I 105th Congress, 2d Session - - - - - - - - - - - - House Document 105- 311
PART 1 APPENDICES TO THE REFERRAL TO THE UNITED
STATES HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES PURSUANT TO TITLE 28, UNITED STATES CODE, SECTION 595( c) SUBMITTED BY THE OFFICE OF THE INDEPENDENT COUNSEL, SEPTEMBER 9,1998
COMMUNICATION FROM
THE OFFICE COUNSEL,
OF THE INDEPENDENT KENNETH W. STARR
TRANSMITTING APPENDICES TO THE REFERRAL TO THE UNITED STATES HOUSE
OF REPRESENTATIVES PURSUANT TO TITLE 28, UNITED STATES CODE, SECTION 595( c) SUBMITTED BY THE OFFICE OF THE INDEPENDENT COUNSEL, SEPTEMBER 9, 1998
SEPTEMBER 18, 1998.~ Referred to the Committee on the Judiciary pursuant to H. Res. 525 and ordered to be printed
U. S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE 5w392 WASHINGTON : 199s
III
September l& l998 Foreword
Pursuant to H. Res. 525, which was adopted by the House of Representatives on September 11, 1998, by a vote of 363- 63, the Committee on the Judiciary, on September 18, 1998, ordered the public printing of volumes two through seven of the Referral from Independent Counsel Kenneth Starr The materials printed herein have been redacted by the Committee. All redactions approved by the Committee are indicated in the attached redaction
report.
At this time, the Committee has elected not to release certain material filed under seal with the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Arkansas.
House Committee on the Judiciary House Committee on the Judiciary
rv
V
House Committee on the Judiciary Redaction Report
Page or other Identification Number
Vol. II, Tab D, Map Vol. II, Tab G Vol. II, Tab I, pp. lo- 19
Vol. III, Tab 1
Reason for Redacted Material
National Security Personal Identifying Information
National Security Deposition of William Jefferson Clinton,
Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. III, Tab 4 Deposition Exhibit 3 Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. III, Tab 5 Deposition Exhibit 5 Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. III, Tab 8 Deposition Exhibit 8 Jones V. Clinton
Vol. III, Tab 9 Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
President Clinton’s Response to Plaintiffs Third Set of Interrogatories,
Jones V. Clinton Vol. III, Tab 10
Sealed Pursuant to Court Order President Clinton’s Responses to Plaintiffs First Set of Interrogatories,
Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
House Committee on the Judiciary Redaction Report
Page or other Identification Number Reason for Redacted Material
Vol. III, Tab 11 Deposition Exhibit 11 Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. III, Tab 12 Deposition Exhibit 12 Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. III, Tab 13 Deposition Exhibit 13 Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. III, Tab 14 President Clinton’s Supplemental Responses to Plaintiffs Second Set of
Interrogatories Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. III, Tab 15, 849- DC- 634 Personal Identifying Information Vol. IV, Tab 2, p. 111, lines 24- 25- p. Privacy
112, lines l- 7 Vol. IV, Tab 3, p. 53, lines 3- 20 Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 3, pp. 88,95, 96, index Privacy
Vol. IV, Tab 6, p. 1 Personal Identifying Information Vol. IV, Tab 10, p. 4 Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 7, p. 1 Personal Identifying Information Vol. IV, Tab 15, p. 10, lines 18- 20 (non- Privacy
compressed copy, p. 9, lines 18- 20)
VII
House Committee on the Judiciary Redaction Report
Page or other Identification Number
Vol. IV, Tab 15, p. 12, lines 3- l 1 (compressed copy, p. 13, lines 3- l 1)
Reason for Redacted Materia
Sexual Description Vol. IV, Tab 15, p. 17, line 4- 5 (compressed copy, p. 18, line 4- 5)
Sexual Description Vol. IV, Tab 15, p. 18, lines 22 !h - 24 (compressed copy, p. 19, lines 22 !A - 24)
Sexual Description Vol. IV, Tab 15, p. 19, lines 3- 17 (compressed copy, p. 20, lines 3- 16)
Sexual Description Vol. IV, Tab 15, 29, line 21- 30, p. p. 31, line 12 (compressed 30, line copy p. 2 l-
p. 31, line 12) Sexual Description
Vol. IV, Tab 15, p. 46, lines 16- 22 (compressed copy p. 47, lines 16- 2 1)
Sexual Description Vol. IV, Tab 15, p. 47, lines 8- l 1 (compressed copy p. 48, lines 8- l 1)
Sexual Description Vol. IV, Tab 15, p. 49, lines 15- 24 (compressed copy of p. 50, lines 15- 24)
Sexual Description Vol. IV, Tab 15, p. 69, index Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 16, pp. l- 4,6 Privacy
Vol. IV, Tab 17, pp. l- 3 Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 19, p. 1 Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 19, p. 4, para. 1 Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 19, p. 7, para. 2 Privacy
.
