Gary's Movie Reviews and Ratings

2000 Movie Chart

1999 Movie Chart

1999 Movie eAwards

All Time Movie Chart

X-Men

= 84 =

The adaptation of a science fiction comic book to the big screen is a high stakes business.  First of all, these movies are usually expensive because of the special effects that this genre demands.  Then, in order to recoup these high costs, the movie must be targeted at a wide audience.  Comics, by their nature, appeal to a comparatively small audience (normally young males).  Therefore elements of the comic must be adjusted in order to attract this wider audience.  But the problem is, that by making these changes, the movie may end up alienating the original comic reading fans that made the idea popular in the first place.  It is a fine balancing act that often fails (see The Phantom, The Shadow, Supergirl, Spiderman).  But when it works, the payoff can be huge (see the success of Superman and Batman).  Director Bryan Singer seems to have hit the bullseye with X-Men, which seems certain to spawn a series of sequels.

The film is set in the ‘not too distant future’.  By a dubious stretch of the term ‘evolution’, mutant human beings are being born who possess an array of weird and wonderful powers.  Because they are different, these mutants are misunderstood and feared by normal humans.  In a parallel to the 20th century human rights movement, two leaders have arisen to fight the cause for mutant rights.  One is Professor Charles Xavier (Patrick Stewart), a powerful telepath who has set up a school for mutants to help them to learn to control their powers.  Xavier believes that humans and mutants can live peacefully together.  The other is Magneto, whose childhood experiences in a Polish concentration camp have taught him that humans will always be prejudiced against those who are different and therefore believes mutants must use violence in order to survive.

Key characters aligned with Xavier are Wolverine (Hugh Jackman), a broody hardman with incredible healing powers and super cool claws that shoot out of knuckles, Rogue (Anna Paquin), a young girl who absorbs the life force of people she touches, Storm (Halle Berry), who can control the weather, Cyclops (James Marsden), who shoots lasers out of his eyes, and Dr Jean Grey (Famke Janssen), who has telekinetic powers.  Magneto’s gang includes heavy Sabretooth (Tyler Mane), the froglike Toad (Ray Park), and sultry shape shifter Mystique (Rebecca Romijn-Stamos).

It may all seem a bit complicated, but the plot is deceptively simple.  The key is that it still has evidence of a rich background which is not required for the movie but necessary to provide a framework for sequels and off screen storylines (see Star Wars and Star Trek for other examples of where this has been done to great success).  For example, we get hints of some mysteries in Wolverine’s past but these are not explored fully.

Why do I think this is such a cool movie?  Well, for starters, the acting is better than you would expect for a sci-fi comic adaptation.  Stewart and McKellen provide a certain level of maturity and dignity, Oscar winner Paquin is great as the tortured teen, and Jackman is wonderfully broody and gets some great lines.  The overall atmosphere is cool, from the décor of the buildings, to the sleek black costumes (it was probably a good move to not faithfully recreate the comics bright yellow outfits).  The action scenes are thrilling.  The climax is emotional.  The movie is serious, but doe not take itself too seriously – look out for some great in jokes, including one classic move by Ray Park.  But most importantly of all, as a part time fan of the comics, I do not feel like the essence of the X-Men has been changed too much.

So this is a summer blockbuster worth a look and I can’t wait for the sequel.  If you’re a hardened X-Fan, you’ll enjoy spotting cameos from Kitty Pride and Ice Man.  If not, its still a great ride, even if you do think Wolverine and Sabretooth sound like characters out of The Jungle Book.

F.A.Q.

Home

All Time Movie Archive

 

Director: Bryan Singer

 

 

Starring: Hugh Jackman, Patrick Stewart, Ian McKellen, Anna Paquin, Famke Janssen, Rebecca Romijn-Stamos, James Marsden, Halle Berry

 

 

Date seen: 19 August 2000

 

 

Last Updated 20 August 2000

 


Contact Gary at harbourboy@geocities.com

1