Identification: Uncertain. If this person died in 1819 at the age of 61, they would have been born about 1756. Unfortunately, these dates do not seem to fit any of the grandchildren of Nicholas (Claus) Erb 1680. But the well-worn inscriptions are indeed ambiguous and subject to more than one interpretation. After photo enhancement (see below), I read the birth date on this tombstone [upper left] as "178?" and the death date [lower right] as "184?" -- a nice example of how genealogical data, even when "carved in stone", is never quite as certain as we would like it to be.

--Photo by Keith J. Erb, Enhancement by John Larkins

A reading of 1788-1849 would fit the 61 year age at death. And a birth date of abt 1788 would fit two of the children of Christian Erb 1758 (#2 below): Abraham, and Benjamin. (Daniel can be ruled out if the identification of stone #5 is correct.)
       Little is known about Benjamin c1788 but we do know that he was still in East Pennsboro in 1832 when he managed the estate sale of his deceased brother Christian 1793 (see #10 below). And he could well have died there himself some 17 years later at age 61.
       Abraham c1788 is an equally shadowy figure, but he was still in Cumberland Co. in 1819 when he signed over his rights to be repaid for a loan (in the form of a Judge's Bond). Although he was listed in the census of 1810, he does not appear in the censuses of 1830, 1840, or 1850. He might have fallen fatally ill in 1819 - which would be one explanation for the transfer of his bond and would fit Keith Erb's reading of an 1819 death date. Or he might have sold his repayment rights as part of his preparation to leave Cumberland Co. about 1819. Or he might have remained in East Pennsboro and died there about 1849. You can view a photo of Abraham's 1818 Judge's Bond here.

Identification: Christian Erb 1758, son of Christian 1734, grandson of Nicholas (Claus) 1680, and husband of Elizabeth Hershey 1765 [#3]. At least two of his sons are also buried here: Daniel [#5] and Christian [#10]. And probably a third son as well [at #1] -- either Benjamin or Abraham.

Identification: Elizabeth Hershey 1765, wife of Christian 1758 [#2]. One source has her having died in Cumberland County, but with a different date - Dec 1832

Identification: Uncertain. This was probably a heretofore unknown daughter of Christian 1758 [#2] and Elizabeth Hershey [#3]. (He is known to have had 4 sons and a daughter named Catherine, but could easily have had another daughter too.) Another possibility is that she was the young wife of the person buried next to her, Daniel Erb 1786 [#5]. (Daniel was only 25 when he died but might have married before then.) Since both Susanna and Daniel died in the same year, it is possible that they both contracted the same fatal disease or both were victims of the same fatal accident.

Identification: This would have been Daniel Erb c1786, eldest son of Christian 1758 [#2] and Elizabeth Hershey [#3]. His tombstone and that of Susannah are the earliest ones in "Erbs Row". His father was buried there 9 years later, and his mother 36 years later.

Identification: This was probably Samuel Erb c1831, a previously unknown son of Christian Erb 1793 [#10] and Elizabeth Witmer. His calculated birthdate of abt 1831 rules out Christian Erb 1758 and Elizabeth Hershey as his parents and Emily Terrell, a descendant of Christian, has a family-portrait-style photo of Elizabeth Witmer and three young men labelled "Christian", "Jacob", and "Samuel". Christian and Jacob are known to have been her sons, strongly suggesting that Samuel was as well.

Identification: Uncertain. None of the known John Erb's fits. There is a Reverend John Erb (1795-1844) buried in Cumberland Co., but at another cemetery.

Identification: Uncertain. Possibly a relative of Elizabeth Witmer 1796. (See #10.)

Identification: Uncertain. Could be a Daniel (or a David) P. Erb. (See #13 for D.P.E.'s possible daughter Rebecca, whose surname is given as Erb". But keep in mind that small marker stones were usually reserved for the graves of children.) If the "D." stands for Daniel, he might have been the eponymous son of Daniel Erb 1796 (#5 above).

Identification: Christian Erb 1793, son of Christian 1758 [#2] and husband of Elizabeth Witmer 1796, who died in Iowa. One source has Christian as having died 1831 in East Pennsboro.

Identification: Uncertain. Could be the son of #7 Johanne. But Charles is a name unknown among early descendants of Nicholas Erb.

Identification: Uncertain. None of the known Christian Erbs fits. But Christian and his brother Abraham (see #14) may have been the heretofore unknown sons of Bishop Jacob Erb (1804-1884) who was the son of Christian Erb 1758 (#2 above) and Elizabeth Hershey (#3) and is buried close by in Shropp's Cemetery near Shiremanstown. Jacob was the 10th Bishop of the United Bretheran Church and is known to have had a daughter named Mary (see #16). But the identities of his wife and other possible children are not known. If Christian and Abraham were his sons, they died young - a half century before their father.
      Alternately, Christian and Abraham might have been the sons of Jacob Erb c1815, who was himself the son of Benjamin Erb c1788 and the grandson of Christian Erb 1758 (#2). Benjamin is known to have lived in Hampden Twp., Cumberland County and had a son named Jacob. If Christian and Abraham were the sons of this Jacob, they would have to have both died in early childhood.

Identification: Uncertain. See #9 for her possible father.

Identification: Uncertain. None of the known Abraham Erbs fits. See #12 for his brother Christian and their possible fathers Bishop Jacob Erb 1804 and Jacob Erb c1815.

Identifications: Uncertain. Since her tombstone is in "Erb's Row", Mary Ann was probably an Erb. But no Erb-Renninger marriage is known. She may have been the Mary Erb c1850, who was the daughter of Bishop Jacob Erb 1804 -- particularly if it is her brothers Christian and Abraham that are buried at [#12] and [#14].

---

Note: All of the people identified above were descendants of Christian Erb 1758 or their spouses. So it would not be surprising if many of the remaining uncertain identities also turn out to be members of the same family line.