BILLBOARD - THE BEAT - UNEARTHED TAPES YIELD A NEW TREASURE by Dave DiMartino
"Nine of Swords" is absolute must listening for anyone who has ever been moved by Nick Drake.
Through an unusual set of circumstances, Appel obtained several hours of tape containing various unfinished Drake compositions from Drake's parents, Rodney and Molly, and was given their blessings to "complete" the works. The result, frankly, is one of the best albums to be released this year.
"Nine of Swords" contains four songs by Drake, including the previously unheard "Bird Flew By", "Our Season" and "Far Leys" (which Appel has "embellished from a lost Drake original", according to the liner notes, and thus co-wrote), along with a version of "Place to Be", from Drake's eerie PINK MOON album. The cassette and CD throw in two additional tunes, including the gorgeous "Blossom" - again, never before heard - and "Parasite", also from PINK MOON
Furthermore, Appel's own originals, which incorporate Drake's unique guitar tunings, merge seamlessly with the Drake material after repeated listening and sound wonderful.
"Nine of Swords" may not be a new Drake album, and it may not be an amazing simulation - but whatever it is, it's the next best thing and very much worth hearing.
ADDITIONAL REVIEWS
CD REVIEW Feb. '96
Scott Appel - NINE OF SWORDS
The recent renaissance of interest in the work of melancholy English troubador Nick Drake has resulted in a few pleasant upshots, one being Scott Appel's inspired unearthing of rare and unrecorded Drake material.
Originally released in 1989, this sadly overlooked reissue includes six Drake tunes (along with some originals) rescued from undue oblivion, even giving two tracks, the lovely "Bird Flew By" and the brisk "Our Season", their first-ever release. Appel captures Drake's textured and shimmering acoustic guitar style and enchanted vocal delivery so well you can practically hear the songwriter rise from the dead and strap on his guitar. Drake worked in unusual, often difficult tunings and Appel, a stylist in the manner of Fahey and Kottke, has obviously worked hard at getting a grip on Drake's technique. His effort was worth it. Even on a tune like Appel's own "Silent Snow" the spirit of Drake lives in the vibrancy of the stringwork, and in the saddened soul of Drake's complicated arrangements.
The only drawback here, is that the New Jersey musician has invested himself into someone else's work. Sure, I'd rather hear just about anyone perform Nick Drake material instead of their own. Who wouldn't? But until Appel takes his own material in his own direction, I'll have to save higher ratings for an original artist.
GUITAR PLAYER Nine of Swords March '96
The quiet, melancholy brilliance of English songwriter Nick Drake was silenced in 1974 when he took his life by an overdose of anti-depressants, but his legacy of breathtaking alternate-tuned fingerstyle acoustic passages and haunting melodies lives on in his four records - Ryko/Hannibal has released them all as a box set - and in Scott Appel's lovely tribute album. Appel deciphered the odd tunings and cool syncopations and recorded lush versions of several of Drake's tunes, along with several of his own, written in a complimentary but not slavishly copied style. The results are stunning: Not only does Appel thoroughly understand the musical materials behind Drake's lost gift, but he captures the sensitivity and articulate romanticism that makes Drake's music so appealing.
BORDERS Nine of Swords Jan. '96
British guitarist Nick Drake delighted fans with his mysterious guitar playing and innovative tunes. Drake died at age 26 in 1974, but a growing cult of fans has kept his music and memory alive.
Lincoln Park native and musician Scott Appel is one of Drake's most fervent candlebearers in America, where Drake is not widely known. "Nine of Swords" recently rereleased to a wider audience, is Appel's homage to his guitar idol.
For Drake fans, this album is a godsend. Appel rescues two early Drake songs from oblivion and reworks a number of the guitarist's instrumental pieces. Appel is even bold enough to share writing credit with Drake on "Far Leys", in which Appel fused together a number of Drake instrumentals.
