A Misfit girl (Robin Tunney) newly enrolled in a Los Angeles high school befriends three other troubled teens (Neve Campbell, Fairuza Balk, Rachel True) and, after showing them she has a knack for casting spells, is welcomed into their secret club dedicated to witchcraft. Soon, the girls are using their powers on a jock (Skeet Ulrich), a racist student (Christine Taylor), and others. Breckin plays Mitt, the jock's friend.