THE UNDERLYING PROBLEM

by Barbara Arthur

Disclaimer can be found in part one.

Comments welcome at Barbart@globalsite.net

Part Four


He shrugged. "Well, Janet didn't like me much in the beginning, if you recall."

"If by in the beginning, you mean all of those years ago in Florida, we both know she didn't. She was afraid for me to be around you, afraid you'd ruin me. But, Rick, that was all over by the time we were all in San Diego together, when you and I were working together."

"Yes," he admitted. "But what about when you guys decided to get married? How did she feel about me, then? And how did Janet feel about my book?"

He was asking for honesty, asking me to be honest with him as well as myself. And I knew I needed to be. The thought of Janet being mixed up in this made me want to vomit again. And yet--"She didn't like your book any better than I did, of course. Janet loves, er, loved me, she didn't like to see the one she loved being made to look like a buffoon."

"No, I suppose not," Rick mumbled. "So, did she ever make threatening comments about me?"

I was confused. "Rick, it's me that was given something, if I was, and if Janet did it. It must be me she wanted to hurt not-----"

My brother gave me that look he had, that look that said he knew I had thought of something, something he already had in his mind. "It could be both of us, Kid," he said softly. "Janet could have decided to use you to get at me, that way we would both be punished."

"No, I won't believe it," I said, stubborn.

"How dirty was your break up with her?"

******************************************


Rick---

A.J. wanted to discount what I was saying, but he couldn't do it. And I hated to say it. I had always liked Janet. Maybe, to be honest, I had more than liked her at different times in the span of years I'd known her. When I first met her in Florida, she and my brother were shacking up together on his boat, and he worked for her father. That's when she thought I was a very bad apple indeed, and tried desperately to keep A.J. away from me.

Later, when we all went back to San Diego, and even though they, A.J. and Janet, broke off their engagement, she worked in the D.A.'s office, we were all friends. Throughout, I thought a lot of her, maybe even loved her on occasion, although, because of the relationship she'd had with A.J., I kept it under wraps.

He finally got around to answering me. "It wasn't pretty, I guess."

"You guess?" I said to him. "Was it ugly enough to cause her to want us both in deep do do?"

He got up off of the bed and began pacing. "I wouldn't have thought so. We----"

"What? A.J., you need to think this through real careful."

"I know," he said. "We were angry with each other, sure. And your book had a lot to do with it."

"How so?" I probed.

"Well, it changed me, of course. I was angry and always disgruntled. She couldn't take it. I really didn't blame her."

"Ah, hah," I responded. "So, she was mad at me. Mad because you were so mad you couldn't live a normal life with her. After all those years of waiting to marry you, and even though I was far away, something I'd done was ruining your life."

He stopped pacing. "Yes, Damn it! Yes, you ruined my marriage! Janet was angrier than I was, really, about the way you portrayed me."

I had a nasty thought. "Angrier than you? Could it be she put it in your head to be angry in the first place? Isn't that about the time you got back together with her, A.J.?"

His back to me when I started to explore a new avenue of thought, my brother reeled around quickly. "No, Rick! Don't even think such a thing! If that's true----"

"If that's true, then what, Kid?"

"Then maybe she's responsible for my being so upset all along, maybe---"

"Yea, maybe," I mumbled, "but is she capable of such a thing?"

He put his hands over his eyes. He was in very real pain, I could see. "A.J., you okay?" I asked him. "You'd better take it easy on this----"

"I can't believe this, Rick, I just can't believe it. I know what she's done to me. I know!"

His pain got to me. I moved to him. "Come on, Kid, sit down and tell me what you're talkin' about. Have you remembered something?"

"Yes." he said, so low I barely heard him. "Vitamins, Rick."

"Vitamins?"

"I've been taking vitamins she recommended just after we got back together. And when we met in San Diego, yes, I just remembered the meeting, she gave me a new supply."

"Oh," I said.

I took him by the arm and led him back to the bed. He looked like he could faint any minute. The statements he'd made bounced around in my head. If it was remotely true what he'd come up with as a theory, then it would be difficult for me to accept. Yet, it was feasible. I needed to know more. I helped him sit down. He laid down immediately. "A.J., listen, I need you to expand on this for me. About the vitamins, I mean. Can you do that? I mean, it's not that I don't believe you, it's just that it's so unlike Janet, you know, I mean, don't you think so?"

