Pure Politics

IFAW's numbers don't add up

Glen Whiffen

Nov 24 98. The Fisheries Editor of The Telegram looks at the claims and counterclaims by government ministers and animal "welfare" groups.
 
 

If we took about 275,000 out of the ocean last year, that’s not even 50 per cent of the increase.

Newfoundland Fisheries Minister John Efford says a seal count is drastically needed this year to disprove claims by anti-sealing organizations that the annual hunt is placing the East Coast seal population in jeopardy.

“We have over six million (harp) seals out there,” said Efford.

“If they only pupped at a minimum rate of 10 per cent annually, that would be an increase in the population of 600,000 a year.

“If we took about 275,000 out of the ocean last year, that’s not even 50 per cent of the increase.”

The International Fund for Animal Welfare (IFAW) launched its campaign on Monday to protest the upcoming commercial seal hunt. The group claims the number of seals killed each year for the past three years was more than 400,000. This, it said, is causing the seal population to decline.

“The current scientific evidence that the seal hunt quota is unsustainable is so strong, that certain groups have chosen to speak up for the first time,” said Rick Smith, IFAW Canada director.

Smith referred to a study done by Ontario marine biologist David Lavigne, who states that Canada’s seal hunt kills up to 40 per cent more animals than are actually caught and processed in the hunt.

 

They prey on the Newfoundland sealing industry to raise as much money as they possibly can for the financing of their organization

A Globe and Mail story Monday stated that Lavigne, a professor at Guelph University, will be publishing a paper suggesting the seal hunt has exceeded quotas by up to 100,000 animals in each of the past three years.

Efford, however, said Lavigne has always been opposed to the seal hunt and the paper is not based on good information. He said the document is basically more propaganda for the IFAW and other anti-sealing organizations.

“They prey on the Newfoundland sealing industry to raise as much money as they possibly can for the financing of their organization,” said Efford. “Every single year, prior to the seal hunt starting off, this is the kind of thing that comes out. What do you do with it? You just ignore them and continue on with the seal industry as we have been doing over the last four or five years."


front local mscl music news sport
mail me

Mar 6 99
1