He also mixes in his own originals, like the melancholy "Blur" and "Somnus", with Drake covers to create a powerful continuity of music.
Appel does a wonderful job of capturing Drake's beckoning and sorrowful guitar work on "Place To Be" and "Our Season".
However, the album is targeted toward fans of Drake. The newcomer can easily get lost in the endless harmonics and dreamy guitar strains of much of the music.
BRITTLE DAYS review by Bob Nutbein
From the Morning:
This version is very true to the spirit and the style of the original - in this case highly commendable. Scott's acoustic guitar picking is excellent, accomplished and adroit: punctuated by intermittent percussive thumps and, toward the end, some nice bells. This is probably my favorite track so far. His voice is clear and conducive. Even if you didn't know the original, you could soon grow to love this. The structure actually builds, too - the track ending in a gorgeous swirl of instrumentation. (Appel also writes the sleeve notes: an intelligent and memorable piece entitled "A Soul With No Footprint".) Excellent.
Hazey Jane:
Appel's second waxing here, and once again it is evident that he is a truly fine acoustic player. This is actually an admirable reproduction: accomplished picking with a tastefully understated electric lead. Fine stuff. (I wonder, however, whether I like this so much principally because it is such a close replication of Nick's guitar style.)
L.A. TIMES - Anthony de Curtis
Since his death in 1974, English singer-songwriter Nick Drake has attracted a cult following, but his dark, powerfully romantic ballads have rarely been covered. Now Scott Appel, a N.J. guitarist of impressive skill, offers "Nine of Swords", an homage to Drake that includes versions of six of Drake's songs, including two that were previously unreleased. The result is a moving example of an artist realizing his own vision by honoring the achievement of a master. Drake devotees will not be disappointed -- nor will anyone else with a love for music of transcendent intensity.
BILLBOARD - Nine of Swords - by Chris Morris
Magnificent album by New Jersey-based guitarist/vocalist contains Appel's versions of hitherto-unknown songs by late U.K. folk giant Nick Drake and some equally impressive originals. Stellar picking and singing will appeal to Drake's enthusiasts, fans of fine guitar work, and even far-looking new age aficionados.
NORTHCOAST VIEW - Nine of Swords - Alan Olmstead
Scott Appel's Nine of Swords offers a moody otherworld of acoustic guitar and voice. Cast as a tribute to and an extension of the work of the late Nick Drake, Appel does justice to his mentor. The unique brittle melancholy and tragic sense that permeated the work of Nick Drake (he took his own life in 1974 at age 26) has never before been so closely duplicated. Molly and Rodney (Nick's parents) unearthed a number of Drake's early unreleased demos and compositional sketches, which Appel has expanded and re-recorded along with his own material. The result is a very special addition to the genre.
Ironically, the recent advent of "New Age" and "New Acoustic" idioms would undoubtedly have embraced the unorthodox tunings and modal talents of Nick Drake. But by definition, a true artist is always ahead of his time. It's our loss that we cannot find way to support artists on the leading edge...and our gain that other artists like Scott Appel won't let us forget
STRANGE THINGS ARE HAPPENING (UK) Scott Appel - Nine of Swords
As a kind of postscript to our NICK DRAKE piece elsewhere in this issue, we would like to focus your attention on an interesting item. SCOTT APPEL is a Nick Drake soundalike, but with a difference. Not only does he sing almost like Nick, the arrangements and guitar style are very close. Six Nick Drake songs are included amongst his own, with no less than four previously only ever heard by Nick's immediate family and taken from priceless demos in their possession. One instrumental track (a Scott Appel original) is superb - called 'Thanatopsis' it has the orchestral sound, feel and structure of FIVE LEAVES LEFT and is a major work. This is fascinating, and something which all of Nick Drake's devotees will want to hear.
