When I first saw the TV Guide synopsis for this one, I rolled my eyes. Figuring the teacher/student affair gone wrong came right out of Dawson's Creek, I was prepared for the worst. Instead, I was suprised that it actually worked quite well. The theme of forgiveness is strong and central to the story, which may be what saves it from being so bad. And unlike DC, the teacher/student affair is quietly, nicely done. I guess not having to see large portions of it like we did on DC helps a lot. Overall, a good effort to bring Buffy back after a long hiatus and to begin the journey to the season finale.
Final Rating: 7.5
Go Fish
by David Fury
directed by Dave Semel
Initial Rating: 7.0
The Sunnydale swim team is on the verge of going to the state championships and Synder is willing to overlook any offenses they might have. Meanwhile, the coach and the team have a deadly secret. A nice story because it makes you think some monster is eating the swim team when actually the swim team is becoming the monsters. A nice touch by Whedon to make this old plot new and interesting. We also learn a few things about Synder and gets hints that maybe he knows more than he's telling about his role as principle. Will we find out any more info next year? I certainly hope so. So far, Joss and company haven't disappointed us..
Final Rating: 6.5
The Becoming, Part One and Two
Written and directed by Joss Whedon
Initial Ratings: 8.0, 10.0
Because they share the same writer and director I am going to put my comments on this one together. Namely because if I don't I will just repeat myself. The Becoming is the perfect ending to the second season, bringing some resolution to all of the events that have gone on in the previous 20 episodes while setting up the next season admirably. There are a lot of things resolved here, so much so that the two hours literally fly by as you view them. The final fifteen minutes of each episode fly by and have you on the edge of your seat. Part two is heartbreaking and leaves you with the feeling that Buffy is going to face some major difficulties next year. A perfect coda to the season, making season two a package deal that is truly one of the best television seasons ever realized.
Final Rating: 10.0
Season Two-General Comments
The best thing I can think of to compare Buffy's second season to is the second volume in a series of novels. The season builds upon the themes, characters, relationships, and situations that we were introduced to back in season one. It's got a definite beginning, a middle, and an end. And while the major storyline of season two has been completed, Joss Whedon and company are wise enough to throw in enough interesting plot revelations and dangling threads to make this one very long, hot summer.
By the main emphasis of the season, I refer to, of course the Buffy/Angel arc storyline. Looking back on the season, it's easy to see that when Joss and company chose season two to move away a bit from the monster of the week as the emphasis and to concnetrate on this developing relationship that it was a wise, successful move. Indeed, looking back on season two, it's easy to forget that it took a long time for the Buffy/Angel relationship to take off, much less to see them actually have any real screen time in a romantic way. Indeed, there are only about three episodes that really do this, before events spiral out of control to take Angel from Buffy. Overall, I like that choice. I know there are those of you out there who like seeing Buffy and Angel together, and it did work rather well when they were together (well, except Bad Eggs, which just felt like spinning the wheels) but I think Joss and company learned a bit lesson from other such shows with great romantic tension that gave into the pressure to put the two leads together too quickly and then not know what to do with it. I think part of it this was the strength of having a setup from year one that Angel could turn on Buffy and do so in a quite remarkable, violent way. But, the thing is Joss and company had the guts to do it. Let's face it, Buffy losing her virginity to Angel and making love to him in Surprise was an emotional highpoint of the season. Many other shows could have just ended it there, allowing us to bask in the afterglow, but Joss choses this moment of happiness and joy to shatter the entire Buffy universe and change it forever. It's a fascinating choice because it was not only a change in the series' tone but also an actual change of night and timeslot as well. Honestly, I think Surpise and Innocence hit a high point for the season that I've only seen duplicated on other shows in a season finale.
It was nice to see the setup. Going back and watching the season over again, a couple of Angel/Buffy scenes jumped out at me as a good set up to this. I think seeing Angel is vampire face at the thought Buffy might be in danger during Reptile Boy saved it from being just really bad. Also, seeing the delicate dance they walked with her being the Slayer and his being a demon was nice. Spike's reaction to them was also interesting. Overall, I think there was so much lead time and set-up for the downfall of the realtionship built in that looking back on season two it's hard not to go, "Of course! That's where it's going." When at the time I had no clue where it might lead.
It's rare show where I enjoy watching repeats as much as I enjoy the first time around seeing it. But Buffy is an unusally great show.
I just hope that the accolades that are being poured on it don't go to the producers heads or cause some stars to get huge egos. I will concede that Sarah Michelle Gellar is superb as Buffy, but the episodes this year showed just how important, interesting, and vital the Scooby gang is. Add to it the tapesty of Buffy's mom, Principal Snyder, and the other recurring cast we see, and it's easily the strongest group of supporting players outside of Deep Space Nine. It's not quite DS9 level for me, but that's only because I've been with the DS9 crew for six years now. What does remind of DS9 and Babylon Five, is Buffy's willingness to have characters grow and change and to have that grow out of the events that shape them.