Vol. IV, Tab 20, p. 1 Privacy
VIII
House Committee on the Judiciary Redaction Report
Page or other Identification Number Reason for Redacted Material
Vol. IV, Tab 20, p. 2, para. 1 Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 20, p. 8, para. 2 Sexual Description II
Vol. IV, Tab 20, p. 9, para. 1 Sexual Description Vol. IV, Tab 20, p. 10, para. 1 Sexual Description Vol. IV, Tab 20, p. 14, para. 3 Sexual Description Vol. IV, Tab 20, p. 15, para. 3 Sexual Description II
Vol. IV, Tab 20, p. 16, para. 4 Sexual Description II
Vol. IV, Tab 20, p. 19, para. 1 Sexual Description II
Vol. IV, Tab 2 1, p. 1 Privacy II
Vol. IV, Tab 2 1, p. 9, para. 2 Privacy II
Vol. IV, Tab 21, p. 16, para. 7 Privacy II
Vol. IV, Tab 22, p. 1 Privacy II
Vol. IV, Tab 22, p. 11, para. 4 Privacy II
Vol. IV, Tab 23, p. 1 Privacy II
Vol. IV, Tab 24, p. 1 Privacy II
Vol. IV, Tab 24, p. 3, para. 2 Privacy II
Vol. IV, Tab 24, p. 10, paras. 3, 5,6 I Privacy II
Vol. IV, Tab 24, p. 11 Privacy II
Vol. IV, Tab 25, p. 2, para. 3 Privacy II
Vol. IV, Tab 25, p. 4, para. 1 Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 25, p. 8, para 2 (first) I Expletives II
Vol. IV, Tab 25, p. 8, para. 2 Privacy
lx
House Committee on the Judiciary Redaction Report
Page or other Identification Number I Reason for Redacted Material
Vol. IV, Tab 26, p. 1 Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 27, p. I Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 27, p. 5, para. 3 Sexual Description Vol. IV, Tab 27, p. 9, para. 2 Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 27, p. 9, para. 3 Privacy
Vol. IV, Tab 28, p. I Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 29, p. I Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 29, p. 2, paras. 4- 5 Privacy
Vol. IV, Tab 29, p. 4, para. 3 Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 30, p. 1 Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 30, p. 6, para. 5 Privacy
Vol. IV, Tab 3 1, p. 1 Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 32, p. I Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 33, p. I Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 34, p. 1 Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 35, p. I Privacy Vol. IV, Tab 37, pp. 2, 5, 6, 8, 12, 13 I Privacy
Vol. V, Tab 28, pp. l- 5 Privacy Vol. V, Tab 3 1, p. 1 Privacy Vol. VI, Tab 49, p. 1 Privacy
Vol. VI, Tab 54 Privacy Vol. VI, Tab 55 Privacy
X
House Committee on the Judiciary Redaction Report
Page or other IdentiIication Number Reason for Redacted Material
Vol. VI, Tab 59 Privacy Vol. VI, Tab 60, p. 3 Privacy
Vol. VI, Tab 61 Privacy Vol. VI, Tab 64 Privacy Vol. VI, Tab 74 Vol. VI, Tab 78, first occurrence
Privacy Privacy Vol. VI, Tab 78, second occurrence
Vol. VI, 0812- DC- 2 Sexual Description
Personal Identifjiing Information Vol. VI, 0828- DC- 12 I Personal Identifying Information Vol. VI, 0828- DC- 13 Vol. VI, 0828- DC- 23
Personal Identifying Information Personal Identifying Information Vol. VI, 0830- DC- 7 Vol. VI, 0830- DC- 17
Personal Identifying Information Personal Identifying Information Vol. VI, 083 1 -DC- 8- 11 I Personal Identifying Information Vol. VI, 0832- DC- 4- 5 Vol. VI, 0833- DC- 980
Personal Identifying Information Personal Identifying Information Vol. VI, 0833- DC- 1857 Expletive Vol. VI, 0833- DC- 27 16 Vol. VI, 0833- DC- 3207
Personal IdentifjGng Information Personal Identifying Information Vol. VI, 0833- DC- 17867, 69, 75, 86, 90,
903,904,908 Vol. VI, 0837- DC- l- 4,6- 19, 21- 24
Personal Identifying Information Personal Identieing Information
XI
House Committee on the Judiciary Redaction Report
Page or other Identification Number Reason for Redacted Material
Vol. VI, 0837- DC- 25- 27 Redacted Prior to Receipt Vol. VI, 0845DC- 190 I Personal Identifying Information Vol. VI, 0849- DC- 90- 102 President Clinton’s Responses to
Plaintiffs Third Set of Interrogatories, Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VI. 0849- DC- 121- 137 Plaintiffs Witness List Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VI, 0849- DC- 352 Transcript of Videotaped Oral Deposition U. S. V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VI, 0849- DC- 586 Vol. VI, 0849- DC- 634
Deposition Exhibit 1 Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Deposition Exhibit I5 Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VI, 0852- DC- 35, 37, 44,45 I Personal Identieing Information Vol. VI, 0854- DC- 1485 I Personal Identifying Information
