Sample Review

LEARNER TRACK (PAGE 1 OF 4)


Thank you for participating. Which of these best describes the role in which you learned (with THIS resource):

Elementary school (K-5) student
Middle school (6-8) student
High school (9-12) student
College or university undergraduate (13-16) student
Graduate student
Pre-service K-12 teacher
In-service K-12 teacher, learning
College or university professor, learning
Museum or science center staff
Home school educator
Policy maker; government staff
NGO staff
Research lab staff
Journalist
Curriculum developer
Librarian
Interested member of the public
Other: please specify:

 

Sample Review

 

LEARNER TRACK (PAGE 2 OF 4)

Thank you for helping us evaluate this resource. These ratings influence which resources are included or deleted from the DLESE reviewed collection, and which resources shall receive "Best of DLESE" awards.



Pedagogical Effectiveness: Did You Learn From This Resource?


Evidence of Learning

4.

I learned a lot from this resource.

3.

I learned a fair amount from this resource.

2.

I learned a little from this resource.

1.

I learned nothing from this resource.

N/A

No opinion.

In the space below, please add any additional comments you might wish to make about how well you think you learned from this resource:



Technical Issues


Bugs & Technical Difficulties

4.

I experienced no technical difficulties.

3.

I encountered a minor bug or technical difficulty, but it didn't interfere with my learning.

2.

I encountered many bugs or substantial technical difficulties, such that they interfered with my learning.

1.

The resource didn't work at all in my computing environment.

N/A

Not applicable.

In the space below, please add any additional comments you might wish to make about how the digital resource functioned in your computing environment. If you are reporting a bug or technical difficulty, please specify the kind of hardware, operating system, and browser you were using:



Scientific Accuracy


Factual Errors

4.

I noticed no factual errors in the resource.

3.

I found one or two minor factual errors, but not enough to interfere with learning.

2.

I found several factual errors, enough to seriously misinform or mislead a learner.

1.

The resource is riddled with factual errors.

N/A

Not enough expertise to judge.

In the space below, please add any additional comments you might wish to make about the resource's scientific accuracy. It would be particularly helpful if you would cite any errors of fact you may have noticed:



Documentation & Supporting Information


Technical: How to use the resource

4.

Technical documentation was clear and complete.

3.

Technical documentation was sufficient to use the resource.

2.

Technical documentation was misleading, confusing, or otherwise not helpful.

1.

No technical documentation was provided, and I needed it.

N/A

Not applicable; technical documentation was not needed.

 



Scientific: Reference list, links to related Web sites, etc

4.

Scientific documentation was clear and complete.

3.

Scientific documentation was sufficient to use the resource.

2.

Rectangular Callout: Here you can make suggestions to improve the resource.Scientific documentation was misleading, confusing, or otherwise not helpful.

1.

No scientific documentation was provided, and I needed it.

N/A

Not applicable; scientific documentation was not needed.

In the space below, please add any additional comments you might wish to make about the documentation provided with the resource:



Ease of Use for Learners


Site Organization and Layout

4.

I found the site's organization and layout to be exemplary; an excellent model for other sites.

3.

The site's organization and layout did not inhibit my learning.

2.

The site's organization and layout caused me to struggle and occasionally frustrated me.

1.

The site's organization and layout prevented me from learning the material.

N/A

Not applicable; not intended for use on computer.

In the space below, please add any additional comments you might wish to make about how hard or easy the resource was for you to use.



Motivational/Inspirational for Learners


Generation of Interest

4.

I was fascinated by this resource.

3.

I was interested by this resource.

2.

It was OK.

1.

I was bored by this resource.

N/A

No opinion.

 



Generation of Curiosity

4.

Using this resource very much increased my curiosity to learn more about this and related topics.

3.

Using this resource increased my curiosity to learn more about this topic.

2.

Rectangular Callout: Your comment here can help make the resource more interesting.Using this resource did not increase my curiosity to learn more about this topic.

1.

After using this resource, I was even less curious about the topic than before.

N/A

No opinion.

In the space below, please add any additional comments you might wish to make about whether the resource inspired or motivated you.

 

 

Sample Review

 

LEARNER TRACK (PAGE 3 OF 4):

TEACHING TIPS

Rectangular Callout: Use this area to suggest ways the teacher may this resource better.

In the space below, please offer any advice you might have for other people using this resource. Your tips will be posted in the library in association with the resource.



 

Sample Review

 

LEARNER TRACK (PAGE 4 OF 4)

DLESE wants to identify resources that work for all kinds of learners.

If you have a characteristic that sets you apart from most learners, here is a chance for you to recommend this resource to learners like yourself.

 

Based on my experience using this resource, I:

Strongly Recommend Using It

Weakly Recommend Using It

Advise Against Using it

 

Does not apply to me

I am an adult learner (older than traditional college age)

 

I am color-blind

 

I am blind or visually-impaired

 

I am deaf or hard of hearing

 

I have limited mobility

 

I have limited experience with technology

 

I have trouble reading English

 

I am classified as learning disabled

 

Rectangular Callout: Here you could explain why you think your experience might help other students.

Comments:


 

 

1