"Yes, it's unlike her," he agreed. "But I recall the meeting now, the dinner at Mom's and everything. It's coming back, I don't know why."

"How long since you took a vitamin?" I asked.

"I forgot them," he said. "I mean, not really."

"Not really?"

"I had thought they gave me headaches, especially since I'd been taking the ones Janet brought to San Diego to give me."

I fought the urge to shudder. "Look, Kid, this is heavy stuff we're talkin' here."

"Yes," he readily agreed, "And we've completely forgotten about Brenda and what part she might have played in this."

I stared at him. "Hey! If Janet did this, then Brenda's innocent. There's no connection between them."

He shook his head. "I doubt if there is, but I don't know. And what about the guy I shot? The man who was going to shoot you?"

"Yea," I said. "What about him?"

We fell quiet. A.J. shut his eyes. There was room for me on the bed, so I laid down beside him. I was harboring a man in my cabin who was supposed to be locked in the holding tank. I couldn't put off doing something and fairly soon. "Are you awake?" I asked.

"Yes."

"Maybe you should go back to the holding tank, let me handle this. If they catch you out, and with me, we'll both be in trouble. I can explain away posing as a guard. I can say I just wanted to talk to you, but if they catch you out---"

He sat up abruptly. "Rick, have you noticed anything funny about this ship?"

A tad aggravated that he didn't seem willing to listen to me, I answered kind of sharply. "Well, I evidently was the target of two different people on it. If that's funny, then---"

"No, that's not what I mean!" He said, loud.

"What, then?"

"Rick, I'm surprised you haven't noticed, surprised I haven't, unless it just happened."

As far as I was concerned, he was talking off the wall. "What the hell are you talkin' about?"

"I think we're anchored."

A retort on the tip of my tongue, I bit it back. "What makes you think so?"

"You know what makes me think so. The same thing that makes you think so, now that you've thought about it."

I grinned at him. "I bet you can't say that again."

"Oh yea, how much you wanta bet?" he said, returning my grin in kind.

"Never mind," I said. "And, yea, now that I've thought about it, I know what you mean. Every once in a while, the ship rocks wildly and then it's quiet, just like I said a while ago."

"Only a while ago, we didn't either one think we were anchored."

"We're not supposed to be," I told him. "What do you suppose is goin' on?"

"Maybe it was so rough, Gethers took it to shore somewhere. It was rough for a while. Remember what happened to us in the holding tank?"

"Yea," I said. "It could be you're right, and it could be you're wrong."

*******************************************


A.J.---

I got up from the bed and then looked back at him. "That makes a lot of sense, Rick. I'm either right or wrong, no question about that."

"Well, you could be somewhere in between," he told me.

"Rick, we're either anchored or we're not!"

"Yea, but we may not be anchored at shore," he said. "We may be out in a harbor somewhere."

"Sure," I agreed. "Why don't you go see?"

"Good idea," he went along with my idea. "But I'm not goin' alone."

Only a short time before, he had said I should go back to the holding tank. I thought that's what he was getting ready to repeat. "Rick, I don't want to go back to the tank. I mean, there must be something else we can do."

"I didn't mean for you to," he said, grinning at me. "You're comin' with me. We might have to swim, Kid, get off of this boat. I want you with me. Maybe you meant me harm, maybe you're lyin' to me now, but I don't think so. I don't like the way the powers that be on here accepted Brenda's word, accepted mine. They didn't consider your credibility at all."

I had a lump in my throat, but I said, "Well, I was using an alias."

"Right, but they didn't question you enough. I think it's a setup, a setup of both of us. You ready to try to escape?"

"I am," I said. "But, Rick, where does that leave the Janet theory?"

"That's what we need to find out," he scowled. "They may all be hooked together. We may never get out of this alive, but I'm willin' to try."

"I am too," I told him. "But if we run into someone, if they're waiting for us, what? I mean, what if the Captain and everyone is in on it?"

"I don't know what we'll do, A.J. We don't have guns. I'm just hopin' we can swim to shore, hopin' we're anchored not far out. If we can just do that, we'll have a chance."

