Closure

Member Comments

"I said last week that I didn't want Mulder's quest to be built on a lie. And its not...completely. The resolution to the foundation of Mulder's quest was not what I was suspecting. After seven years, actually, after all of Mulder's life, I figured no resolution would work unless he found his sister. After all these years the show owed it to Mulder. The strange thing is, that he didn't find his sister. But he did see her again. I have to say, the ending scene with Mulder and Samantha as stardust was touching. It never seems to help when a person says that "they're in a better place" but now that the whole obbsession and the angle that is Samantha is out of the Mulder persona...then he is free. It seems that because of this, he'll renew his search for the truth with a new vigor, that would be refreshing, especially with the type of episodes that have been shown this year. The religious angle was appreciated. I kept saying that I wanted Mulder to have something else to hold on to besides the belief that his sister was alive. My only problem with the whole plot was that everything in the past spoke of the fact that his sister was alive. That beleif sustained him, and us actually throughout the whole show. It seems like I've been taken off a drug now that the Samantha thing is resolved. The show is coming to an end, there's no other way around it, and that is what made me feel like crying in the end."
-Eileen A.-

"A ghost of it's former self the X-Files tries to tie up the disappearance of Mulder's sister by having her appear as an apparition? Boo. The way the ghosts in this episode were handled made me feel like hiding under a sheet and making like Casper myself. The scene where Mulder's in bed and his dead mother speaks to him as a ghost was especially silly. The acting by Duchovny and Anderson was solid. The direction of the human characters by Kim Manners was alive. The way the characters were handled in the writing was unhindered by poltergeist activity. The storyline, however, traveled the arc of it's hour long hit and miss life span only to become dead and ectoplasmic. Come on... what happened...has a seventh season specter invaded the X-Files offices...Chris Carter and Frank Spotnitz can't come up with anything better than this?"
-Michael B.-

"I really hope that this is not what really happened tpo Samatha. That sucks soo much. After all of The X-Files being centered around how Mulder is looking for Aliens and how Samantha was abducted, it would suck if she was not still alive, and if she was'nt abducted after all. Doesn't Chris Carter know that this will ruin it all. Who wants to watch the X-Files if there is nothing to keep Fox going. After all, if he's not looking for his sister, doesn't that mean that the X-Files will just end? Personally I really didn't like this. I hope it's just another one of those episodes that they never think of again, like the end and the beginning, and the one where CSM has Samantha in the car. "
-Theresa C.-

"I thought the episode was wonderful. D.D. did an excellent job acting his part. You could really feel the sense of relief that Mulder felt. Great job guys! I'm saving the rating 10 for the Mulder and Scully get together. I'm hopeful they will before the series end."
-Suzanne K.-

["Closure" Results | XFEOS Results | XFEOS Web Site | The X-Files | Dena's Home Page]

It was created and is maintained by XFEOS.

This page hosted by Get your own Free Home Page