This semester, the course will focus on political institutions again in light of current politics. Specifically, the circumstance of an election during wartime. So this semester special emphasis will be placed on discourse and rhetoric as the mediation between the state and war. If politics is warfare carried on by other means, then it is also true that war is politics carried out by other means. “War is peace and peace is war” was how Orwell put it, but one did not have to wait until 1984. This basic construction is immanent in the theory and practice of the State and of war.

Oration is a tactic and a strategy of war and of politics: to speak is to struggle. If we speak freely, then we act. With speech comes forms of rationality (or ways of making sense of the world else speech would not communicate any meaning), so the course will also focus on decision-making by institutions in a state of crisis. We will use two historical events as case studies: the Cuban Missile Crisis and the Apollo XIII disaster to examine modes of decision making and analysis.
 

 
 
 

Course Requirements
 

 

Class Participation

Education is not a one way street and we can not expect to simply passively receive knowledge. Participation is mandatory and will be factored into the final grade.
 

 

Contention Cards

Participants are expected to prepare a short statement on the readings for each class. The statement should address some aspect of the readings that you found interesting, troubling, questionable, or it may be a more general comment.

A) This statement should be legibly written on a standard 3x5 index card.

B) Write your name and the reading that you are addressing on the top line of the card.

C) Keep a copy for yourself and give one copy to me at the beginning of each class. I

Contention cards will constitute 20 percent of the final grade.
 

 

Final Paper

One paper, 8-12 pages in length. All papers are to be typed and double-spaced on standard paper in a standard font. Handwritten papers will not be accepted. The paper will count for 80 percent of the final grade.
 

 

Absences and Lateness

Persistent absences or lateness will result in a reduction of your final grade.
 

 

Grades and Incompletes

Incompletes will be granted only in accordance with the established policy of the college. The request must be made in advance of exam week. It must be made in writing. An incomplete is “available only if the student has been in regular attendance, has satisfied all but the final requirements of the course, and has furnished satisfactory proof that the work was not completed because of illness or other circumstances beyond control” (Pratt Institute Bulletin).
 

 
 
 

READINGS
 

 

The Required texts for the class are

a) the Class Reader available at the Stuben Copy Center
 

 

b) The Essence of Decision: Explaining the Cuban Missile Crisis

Graham T. Allison, Grahman Allison (Editor);
ISBN: 0321013492
Paperback, 416pp
Pub. Date: January 1999
Publisher: Addison-Wesley
Edition Description: REV
Edition Number: 2

 
 

c) Constructing the Political Spectacle

Murray J. Edelman
ISBN: 0226183998 |
Paperback, 137 pages
Publisher: University of Chicago Press; (March 1988)

You may purchase or order the books from many bookstores in the city, including St. Marks Books, Labyrinths Books, Barnes and Nobles on 5th Ave, Colosseum Books, etc. You may also purchase these books, online.
 

 
 
 

I suggest these sources for purchasing the readings:
 

 
 
 

The Advanced Book Exchange

abebooks.com - over 6,300 booksellers from around the gllobe with 20 million items listed.

The Strand
www.strandbooks.com --- the huge second-hand store on 12th street.

Tattered Cover Bookstore
large independent bookseller specializing in new books.
www.tatteredcover.com

Powells

wells.com

Barnes and Nobles 

www.BARNESANDNOBLE.com

Amazon.com
http://www.amazon.com
 
 

Blake's Books

http://www.blakesbooks.com

City Lights Books

www.citylights.com

Bookfinder

www.bookfinder.com - over 5,000 individual booksellers.>

Borders

www.borders.com

You may also personally order the text from the Pratt bookstore.

 

 

Readings not in required texts:

The photocopies of these may be purchased from the Pratt copy center in Stuben.
 

 

________________________________________________________________________

Session I: Introduction to the Course
 

 

PART ONE

FOUNDATIONS OF POLITICAL INSTITUTIONS


 
 

Session II:

Plato, The Republic, Book II. The Luxurious State (372A-374E), pgs.59-63     
  http://classics.mit.edu/Plato/republic.html 

Aristotle, Politics Chapter XVII, On the State, the household, and Slavery, pgs.1-6       
  http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/politics.html  

Sigmund Freud, Civilization and Its Discontents, pgs.41-54

Alexandre Kojeve,Selection from an Introduction to the Reading of Hegel: Lectures on the Phenomenology of Spirit.
 