"It could be we're wrong about everything except Janet," I said. "I hope we are."

"Yea, but that guy you shot," Rick said. "It's just all too much of a coincidence."

I nodded. "Well, I'm ready. Good luck to us."

He grinned broadly, then hugged me in a tight embrace. "We've got good years left in us, Kid, but we've gotta get off of this tub to enjoy them. Let's go."

We left Rick's cabin cautiously, much more cautiously than we'd left the holding tank earlier. As we crept along the wall for a time, I though back to that walk we'd made to my brother's quarters. We had not seen a single soul. Had the boat been anchored then? Was everyone else aboard in on a conspiracy against Rick and me? He was ahead of me. I reached out and grabbed his arm, causing him to turn to me. "Maybe they're all gone," I said.

"Who?"

"Everyone who was on this ship. Maybe they're laying in wait for us somewhere."

I could see a multitude of ideas were passing through Rick's mind. The expression in his eyes kept changing, revealing he'd had a new thought. "Wow!" he said. "You're still a P.I., A.J. Your mind still works like one, anyway."

"I can't tell whether you think I'm right or wrong," I said.

"I can't tell whether I think you're right or wrong either, but you could be right."

"How would everyone have left the ship without our knowing it?" I asked him. "Surely, they had to make an announcement or something."

"Yea, you would have thought so," Rick said, "But maybe they have a way of not broadcasting to individual cabins."

I looked at him. "So, you think they know we left the holding tank? Know you were there in the first place?"

"I think so. Don't you?"

I sighed. "Yes. Now what?"

"We keep movin', find out if we're right about this, find out where we're anchored, find out who's waitin' for us and where, then we make a decision."

"Let's go," I said.

And so we kept walking along the ship's corridor. We came to no place where another human being could be seen. It was eerie. My skin crawled with each passing step. My brother and I did not speak for quite some time. He was the one to break the silence.

"This is weird as hell, A.J.," said Rick.

"I'll say it is. I feel like there are ghosts coming out of the walls."

He laughed his short way of expressing mirth. "Might as well check out the Captain's quarters. We're close to it."

"You think Gethers is lying in wait for us?" I asked him.

"No time like the present to find out."

We came to the door behind which we'd all been taken after the shooting incident in the dining room. Rick pulled out a credit card. I made eye contact with him, as I moved over to the side of the door. "Still opening doors the hard way, I see."

"Actually, I haven't done it in years," he frowned. "But guess I still know how."

"I wouldn't be surprised," I said, as the door opened in front of us.

We both took a peek inside. It was dark. "He might be up at the controls," Rick told me.

"No one seems to be here," I said.

"Somehow, I'm not surprised," Rick said. "Watch the door, I'll look around."

******************************************


Rick---

Moving very carefully, I walked around Gethers' humble home at sea. I could see nothing which would tell us anything one way or another. Certainly, I didn't see Captain Gethers or anyone else. A light had been left on, though, making me wonder if Gethers intended to return soon. A.J. watched me from the door. I felt naked without a weapon in that situation and felt sure my brother did as well. What I was looking for, beyond a human being, I didn't know. Until I found it. "A.J., get your rear over here!"

He came immediately into the small area where Gethers slept. There was a bunk and there were some shelves. On the shelves, in plain view, was a book. My book. "He's been reading my book," I said.

A.J. questioned me. "So? Lots of people read your book."

"And take it on cruises with them? And keep it on the shelf in their quarters? And then act like my name was one he'd never heard before?"

The last part got through to my brother. "He did say he wasn't familiar with your book or the movie."

"Yes, he did," I agreed, remembering how, during the first few minutes of the question and answer period, Gethers had asked my name. I'd told him who I was and that he might know me from my book or the movie made from it. Totally straightfaced, he said Rick Simon rang no bell with him. He had lied, evidently. "I smell a rat," I said.

"A whole ship full of rats, maybe," A.J. frowned at me. "But does Janet have anything to do with it? How would she know Gethers, maybe the guy I shot. How, Rick?"

I touched him on the arm. "Take it easy, Kid. We're gettin' somewhere now, let's not panic."

He took a deep breath. "Well, there may be some other clues here. Let's look around some more."