Vol. VI, 0856- DC- 2 I Personal Identieing Information Vol. VI, 0880- DC- 2 I Personal Identifying Information Vol. VI, 08902- DC- 33 I Personal Identifying Information Vol. VI, 08902- DC- 135 I Personal Identifjiing Information
Vol. VI, 0916- DC- 3 Personal Identieing Information
XII
House Committee on the Judiciary Redaction Report
Page or other Identification Number Reason for Redacted Material
Vol. VI, 0920- DC- 13 Personal IdentiIjing Information Vol. VI, 0920- DC- 5 17- 525 Order,
Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VI, 0921- 61- 62 Clerk’s Minutes, Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VI, 092 1 -DC- 96- 100 Plaintiffs Motion to Compel Responses to Plaintiffs Second Set of Interrogatories
to Defendant Clinton Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VI, 0921- DC- 101- 119 Second Set of Interrogatories from Plaintiff to Defendant Clinton
Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VI, 0921- DC- 120- 137 President Clinton’s Responses to Plaintiffs Second Set of Interrogatories
Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VI, 0921- DC- 138- 143 Exhibit 3, Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VI, 0921- DC- 144- 145 Exhibit 4, Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VI, 0921- DC- 150- 151 Exhibit 5, Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
XIII
House Committee on the Judiciary Redaction Report
Page or other Identification Number
Vol. VI, 092 1 -DC- 459- 466
Reason for Redacted Material
Order, Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VI, 092 l- 736- 744 Order, Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VI, 092 l- 75 l- 752 Clerk’s Minutes, Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VI, 092 l- DC- 770- 72 Vol. VI, 0921- DC- 775- 778
Vol. VI, 0929- DC- 56 Vol. VI, 0964- DC- 862 Vol. VI, 096% DC- 73, 187,236,263, 303
Vol. VI, 0968- DC- 3506, 10,22, 33,46, 50, 56, 58, 69
Vol. VII, lOOO- DC- 768 Vol. VII, 10 13- DC- 95- 96
Vol. VII, 10 14- DC- 22 Vol. VII, 1033- DC- 33- 35 Vol. VII, 1033- DC- 115- 16
Clerk’s Minutes, Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Motion for Protective Order Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Personal Identieing Information Personal Identifying Information
Redacted Prior to Receipt Personal Identifying Information
Personal Identifjing Information Personal Identieing Information Personal Identifjing Information Personal IdentifjGng Information Personal IdentifjGng Information
XIV
House Committee on the Judiciary Redaction Report
Page or other Identification Number
Vol. VII, 1034- DC- 60- 63, 99, 103, 109, 111
Reason for Redacted Material
Privacy Vol. VII, 1037- DC- 11, 17, 22, 38, 40, 42, 63, 86, 103, 107, 265, 280, 296, 318, 338,
341,553,583 Personal Identieing Information
Vol. VII, 1037- DC- 39, 168, 3 18, 341 Vol. VII, 105 1 -DC- 3 Vol. VII, 1064- DC- 8 Vol. VII, 1065- DC- 6, 8
Vol. VII, 1078- DC- 2 Vol. VII, 1178- DC- 5, 11, 13- 16, 18- 21,
23 Vol. VII, 1178- DC- 26 Vol. VII, 1205- DC- 16 Vol. VII, 12 16- DC- 22- 23 Vol. VII, 1248- DC- 8, 305, 307, 3 11, 3 12-
315, 319, 327- 328, 381,444 Vol. VII, 1362- DC- 1171
Vol. VII, 1407- DC- 5 Vol. VII, 1408- DC- 5 Vol. VII, 1414- DC- 001, 1006- 1014
Expletives Personal Identifying Information Personal Identifying Information Personal Identifying Information Personal Identifjing Information Personal Identifying Information and
Certain Material Redacted Prior to Receipt
Personal Identifying Information Personal Identieing Information Personal Identifjring Information Personal Identifying Information
National Security Personal Identieing Information Personal Identifying Information
Order, Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
xv
House Committee on the Judiciary Redaction Report
Page or other Identification Number
Vol. VII, 1414- DC- 1188- 1192
Reason for Redacted Material
Order, Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VII, 1414- DC- 1327- 1346 Hearing Transcript Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VII, 1414- DC- 1534- 1546 Second Set of Requests from Plaintiff to Defendant Clinton for Production of
Documents Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VII, 1472- DC- 6- 20 Vol. VII, 1506- DC- 29, 3 1, 50
Vol. VII, 1506- DC- 57- 58 Vol. VII, 1506- DC- 68, 70, 102, 139, 144,
192,275,373 Personal Identifying Information
Personal Identifying Information Redacted Prior to Receipt Personal Identifying Information
