The strict and mild treatment of the Caliph Umar (ra)

Refrences from and Transmitted by:
Hayatus Sahabah (Lives of the Companions) p 41 - 43 .
Abi Naim in Al Hilliyah .
Al Kanz Vol V p382 .

In the Name of Allah, the Most Beneficent, the Most Merciful

Said bin Musaiyb (ra) says:

When Umar bin Khattab (ra) became a Caliph he delivered his address from the pulpit. After praising Allah, he said, "O People! I am aware of the fact that you think of me as a strict tough person. And this is because I had been with the Prophet (pbuh) as a slave and a servant and he was as Allah has said, about him, 'You are very kind and merciful toward the Muslims'. In fact, I was like a drawn-out sword in his presence but he would keep me in the sheath and I stopped if he ordered me not to do something otherwise I would attack people because of his extreme politeness. I passed my days with the Prophet (pbuh) in the same manner till he passed away. And he left in a state that he was pleased with me. I pay much thanks to Allah over this and I achieved success because of him. I remained with Abu Bakr (ra) in the same manner who became his (pbuh) Caliph. You know well how soft, kind and merciful he was in his dealings. I was his servant and acted like an open sword. I used to associate my firmness with his softness. But I used to stop if he ordered me so, otherwise I acted on my own. I passed my days with him until he also passed away. Bu he left in a state that he was pleased with me and I thank Allah much for this. I achieved success because of him too. Now your affairs have been entrusted to me. And I know someone will say that I was so strict when the Caliphate was in the hands of others and what will I do now when the Caliphate has come to me. Let it be known to you that you should ask others nothing about me, for you know me well and you have vast experience about me. You are well aware of the Sunnah of the Prophet (pbuh) as I know it. And I am not ashamed of (doing) anything if I think it to be good, for I have already verified things from the Prophet (pbuh). Now I want to make you know that my firmness against the oppressors and the wrong-doers will now multiply, as the Caliphate has come to me. I will not rest until my cheek touches the ground in my strict actions against exploitations of the weak. I will perform my duties with determination in the interests of the honest and the pious people, who refrain from doing wrong and who obey commands of Allah. I do no don't deny the fact that if any difference takes place between you and me, I shall be found ready to go to anybody of your favour for seeking justice. Thus, 'O Servants of Allah! Fear Allah and help me to become a person who acts in accordance's with Allah's permissible and impermissible orders and do not hesitate to tender me your admonition regarding the matters Allah has entrusted to me'. Thereafter he descended from the pulpit.
Mohammad bin Zaid (ra) narrates. Ali (ra), Uthman (ra), Zubair (ra), Talha (ra), Abdul Rahman bin Auf (ra) and Saad (ra) gathered together and they said to Abdul Rahman (ra) who was supposed to be very frank with Umar (ra), 'You go and talk to Amir-Mominin about the people and say that a needy person goes to him with his grievance but cannot place it before him out of fear, and awe'. Accordingly Abdul Rahman (ra) went to Umar (ra) and said, 'Please turn polite towards people, because a needy person comes to you but he cannot place his grievances out of fear, and he goes back without saying anything'. Umar (ra) said, 'Tell me by Allah, O Abdul Rahman, have you been sent by Ali, Uthman, Talha, Zubair and Saad?'. Abdul Rahman (ra) replied in the affirmative. Umar (ra) said, 'O Abdul Rahman! By Allah, I became so much mild and soft towards the people that fear of Allah's accountability gripped me. Then I turned towards firmness but that too created fear of Allah in me. Now you tell me as to what is the way out?' Having heard this, Abdul Rahman (ra) got up with tears in his eyes, and while throwing shawl over his shoulders, he kept indicating that he very much regretted the attitude if those people (towards him).

Hayatus Sahabah (Lives of the Companions) p 41 - 43 .



Shabi narrates that Umar (ra) said, 'My heart turned as soft and mild as foams of water and my heart turned harder than stone in matters of Allah'

Transmitted by Abi Naim in Al Hilliyah .

Ibn Abbas (ra) narrates, 'When Umar bin Khattab (ra) became Caliph a certain person intimidated him that some people wanted you to give back your Caliphate.' Umar (ra) said, 'Why?'. The person said, 'They say you are stone-hearted'. Unar (ra) said, 'All praise be to Allah who has filled my heart with pity for them and their heart with my awe'

Al Kanz Vol V p382 .

1