"Yea, good idea." I said, and hoped sincerely we could find something else to go on.

We looked in all nooks and crannies of Gethers' quarters, but found nothing more. I was beginning to wonder about something, when A.J. echoed my thoughts. "How will we ever piece this together without more to go on?"

"I don't know." I replied, being as honest as I'd ever been in my life.

"He can always say it meant nothing, his having your book, I mean. He could say he hadn't read it yet, didn't even know where he got it, that he'd read it, but hadn't paid any attention to the author's name."

I grinned at him. "You remember every excuse we ever heard in the business, don't you?"

He smiled at me. A.J. Simon has the most beautiful smile in the world. It warmed my heart to see it. He said, "I've missed being a P.I., Rick. Have you?"

I shrugged, but my eyes told him all he needed to know. I said, "Some, I guess, although I don't like to be thrown back into the game this way without the proper tools."

"I wonder if they took my gun with them when they left," A.J. said.

"We could take a look see," I suggested. "Where do you think they left it, if they left it?"

"Probably in the office of the security guys."

"Where's that?"

He rolled his eyes. "How would I know? Maybe we can see a name on a door."

"Let's go, then," I said, and we quickly left the Captain's quarters. I returned my book to his shelf before I departed.

******************************************


A.J.---

Rick and I again walked through what I now thought of as a ghost ship. Not that I wasn't leery that someone would suddenly appear, someone we wouldn't be glad to see. I didn't have much hope we would find any weapons, mine or otherwise, if and when we located the security office. Wondering if we shouldn't have checked on the status of the ship, whether not we were anchored or docked, I mentioned it to my brother. "Maybe we should go top side, see where we are."

"Maybe, but we might be seen then," he said. "I'm sure they're just playin' us along, lettin' us think we've got a chance, but no use to go out in what might be plain view so soon."

"Okay," I agreed. "Hey!"

"Yea?"

"Here's the security office?"

"So it says, anyway. Should we knock?"

"You'll never change, Rick," I said.

"You thought I had," he responded, as he once again used his credit card to open the door. I wondered briefly if that card was any good now that he was broke.

"Yes, I thought you had, but I was drugged. That's one thing I'm sure of. I feel so different now."

"Let's be grateful for that and see if we can find your gun and maybe one for me."

"Okay."

We entered the security office slowly. There was a light on there, just as there had been in the Captain's quarters. And just as in Gethers' domain, there was no one about. We began to search for weapons.

"If they left guns here, they are probably behind locked doors," I noted. "There are several cabinets."

"Yea," he acknowledged. "Let's see if any of them will open."

We began opening cabinets and drawers. Some of them were locked, some were not. We found no weapons. When we'd opened everything in sight, I said, "Well, looks like we struck out."

"I guess," Rick said, and then his eye was caught by something shiny under one of the cabinets. "Unless---"

"Unless what?"

"Unless there are guns in that secret compartment," he finished.

"What secret compartment?" I wanted to know, following his gaze and seeing nothing but a huge storage cabinet.

"That one," he said, pointing. "It looks like it's built in, but it isn't. See, there's space around it."

I moved closer. "You're right, it's portable."

We both knelt down to examine our find. There seemed to be no opening. Lost in concentration we did not hear the door open. When we did, we both reeled around. Before I knew what was happening, Rick pushed me down and then got between me and the man who had entered the security office. It flashed through my mind that this was typical behavior for my brother. Even when we were at our best at P.I. work, and I was able to fend for myself very well, instinct caused him to protect his younger sibling.

I leaned out around Rick to see who had joined us. It was Hawthorne, the man who had questioned me in the Captain's quarters earlier. "So," he said, pointing a pistol at us. "I see you two have chosen to reunite."

"You knew we would, didn't you, Hawthorne?" Rick asked him.

"Yes, we were pretty sure. That's why we left you to your own devices for a while."

I shoved out to where I was facing him as squarely as my brother was. "Would you mind telling us what this is all about, Mr. Hawthorne?"

"Yes, I would mind," he said. "At least, I don't care to tell you now. Instead, I want you to come with me. Move slowly in front of me, both of you, and then out the door. We're going for a walk."


Back to the Simon and Simon Fan Fiction page. 1