Vol. VII, 2004- DC- 83, 85, 86, 87, 88, 90, 91
Personal Identifying Information Vol. VII, MSL- 55- DC- 94, 124
Vol. VII, MSL- DC- 1166 Vol. VII, MSL- DC- 1176, 1192
Vol. VII, V002- DC- 5 Vol. VII, V002- DC- 6- 15
Privacy Personal Identifying Information Personal Identicing Information Personal Identifying Information President Clinton’s Responses to Plaintiffs First Set of Interrogatories
Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
House Committee on the Judiciary Redaction Report
Page or other Identification Number Reason for Redacted Material
Vol. VII, V002- DC- 16- 32 President Clinton’s Responses to Plaintiffs Second Set of Interrogatories
Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VII, V002- DC- 52- 55 President Clinton’s Supplemental Responses to Plaintiffs Second Set of
Interrogatories Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VII, V002- DC- 56- 92 President Clinton’s Responses to Plaintiffs First Set of Requests for Projection of Documents and Things,
Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VII, V002- DC- 93- 116 President Clinton’s Responses to Plaintiffs Second Set of Document
Requests, Jones V. Clinton Sealed Pursuant to Court Order
Vol. VII, V004- DC- 134- 167 Personal Identieing Information Vol. VII, V004- DC- 171- 172 Redacted Prior to Receipt
Vol. VII, V004- DC- 183 Personal Identieing Information Vol. VII, V005- DC- 58, 60- 61 Redacted Prior to Receipt
Vol. VII, V006- DC- 7- 9 Personal Identifying Information Vol. VII, V006- DC- 20 Personal Identifying Information Vol. VII, V006- DC- 118 Personal Identifying Information
XVII
House Committee on the Judiciary Redaction Report
Page or other Identification Number
Vol. VII, V006- DC- 157- 159, 162, 167, 180, 181, 183
Reason for Redacted Material
Personal IdentitLing Information Vol. VII, V006- DC- 225 I Personal IdentifjGng Information Vol. VII, V006- DC- 39 1 Personal Identieing Information Vol. VII, V006- DC- 1770, 1792, 1796 Personal Identif+ ng Information
Vol. VII, VOOG- DC- 1813- 1814 I Personal IdentifjGng Information Vol. VII, V006- DC- 2064- 207 1 Personal Identifying Information and
Certain Material Redacted Prior to Receipt
Vol. VII, V006- DC- 2095,2130, 140, 142, 146- 147, 156, 158,214, 243
Redacted Prior to Receipt Vol. VII. V006- DC- 37 19 I Personal Identifiing; Information
XVIII
CONTENTS
Foreword .................................................................................................. Redaction Report ................................................................................... Volume II: Appendix.. ............................................................................
Statement of OX’s Jurisdiction ........................................................ Order Pe~ itting Disclosure of Grand Jury Material ................... Procedural Background and History of Jones v. Clinton.. ............. Map of White House, West Wing ...................................................... Table of Monica Lewinsky White House Visits.. ............................ Table of Contacts between Monica Lewinsky and the President . . Table of Phone Conversations .......................................................... Litigation History ............................................................................... Evidence Reference ........................................................................... Legal Reference .................................................................................. Monica Lewinsky Immunity Agreement.. .......................................
. . .
111
V
1 5 9 11 99 103 113 127 183 201 263 377
Volume III: Document Supplement, Part A, William J. Clinton Statement . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..**.........................................*...................*...*...... 381
Volume IV: Document Supplement, Part B, Monica S. Lewinsky Statements . . . . . . . . . o . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 701
Volume V: D~ ument SuppIement, Part C, Documents Cited in Referral: Tabs l- 46 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D... 1619
Volume VI: Document SuppIement, Part D, Documents Cited in Referral: Tabs 47- 83, Bates Numbers 812- 968 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2207
Volume VII: Document Supplement, Part E, Documents Cited in Referral: Bates Numbers lOOO- VO06 . . . . . . . . . .. l......................... 1 . . . . . 2747