Once again, I turn to Buffy and Angel's relationship. In Innocence, Angel taunts her at not being able to slay him, to which Buffy responds not yet. The rest of the year sees a build up to her being ready to do just such a thing. It's a nice touch to see. I was one firmly in the camp that Angel needed to die after he killed Jenny. I understand redemption, but I also see that once Angel got a point, he had to accept responsbility for his actions. And I really liked seeing how Buffy went from not wanting to slay him, hoping she could get her Angel back to seeing that if she was to survive and see her friends make it through all the hell in Sunnydale that Angel had to die. It also made the final few moments of the Becoming, Part 2 that much more haunting and poetic. (And that Sarah McLaughlin song just huants me! I love it!)
So, it was a good season, overall. I loved the arc storyline. It gave us a reason to tune in each week and was interesting. It was truly a season of television viewing to be remembered. I've personally got all of them on tape and really found myself enjoying the hell out of rewatching the season again. Even some of the first eps that were initially a bit slow and pedestrian at the time really hummed the second time around. That doesn't mean there weren't clunkers. But there was only one that I would relegate to the category of playing in hell's waiting room-namely, Killed by Death. Now, I know there are some of you out there who will want to argue that it wasn't as bad as I initially thought. It wasn't. It was worse. Sorry folks, but it still bored the tar out of me the second time around. I was really tempted to hit the fastfoward button, which is why it ranks so low in my final season estimation. It was a waste of time and of a good hour of Buffy.
But, let's face it, there were episodes that made up for it. Ted, Suprise/Innocence, School Hard, Becoming, etc. Indeed, with only one bad episode and a lot of tens (I haven't awarded this many tens to a show in one single season in quite a while), it's hard to pick my favorite of the year. But, as I rewatched, there was one episode that really stuck out as being just barely head and shoulders above the rest. And it was Lie to Me. Simply put this is a superb episode that benefits from the fact that it plays with the Buffy vampire myth a bit by having Ford want to be a vamp. I liked that. But what really won me over was Ford's motivation to want to live forever and the final graveside converstation between Buffy and Giles. Superbly written and realized. I think if Buffy is going to win an Emmy it will be on that episode alone. It was just superb. It rose above the high standard Buffy set and easily won out as best episode of the year, standalone or otherwise. It's pretty much become the measuring stick by which I measure all other episodes.
So, it's been a good year. And I loved it. And who isn't looking forward to season three? I know I'm counting down days until the rumors come out because I'm anxious and excited. I haven't been this curious about a season opener since Star Trek: The Next Generation's, Best of Both Worlds, Part Two. Lofty, lofty company.
So, that's about it, except a few small things that I wanted to comment on.
--Where did Oz go after Phases? Yes, he was in a few episodes, but one thing that really struck me in the first part of the season was how carefully and precisely Joss and company set him up only for him to virtually disappear at the seasons' end. I understand that Seth Green might have other commitments, but now that he's a regular Buffy cast member, I expect to see him continue to grow and develop rather than being someone for Willow to sit on his lap.
--Xander and Cordy. Of all the relationship on the show, this one confuses me the most. It seems as though some of the writers like it, while others are content to ignore it having the two at each other's throats the entire story. A lot of people see them as being very much in love, but at times I don't. I can understand there is a bit of verbal sparring in every loving relationship, but I honestly think that Xander and Cordy take it a bit too far when together. I am not saying I want to see them falling all over each other being mushy, but just a bit less edge to their comments would go a long way toward selling me on this relationhip. And I need to be re-sold at this point. Unless, of course, they are setting up a triangle of Willow/Xander/Cordy next year.
--Spike was a great villain, even if he got a bit of the short end of the stick when Angel turned back to the dark side. Spike wins as best villain of the season, simply because James Masters played him with such flair. He is so easily memorable and exciting that it really worked. I hope we haven't seen the last of these two.
--As for Dru, sometimes I loved her, sometimes I loathed her. Part of me wishes that we'd see some more development of her. I'd personally love to see her convertion to vamp form and what Angel did to her. That would go a long way to explaining a lot about her. Maybe we'll see this next year. Also, does anyone see a bit of a rift that could form between her and Spike that could lead to interesting complications for the Scooby gang. Imagine a vamp conflict with Sunnydale in the middle and Buffy has to not only stop both sides but keep them from destroying Sunnydale. Interestng.
So, that's about it for now. It's gonna be a long, hot summer as I wait for new Buffy episodes. Thank goodness someone at WB heard by cries and decided to re-show season one to help tide me over. Now, if they'd just stop skipping episodes..
Final Season Rating: 8.0 (Note: This is a ratng as a whole, not an average of my review ratings!)
Copyright 1998 by Michael Hickerson. All Rights Reserved.
Back to Season Two
Main Page