Blockbuster Entertainment Awards 1997 Winner Favorite Actress - Romance for Romeo + Juliet

Blockbuster Entertainment Awards 1998 Nominee Favorite Supporting Actress - Drama for The Rainmaker

Emmy Awards 1995 Nominee Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama Series for "My So-Called Life"

USA Golden Globes 1995 Winner Best Performance by an Actress in a TV Series - Drama for "My So-Called Life"

MTV Movie Awards 1997 Winner Best Female Performance for Romeo + Juliet

MTV Movie Awards 1997 Nominee Best Kiss (shared with Leonardo DiCaprio) for Romeo + Juliet

MTV Movie Awards 1997 Nominee Best On-Screen Duo (shared with Leonardo DiCaprio) for Romeo + Juliet

ShoWest Convention 1997 Winner Female Star of Tomorrow