Star Wars: The Phantom Menace

Reviewed by: Pincher Martin

May 23, 1999

Return

The Phantom Menance is the most boring movie I've seen in some time. Please whatever you do, don't go support that trash with the purchase of a ticket, or God forbid, the purchase of Star Wars merchandise for your sons and daughters, nephews and nieces. The critics were properly vigilant in their reviews: as many reported, there was not a single interesting character in the movie, except for Darth Maul, and he had so little screen time that it's hard for me to know if he was an interesting character or just mercifully underexposed in this colossally dull movie.

Unlike some here, I enjoy Hollywood movies. I don't have a Mondaugen-like abhorrance of happy endings or other schlockish devices so common in Hollywood movies. I would much rather watch a movie like "Dances with Wolves" or "Braveheart" than "Affliction" or "Fortune Cookie". When judging movies, I ascribe to Clint Eastwood's philosophy: You can kill me, rape me, mutilate me, but whatever you do, don't bore me.

Unfortunately, TPM does just that. The plot and characters were both so uninteresting that when one major character dies near the end of the movie, I barely stifled a yawn. Even the computer generated effects, much praised by many reviewers who otherwise trashed the movie, were overrated. As I said above, the one major point of interest for me, Darth Maul, was destroyed at the end, thus probably simulatneously destroying any reason for me to return to see episode two.

 

1