|
|
|
|
|
What relates Poetry to Design? Similarly one wonders about the relation
between philosophy and design. This page suggests some answers to these
questions.
A good starter is this citation from one of the latest books by Umberto Eco, "Kant e l'Ornitorinco" (Kant and the platypus), Bompiani, 1997, p.42 . " The language of poets seems to place itself in a free zone...They seem to be those that not only celebrate neccessity, but often they allow themselves (and us) to deny the resistance (n) - because for them turtles can fly, and even can escape from death." n.of undeniable facts, (my note) If this seems to troublesome to you you might proceed directly to the page on 'rythm in design' (in preparation) |
indice |
Paul Celan was a german poet born in 1920 in Rumania from jewish
parents.
This is a sample from the volume ATEMWENDE ( change of breath)
from 1967 with a possible explanation that does serve me to penetrate,
be it in a lateral way, in our topic: the sense of design.
|
DIE SCHWERMUTSSCHNELLEN HINDURCH
am blanken Wundenspiegel vorbei: da werden die vierzig entrindeten Lebensbäume geflösst. Einzige Gegen-
|
THROUGH MELANCHOLOC RAPIDS
past the blank mirror of wounds: there the forty skinned trees of life are floated. Only she the counter-
|
These words need explanation:
Celan shows us a place in the mountains, a place where his friends Nietsche
and Buechner used to dwell, there is a forest of giant trees its eternal
peace is disturbed, interrupted, killed forever. Yes activity is going
on: the holy trees (there are only forty of them) are cut, skinned and
floated into the river where they swim, passing through the swirls and
noise of rapids, along a quite lake that mirrors the sky, towards
their destiny of human consumption, construction or pulp. The modern world
is taking its toll but someone is contesting: a woman (is it green peace
?) reports.
past the blank mirror of wounds : history is reflection of past crimes here the forty : a multitude skinned trees of life are floated : revealing words are spoken Only she the counter swimmer : only poetry is struggling
to announce their truth
through melancholic rapids:
Past crimes that are remembered here are a constant theme in Celan's poems, referring to the holocaust, his mother died in a concentration camp. Poets are "Hurt by reality and searching for reality" states Celan in a speech from 1958. (4) The Torah, of which the Cabbala is an exegetic instrument, is an "opaque mirror of knowledge... yet it is shining in the pureness of written doctrine..., writes the eminent scholar of the Cabbala, Gershom Scholem, ... knowledge cannot be retrieved from it." This will explain the 'blank' mirror in Celan's poem. (5) |
The sin fall , detail, painted by Michelangelo in 1508-1512 on the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel in the Vatican Museum in Rome. |
forty years
St. Augustin indicated in forty the product of 4 (= time) and 10 (= knowledge): 'forty' teaches therefore to live in coherence to knowledge; and, what is more, it took Moses forty years, after first engraving the 10 commandments on a stone slab, to deliver the Torah rolls that he wrote during the exodus through the desert. At Stonehenge forty stone blocks are used as columns in a circle forty paces wide, alluding to an astral origin. (6) This is a famous symbol in ancient religions of India (Veda) and Mesopotamia (Zohar), signifying the emanation of divinity in all things living. Often it is imagined upside down with its roots in heaven and its branches on earth. Much mystification has developed around such sacred texts and its supposed benevolent influences, as in the movement of "The Golden Dawn" which doesn't interest us really in this pages. Even then some positive effects can be found in the net. I suggest this "Tree of Life" site, it offers an interesting biological taxonomy: http://ag.arizona.edu/tree/phylogeny.html
Celan mentions, in his poem, 40 trunks, remnants of trees of life and as it is known that the jewish poet, amongst the different meanings of his texts, always includes the reflection about the distance between words and names, the first being directly accessible to the senses, the other indirectly pointing at the mystical name of God, the forty trunks are in this sense forty words on the way to become names in a poem. Are there perhaps forty religions in the world as a further allusion?
