KIBBUTZ: THEN & NOW

Kibbutz - a collective farm owned by its members; children are reared collectively... (Webster English Dictionary)

So, what exactly is it?
The definition by the Webster Dictionary brought here (courtesy of the Merriam-Webster), is short and even illusive. most of the "kibbutzim" (more than 1 kibbutz...) are no longer based on agriculture and farming, but rather on sophisticated industry. In most cases, children are not "reared" collectively anymore. The kibbutz has changed dramatically over the past 15 years. So, how does it look now? What kind of changes have been made? Why? This page contains a short historical overview on this strange phenomena, and a short description of kibbutz-life today.

THEN...
The conception of the kibbutz as a cooperative system of collective ownership over property and means of production was developed by the Israeli new-comers from middle and eastern europe (mainly Germany, Poland, Hungary, Bulgaria etc.) at the start of the 20th century. These guys were heavily influenced by the communist viewpoint and by the Zionists thinkers who called for a "new kind of jewish people" that will defend themselves, work its new/old land and will flourish from the fruits of their work. The basic idea was simple: each and everyone invests everything he owns and all his/her efforts in the collective, and takes back only his/her needs, as long as equality was preserved... I know, it sounds EXTREMELY naive, but hey, it was a "new kind of people"... The kibbutz ideology also induced the idea that the kibbutzim should "settle the country of Israel" and thus, the further away you got from the urban areas (at that time, Jerusalem, and some parts of the shore strip of the Mediterranean sea), the better it was.
The first kibbutz ever was Degania, established in 1910, on the southern edge of the Sea of Galilee. Conditions were extreme. Lots of the settlers suffered malaria, typhoid and other disease, as well as attacks from the arab population. The collectivity was also extreme. one was not even allowed to have a personal knife and fork, and fierce debates took place over the issue of marriage, and whether a 'kibbutznik' is entitled to have his "own" woman (and vice versa: the kibbutz female members were equal to men in everything)... in short, it wasn't a walk in the park to be a 'kibbutznik' those days. Children were considered to be part of the property, and parental gestures were discouraged severely. The kibbutz, in general was non-religious, and let alone a few religious kibbutzim, still maintains this agnostic line. Kibbutz members were not paid for their work, since they were the owners anyway; instead, they got food, residence, and other utilities from the kibbutz, in equal shares; everyone got the same house (or room, as it is still referred to in most of the kibbutzim. In practice, it was actually a tent, or a stone-house with one room). showers were public. meals were served in the dining-hall, at no charge. Yes... those were the days...
A lot of changes took place over the years. First to go was the "private property" prohibition. It probably started with a "private" coffee pot, or a "private" tablecloth... (clothes, mind you, were public! you were not allowed to have your own private clothes.) By the mid-seventies, you could own your private stereo system, and by the mid-eighties, most of the kibbutzim already allowed the purchase of a TV set. since the eighties, most kibbutzim started to move the kids from the "children houses" to the family-homes. When I was growing up during (until 1983 or so), children were sleeping in a special "children-house" and spent most of the days there, studying, doing some recreational work (we had a small 'zoo' we took care of), and so on. We went to our parents 'rooms' for only 4 hours, roughly from 4 pm until 8 pm, when we returned to the children house to sleep. My sister, who was born in '76, was living with my parents since she was 10 or so, and the whole system of the children houses was abolished completely in my kibbutz (Yakum) by 1985.

Kibbutzniks had always been evaluated in Israel as very reliable, resourceful, and honest people. Educated in their own kibbutzim, they were considered good soldiers (very important in Israel), and devoted workers, who will treat the workplace as part-owners, do whatever is needed and worry about the money later. They are also considered to be 'snobs', 'lefties' socialist by nature, and naive. There is much more to be said about the kibbutzim, historically and socially, but this is only my private (yes, private) overview, and i'd humbly guess that if you read that far, you'd probably got the idea by now. so we can move on to the introspection commonicativa: ...NOW



about me            back to main

1