Gary's Movie Reviews and Ratings

2000 Movie Chart

1999 Movie Chart

1999 Movie eAwards

All Time Movie Chart

What Lies Beneath

= 77 =

As Halloween approaches, I am reminded that it really effective supernatural thrillers have been a bit thin on the ground lately. I remember the times when, as a kid, I used to watch the Sunday Night Horrors by myself on TV and get so freaked that making my way back to bed afterwards was a precarious and nerve wracking experience. While over time I may have become somewhat immune to the cliched scare tactics of horror movie directors, I have also been disappointed with recent attempts at this genre (with the exception of last year's Blair Witch Project and The Sixth Sense). But with What Lies Beneath, director Robert Zemeckis has managed to re-create the truly spooky movie and succeeded in scaring me more than I should really admit.

Michelle Pfeiffer and Harrison Ford play married couple Claire and Norman Spencer. He is a brilliant geneticist who is busy working on another breakthrough. She is the overly glamorous housewife who is dealing with empty nest syndrome after packing off daughter Caitlin to college. They live in a large house on the shores of a lake (already a bit spooky). The couple next door to them are always arguing and then one day the wife vanishes mysteriously (getting a bit spookier). Around the same time, weird things start happening to Claire when she is alone in the house; doors opening mysteriously and pictures falling off tables (getting well creepy now). Of course there is probably a rational explanation for all this, right? Well, a lot of the rest of what happens is annoyingly given away in the trailer, but in case you haven't seen this, I won't spoil things for you now. Suffice to say that things are not what they seem and it all gets pretty tense and leads up to thrilling (if not a little hokey) ending.

Zemeckis wheels out all the horror / thriller clichés: there's the mysterious things that only happen when Claire is alone, there's the slow build up to an obvious fright, there's good use of mirrors, showing us facial expressions of shock before showing the source of the fright, spooky houses, creepy lakes, creaky doors, and of course loads of haunting music. These are all tired clichés, but only because they have been so often misused. In the hands of a good director (such as Alfred Hitchcock - to whom Zemeckis is clearly paying homage), these devices can be used to guarantee goosebumps.

There isn't much in the way of character development in this movie so Harrison and Pfeiffer aren't given much to do, but as experienced professionals, they carry off their lightweight roles creditably - even if their characters are a tad annoying at times. The plot is also a little creaky with some bits that don't make much sense and other elements that are probably given away far too early.

But while the script could probably have done with a bit of resurrection, this is a minor quibble. The real measure of the success of this film for me was that I was stilling jumping at my own shadow several hours afterwards.

Superbly chilling stuff. Watch it alone at your peril.

F.A.Q.

Home

All Time Movie Archive

Director: Robert Zemeckis
Starring: Michelle Pfeiffer, Harrison Ford, Diana Scarwid, Miranda Otto, James Remar
Date seen: 23 October 2000
Last Updated 24 October 2000


Contact Gary at harbourboy@geocities.com

1