| WWF SUPERSTAR | DATE WON | DATE LOST |
| TAKA MICHINOKU | 7 DECEMBER 1997 | 18 OCTOBER 1998 |
| CHRISTIAN | 18 OCTOBER 1998 | 23 NOVEMBER 1998 |
| GILLBERG | 23 NOVEMBER 1998 | 8 FEBRUARY 2000 |
| ESSA RIOS | 8 FEBRUARY 2000 | 13 MARCH 2000 |
| DEAN MALENKO | 13 MARCH 2000 | 17 APRIL 2000 |
| SCOTTY 2 HOTTY | 17 APRIL 2000 | 25 APRIL 2000 |
| DEAN MALENKO [2] | 25 APRIL 2000 | 13 MARCH 2001 |
| CRASH HOLLY | 13 MARCH 2001 | 24 APRIL 2001 |
| JERRY LYNN | 24 APRIL 2001 | 5 JUNE 2001 |
| JEFF HARDY | 5 JUNE 2001 | 25 JUNE 2001 |
| X-PAC | 25 JUNE 2001 |