EAST COAST ROCKER - Indie Report - Scott Appel - Nine of Swords
Appel seeks here to carry on the intricate, acoustic-guitar-based folk/rock tradition of Nick Drake, a virtuoso musician who died of a drug overdose in 1974. Drake specialized in unusual tunings and chord structures on his three albums for Island, released between 1968 and 1972.
The songs featured on NINE OF SWORDS are Appel's completed versions of unfinished Drake compositions, which the New Jersey-based musician obtained from Drake's parents. The results are consistently intriguing and often moving. This is a must for those fascinated by the seemingly endless possibilities of the guitar, and also should appeal to more adventurous fans of New Age.
FOLK ROOTS (UK) SCOTT APPEL - Nine of Swords by Stella Washburn
Strange, strange. Appel's last album GLASSFINGER showed an overt reliance on the works of Mr. Kottke, and no-one was at greater pains to point this out than Appel himself. On reading the liner notes (and suppressing the odd guffaw), we find that this year's model is the late Nick Drake: so much so that, with the help of Drake's parents and some unfinished demos and work tapes, we have two 'new' Nick Drake songs, one guitar piece put together by Appel from fragments, and "Place To Be" from PINK MOON. Oh, and five originals.
Scott Appel certainly has got the Nick Drake guitar style off well, no small feat, and the two new tracks "Bird Flew By" and "Our Season" fit into the Drake canon easily - jazz/folk guitar and moody vocals accompanied by everything from citterns to rock bands; lyrically, the songs are dreamlike and very personal, and therein may lie a quandary: much of the continuing appeal of Nick Drake [boxed sets and the like] is the relationship of the records to his sad, short life, and this mild necrophilia is hard to shake off. Without wishing to denigrate Appel's labor of love, I'm sure that most Drake fans/completists would want to have the original demos, even in poor condition (obsessives are funny that way).
That said, and saving the points raised for another time when the magazine needs a filler article, the combination of cover versions and originals shows Appel to be a more sensitive and lyrical player than his debut suggested; quite New Age in the recording, which also goes to show how much that 'movement' owes to such as Drake. The longer Appel pieces, SOMNUS, NINE OF SWORDS and the sole bottleneck track BLUR create a dark fantasy world, a landscape hanging in the wind...oops, those liner notes are getting to me. In slightly plainer terms, NINE OF SWORDS is a long, slow album with a rather late '60s feel (relaxing and yet, somehow...intense); the breadth and versatility is impressive and a big step forward from the first record.
Hate the liner notes and find the cover doesn't do any favors, but like the album. One nagging question remains - who next for Scott Appel? Barrence Whitfield? Napalm Death? Tanita Tikaram?
BUSCADERO (Italy) SCOTT APPEL - Nine of Swords by Mauro Quai
It's as surprising to find a guitarist like Scott Appel singing the songs of Nick Drake as it is to find myself on this 'Good Friday' writing a review of the strange and delicate "Nine of Swords". I don't know why Drake's music in general, (or perhaps it is just this situation), reminds me of certain characters from the films of Pasolini. Pasolini, a man strongly tied to our land, Friuli, depicts men or boys crucified under tragic circumstances, who in the end become martyrs of a society both unjust and absurd. Perhaps it was the emotion of the moment, due to the great love that I, like many others, have for Drake and his ethereal music, but this record awakens old memories and sensations from a time when a writer could simply be a listener, rather than one faced with the "serious" task of judging a record as a critic.
Scott Appel, with this, his second album, (the first was "Glassfinger", KICKING MULE), has revealed himself to be both an artist and instrumentalist of exquisite taste. The alternation of skillful instrumental passages, as in the workmanship of "Somnus", "Blur", "Nine of Swords", "Thanatopsis", and "Silent Snow", with compositions by the unfortunate Nick, including the splendid, unpublished "Bird Flew By", and other pieces: "Far Leys", "Parasite", "Blossom", "Our Season", "Place To Be" offers pleasant discoveries for both writer and listener, with an abundance of arrangement and care. A superb and delicate recording.