Gary's Movie Reviews and Ratings

2003 Movie Chart

All Time Movie Chart

8 Mile

= 48 =

"Yo, hey, what up, dawg? You gotta flip that script, B, you know what Ima saying?" If you understood a word of that, then you will probably enjoy this film. Otherwise, this is simply a mildly entertaining rehash of the standard Rocky / Karate Kid fairy tale, but with rap music replacing hand to hand combat.

With that in mind, the plot requires little introduction. Washed up boxer / skinny kid / wannabe rapper (Eminem), is struggling to put his stamp on the world due to being out of shape / doesn't know karate / has stage fright. A big boxing match / karate tournament / rap battle is coming up and if he can prepare in time, he might just triumph over the heavyweight champion / local black belt bully / reigning rap king. Encouraged by aging boxing trainer / mystical karate odd job man / yobbo mates and inspired by love/lust for "girl-with-a-boy's-name-starting-with-A" Adrian / Ali / Alex (Brittany Murphy), will he overcome his demons in time? Of course, you know that he will, it's just a question of what form the victory will take and how well the audience has been emotionally prepared for it to have maximum impact.

The world's most successful and controversial rapper, Eminem, does a good job in the lead role, although it has to be said that the part of white, moody, foul mouthed, but lyrically blessed poet Jimmy 'B Rabbit' Smith is probably not much of a stretch for him. Most of the supporting cast fill their roles convincingly enough, although Kim Basinger is a little over the top and out of place as Rabbit's trailer trash mum and Brittany Murphy (previously only seen as oddballs in the likes of Girl, Interrupted) is a revelation as Alex, Jimmy's trampy pseudo-girlfriend.

The whole movie takes place in dreary Detroit (even bleaker than Rocky's Philadelphia) where the sun never seems to shine and everyone is permanently grumpy. In some ways, this film is trying to be part social commentary, with numerous references blaming 'the City' for the district's woes. But the people who will really enjoy this film are not there to ponder the causes of poverty, they want to see Eminem in action. And they are well rewarded with the rapping scenes where the man unleashes his unique style to great effect. And, ironically, herein lies one of the problems with this film. Rabbit is not enough of an underdog. Sure, he is a white guy in an agressive black community, but you know he is Eminem, and even the other characters keep raving about how skilled he is. So you don't end up rooting for him at the end the way you should - because you know he's a star - and he doesn't need your encouragement.

All in all, this is vastly superior to most films starring popular musicians. However, this is not saying much. It certainly helps if you like rap and/or Eminem, but I can't help thinking this is simply an ordinary retelling of a failsafe formula.

F.A.Q.

Home

All Time Movie Archive

Director: Curtis Hanson
Starring: Eminem, Brittany Murphy, Mekhi Phifer, Kim Basinger, Eugene Byrd, Omar Benson Miller, Taryn Manning
Date seen: 18 January 2003
Last Updated: 19 January 2003


Contact Gary at harbourboy@geocities.com

1