(auriel@primenet ) Explains the french anthropologist Gilbert Durand:
"shell" or "husk". The idea of a covering or a garment or a vessel is common in Cabbala, where it is used, at various times and with various degrees of subtlety, to express the manner in which the light of the En Soph is "encapsulated". For example, the Sefiroth , in their capacity of recipients of light, are sometimes referred to as kelim , "vessels". The duality between the container and the contained is one of the most important in Cabalistic explanations of the creative moment. The word "qlippah " is an extension of this metaphor. A qlippah is also a covering or a container, and as each sephira acts as a shell or covering to the sephira preceding it in the order of emanation, in a technical sense we can say the qlippoth are innate to the Tree of Life. Cut a slice through a tree and one can see the growth rings, with the bark on the outside. The Tree of Life has 10 concentric rings, and sometimes the qlippah is equated to the bark. The word is commonly used to refer to a covering which contains no light: that is, an empty shell, a dead husk...... The "Zohar " attributes the primary cause of evil to the act of separation. The act of separation is referred to as the "cutting of the shoots". What was united becomes divided, and the boundary between one thing and another can be regarded as a shell. The primary separation was the division between the Tree of Life (Pillar of Mercy) from the Tree of Knowledge (Pillar of Severity). In normal perception the world is clearly characterized by divisions between one thing and another, and in this technical sense one could say that we are immersed in a world of shells. The shells, taken by themselves as an abstraction divorced from the original, undivided light (making another separation!), are the dead residue of manifestation, and can be identified with dead skin, hair, bark, sea shells, or shit. They have been referred to as the dregs remaining in a glass of wine, or as the residue left after refining gold. According to Scholem, the Zohar interprets evil as "the residue or refuse of the hidden life's organic process"; evil is something which is dead, but comes to life because a spark of God falls on it; by itself it is simply the dead residue of life. The skeleton is the archetypal shell. By itself it is a dead thing, but infuse it with a spark of life and it becomes a numinous and instantly recognizable manifestation of metaphysical evil. The shell is one of the most common horror themes; take a mask, or a doll, or any dead representation of a living thing, shine a light out of its eyes, and becomes a thing of evil intent. The powers of evil appear in the shape of the animate dead - skulls, bones, zombies, vampires, phantasms." (cited from Colin Low)
Celan tells us here that he, though a poet, gives utmost importance to facts and the objective analysis of them. But the search is also conducted in another, alternative way 'touching' its objects, approaching them with poetic sensitivity, with feeling. |
Albrecht Duerer's Melancholia , 1510 to 1515. |
This is the central point of my excursion in the field
of poetry: details, as "Denkbruchstücke",
Benjamin's "thought segments" (10),
tell a tale that differs from the obvious whole, a chair is a chair is
a chair, but the form of the passage between an armrest and the back
of the chair, just as any joint, tells a different story, similar
to words outside their normal context.
An important hidden criteria for evaluating a poem is its rhythm, the
measure of its cadences, but this is strictly connected to the language
in which it is written in and nearly impossible to save in
translation. But you can look at the DA dada-'words' that show Celan's
convincing rhythm of the following nonsense phrase (you may recall the
Dada movement in Europe from the beginning of this century):
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
In this table I suggest, in a truly dadaist way, a prosodic scheme
for the metrics underlying Celan's poem in the german edition, with
shows the carefully selected alternation of iambic and anapestic accents
in the first verse and of the dactylic accents in the second. It
evidences also the symmetry and the accelerating change of accent of the
second verse in respect to the first, as it seems proper for the great
effort of swimming counter current of the actress in the poem and it expresses
in the same time the meaning of the title of the volume to which the poem
belongs "ATEMWENDE" (change of breath), the alternating of in- and exhaling.
The theme of breath recurs often in Cellar's poems as it does, for example
in islamic mystical thinking of the Sufi's. Walter Benjamin sees
the development of art, as a search for truth, a deep respiration of the
mind. (11)
This parallelism of the semantic and the prosodic discourse, theorized by Greimas , is the aspect upon which my interest in poetry and its affinity to the theme of form and function in design is centered. (12) Celan, in one of his rare theoretical writings, explains his interest for prosody: "Art, that is, as You will remember, a childless, iambic five footed being, and this quality is also proved by the reference to Pygmalion and his creation." (13) (I due time I will enter here an "embedded object" to actually let you hear the rhythm.) We can connect the notion of prosodic rhythm with modularity in architecture and design. |
(1) Walter Benjamin, coins
the term "devastated language" in relation to baroque theater pieces
in Abhandlungen, Gesammelte Schriften,I-1, p.382, Suhrkamp,
1983 (back)
(2) Petra Leutner, Wegedurch die Zeichenzone. Stéphane Mallarmé und Paul Celan Metzler, Stuttgart, 1994, p.186 (back) (3) Walter Benjamin, op.cit. I-1,p.407 (back) (4) Paul Celan, Gesammelte Werke, III, p.186, Suhrkamp, 1983 (back) (5) Gerschom Scholem, Zehn unhistorische Sätze über Cabbala (1938) in Il Nome di Dio e la teoria cabbalistica del linguaggio, Adelphi, Milano, 1998, p.95, orig.ed. Suhrkamp, Frankfurt, 1970 (back) (6) Franz Carl Endres and Annemarie Schimmel, Das Mysterium der Zahl, Eugen Dietrichs Verlag, Cologne, 1984, the page numbers refer to the it.ed. Il dizionario dei numeri , Como, 1991 (back) (7) Gilbert Durand, Les structures anthropologiques de l'Imaginaire , P.U.de France, 1963, it.tr. Le strutture antropologfiche dell'immaginario , Dedalo, Bari, 1963 p.347 (back) (8) Günter Sternberger, Der Talmud, Einführung, Texte, Erläuterungen Beck, München, 1982; it.tr. Il Talmud, introduzione, testi, commenti Dehomane, Bologna, 1989 (back) (9) cf.
. (back)(10) Walter Benjamin, op.cit. , p.208 (back) (11) Walter Benjamin, op.cit. , p.225 (back) (12) Algirdas Julien Greimas, Essais de sémiotique poétique , Paris, 1972, p.11 (back) (13) Paul Celan, op.cit. p.187, , Der Meridian ,1960 (back) |
|||
back
to
"special page" |
|
|
|
|
|