Name: Félix Viau
I live in: French!!!!!
Comments: (left blank)
Name: Elizabeth Whitlock
I live in: Texas,U.S.A.
Comments: As a citizen of your neighboring country,i am saddened by this
obvious form of racism.i plan on writting a letter to my state officials
protesting NAFTA,and i am going to remember this bill when i purchase products.
i will encourage my friends to do the same.If anglos are so hated by your
people, then anglos should be careful how they spend their funds.i can't see
helping a government promote racism.How sad for us, with our common heritage,
that we are at such odds.
Name: Etienne Laurent
I live in: Switzerland
Comments:
A few facts have to be corrected. I'm sorry to say, but it is not impossible to
get english services in Quebec and certainly more difficult than to get french
services in other provinces.
The english community in Quebec may not be totally satisfaid with bill 101 and
other laws to protect the french language. But there is a few facts that have to
taken in consideration. About 6 millions french people live in Quebec. A drop in
an ocean of english people living around us. The laws to protect french is not
directed as an oppression tool againts english quebeckers. It is in fact there
to promote fench. In the 50's, someone who be working for an insurrance
compagny, selling a policy to a client, both of them bieng french, they would be
signing a contract in english, and most people didn't understand of word of
english back then.
The oppression of english is obvious that the english quebeckers still have more
universities par capita the the french speaking quebeckers, radio stations, etc.
The have not been cut from any english, canadian and american culture, nor has
the gaol of even the separatist government to eliminate them.
To respnd also the letters from exas, let me just remind you that a great number
of states and cities in the U.S. have voted law to make english the only
official language. Let me also remind them that english quebecker and french
quebeckers are among the people most bilingul in the western wolrd.
It quite easy to sell an image of unjustice. Be sure to get more information
from all sides before making your own judgement on the subject.
Yes there are some compromises asked from the englis community in Quebec. It has
to be in cohabitation.
The frech canadian have done a few compromises over the years.
Quebec is certainly not a where racism is more present then in the US. Its my
opinion as a lived in Washington DC and in Montreal.
Authors Note: Nowhere in the article did I mention that english services were impossible to obtain. Rather, I said nearly impossible. And that's just what it is when legislation prohibits the use of english in the workplace. Other provinces do not prohibit the use in french in any way - instead, they promote it by investing millions of dollars into bilingualism.
You're certainly right that 20 years ago french was in the same situation. That's my point. We have corrected one evil with another.
Furthermore, before you use our TWO universities as an indicator of anglo-priviledges, ask yourself this: how many students attending those universities are out-of-province and foreign students? How many are francophone? McGill has an enormously high out-of-province and foreign student rate, and has a quota that 20% of its students must be french canadian.
Finally, the point of my piece was not to demean the french population in any way - indeed, I am part francophone myself. The point is freedom and justice. "Compromise" as you put it is NOT democracy, it is communism. I am pro-democracy, pro-freedom, and I believe that is reflected in the series on freedom in Quebec that I wrote.
|
Name: Nate Whitlock
I live in: Texas,U.S.A.
Comments: may i say as a citizen of the United States, my intrest in this issue is
one of common freedom from government oppression.I live in Texas, my
country is bordered by Mexico.As such,we have a very large hispanic
community in almost every major city. We provide language assistance in
our business',many of our schools have bilingual programs,we have
billboards in spanish. As a member of corporate america,i have learned
to speak some spanish phrases to assist my customers. It is good
business,it is also humane. I don't believe your language will ever die
out-it is beautiful.Also, with NAFTA in place,many american
children,mine among them,are learning to speak French. Good for
business.No reason stated stands up to logic. This leads me to believe
the people of Quebec hate all anglos,including me and my family. I plan
on using my freedom of speech to tell my friends about this
discrimination,write my legislators, and use my power as a consumer to
purchase goods not made in Canada. How sad that we are reduced to such
actions. Canada and the U.S. are so close in culture. The Acadians gave
us the wonderful influence of Louisiana.Why oppress your people and
force people like me to boycott in quiet support?
|
Name: John Flattus
I live in: Montreal, Quebec
Comments: Unfortunetly, I was also told to speak in French first then English if I wanted
to. But this was not told to me by my employer. This was told to me by a
person who had a shirt saying Quebec Libre on it.
I really don't mind greeting someone in their preferred language but I will not
leave my spoken language out.
My employer is awaiting the visit from the OLF, but he is a person that would
swing a baseball bat at someone for telling him that he has to do something.
Enstead of greeting people in both languages I now just greet then saying "LO"
(It sounds like both Hello, and Allo) and this way, when the person responds
back, I can then speak to them in their language.
I am proud to be able to speak both languages with almost no difficulties, but
what gets me really pissed is when the PQ Government treats the English like
they are not wanted here, and I am begining to dis-like speaking french, but I
won't go down to the level of maturaty that the PQ Government has.
| |