PhD Ponderings



These are my ponderings, thoughts about life in graduate school, based on Aaron Karo's Ruminations. They're fictional entertainment and not criticism so don't sue me. - rani


Ponderings #10 - October (the next year!)
Life as a Graduate Student - october

Halloween.

It's been more than months since I last wrote an issue, hasn't it? I hope you will consider what I might have been doing during the long months that have intervened while you waited longingly for this issue (yeah, whatever):

Was I
a) snoozing at my desk over papers
b) scrounging up quarters for last year's taxes
c) begging my advisor for compassion (as if)
d) actually working
e) just kidding about that one :)

If you picked e, you are absolutely, positively

WRONG.

Believe it or not, I was actually working. What? Does this happen, you may ask. You may wonder what has happened to the standards of graduate studentship and other ships in the night. You may cast your eyes down and shake your head and say, "I was afraid of this. I knew someday this would happen. What has happened to the kids these days?"

But you must cheer up, because in all the time I have been working, I have accomplished nearly nothing! You must know that I have found comfort in work without clear results! I have worked diligently without publishing a paper!

It's almost as good as publishing a paper without working.

Aah publishing. It is that word that sweetens our tongues and makes our eyes fog with yearning. To have your name in print on smooth glossy pages alongside your advisors, with a star by your name and a footnote. To have a set of figures and text following and page numbers in the corners. To have acknowledgements at the end and references and to be referenced by others and to be noticed for what you have done!!! Why, it's astonishing.

Well, it's astonishing: your name is misspelled, the star by your name is for "minor contributions" or "these two authors contributed equally" (i.e. each did half of what they should have), the page numbers are 13131313-13131314, and you are referenced by one other paper that happens to be by someone in your own lab.

It isn't so bad. At least it's published. Think of those poor people who actually spend months doing experiments and calculations. Then they write it up, send it to the prof, have it back, edit for another few months. Send it to a paper, only to have it plastered with a big red REJECTED. And send it to another, where you get two reviews: one says BRAVO and the other says BRAVO but sarcastically. You send it elsewhere, where they say it's too good for us. You send it elsewhere, where they say you should have sent it to the other one. And another journal says they don't have "enough space."

When you finally get your paper in, you are thrilled, only to be told you have 50 revisions to make (including changing your hypothesis). So you stick to it, change what you can, and are finally informed of your acceptance: to be published in 2010.

In the meantime, another group publishes the same information. Boy, I love writing!

Happy Halloween! (Trick or Treat)...

1