 

Session III:

The History of Political Institutions

Karl Marx, from the German Ideology  

  http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1845/german-ideology/index.htm

Max Weber, "Politics as a Vocation" pgs.124-127; "Characteristics of Bureaucracy" pgs.196-198; "Stages in the Development of Bureaucracy" pgs.235-239; "The Sociology of Charismatic Authority"; pgs.245-248;  "The Origins of Discipline in War"; pgs.255-260. From H.H. Gerth and C. Wright Mills 1981[1946]. From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology. New York: Oxford University Press.

E.V. Walter, "Policies of Violence: from Montesquieu to the Terrorists"; in The Critical Spirit: Essays in

 Honor of Herbert Marcuse (Boston: Beacon Press) Kurt Wolff and Barrington Moore. 1968.
 

 

Session IV: The State, Authority, and Terror

V. Lenin, State and Revolution, from Lenin on Politics and Revolution, pgs.184-195.

http://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1917/staterev/ch01.htm

Leon Trotsky,
Selection from
Terrorism and CommunismInternational Publishers
http://www.marxists.org/archive/trotsky/works/1920/dictatorvs/index.htm


Henry J. Schmidt, trans. and ed. 1977. 
Georg Buchner. The Complete Collected Works, New York: Avon.

Max Horkhiemer,"The Authoritarian State"

Documentary: Seduction of a Nation. (1 Hour).


Session V: The State and Public Discourse

The Media and the Institutionalization of Political Discourse

Murray Edelman, Constructing the Political Spectacle
 

 Session VI: Documentary: The War Room

   

Session VII: The Media and the Institutionalization of Political Discourse II

Murray Edelman, Constructing the Political Spectacle
 

 

Session VII: Politics as War Carried out by Other Means: Political Discourse III

Documentary: Manufacturing Consent: Noam Chomsky
 

 

Session VIII: War and the State

Thucydides, Peloponnesian War, Pericle's Funeral Oration, Book II chap. 4, pgs.115-122


Abraham Lincoln, The Gettysburg Address

http://www.loc.gov/exhibits/gadd/


Plato, Republic Chap XVIII, v. 466d-471c, pgs. 169-174 ["On War"]

http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/cgi-bin/ptext?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.01.0168&layout=&loc=466d

Brutus, X, 24 January 1788 ["On the Standing Army"], from The Anti-Federalist Papers
and the Constitutional Convention Debates, edited by Ralph Ketcham, pgs.287-292;
http://odur.let.rug.nl/~usa/D/1776-1800/federalist/anti_I.htm


Gen. Douglas MacArthur, speech at West Point



Gen. George C. Patton, War Speech         

 

 

Session IX: The War Machine

Delueze and Guattari, "1227: Treatise on Nomadology---The War Machine, Proposition IX"; A Thousand Plateaus, pgs 416-423.


  Xenophon, from The Persian Expedition (also known as the Anabasis), pgs. 238-241


General William T. Sherman, excerpt from Sherman's March to the Sea, from The Great Republic According to The Master Historians, vol. III, pgs. 266-284
Sherman's March to the Sea     http://www.cviog.uga.edu/Projects/gainfo/marchsea.htm 


 

Session X: Politics as War Carried out by Other Means: Political Discourse IV

Martin Luther King, Jr. Speech at the Lincoln Memorial [I Have a Dream]


Lyndon Johnson, "The Great Society: Freedom is not Enough"


Lyndon Johnson, "Address before Congress" March 15, 1965


Ronald Reagan, "City on the Hill"


Mario Cuomo, "Two Cities" Convention Speech


Bill Clinton, First Inaugural Address: "A New Covenant for America"
 

 

PART TWO

TOPICS IN THE STUDY OF POLITICAL INSTITUTIONS:

Two Examples of Political Institutions in a Time of Crisis


Session XI: Essence of Decision

Session XII: Essence of Decision

Session XIII: Apollo 13

Session XIV: Apollo 13

Review XV:
 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   1