QUESTION: Why are desires always from the lower self?
ANSWER: I certainly did not say that. On the contrary, I have shown clearly that there are also proper and very important constructive desires. (Maybe I misunderstood) You overheard it. You will see when you read this lecture. (But how can we tell if a desire comes from the higher or the lower self?) By examining the desires and their real motives you will be able to differentiate. Clearly and concisely, ask yourself this question: "What is it that I want and why do I want it? What is my real motive behind it?" You see, it is often like this. You may have a right desire with a good motive behind it, but at the same time there is also -- notwithstanding the good motive -- an impure motive in it as well. The moment you recognize this, then you have already done something for your purification. Purifying does not mean merely that you are already perfect, but the process of becoming perfect is already purification. It is an integral part of this process to say: "In addition to my good motive, there is also a selfish motive or a vain motive hidden under this good cause." By saying this to yourself, you have already purified yourself to some extent. To illustrate: A person may be spiritually active, having clean and pure motives to help other people. These good motives certainly exist. Yet, at the same time, the desire current of the lower self mingles in -- perhaps the ego or a vanity to be outstanding, to be admired, to be an authority. When the mixture of the motives is recognized by you, calmly and freely, then it becomes a purification process. With such an act, you have raised your consciousness to a pretty high degree. This is so merely by the recognition of it, even if you are as yet incapable of shedding the impure motives. Something in the chemistry of your body and of your soul begins to change with such clear a self-recognition because you approach the truth. The most severe and the most frequent violation of spiritual law -- one that is mostly overlooked by human beings -- is living in truth. When I say that, then you imagine that I mean that you should not lie. I do not mean that at all. It is self-understood that a person should be honest and should not lie. Lying to oneself is often infinitely more dangerous and more harmful than lying to others. Why do I say more dangerous? I say this because when you lie to others, then at least you are aware of it and you know it. Thus you are a step nearer to being in truth than when you lie to yourself. When you lie to yourself, then you do not realize it. This is not because you cannot, but simply because you do not want to do so. Thus you are completely away from the truth. And that is a grave violation, setting you apart from God. That afflicts you with a dark wall behind which you must be unhappy, for you are then involved in the outer conflicts that this must create for you sooner or later. Behind this wall you are lonely and lost. The only way you are able to find the light is by tearing down these walls and viewing what is behind them, even if it is unpleasant. The first moment you do this is a fight. But after you have decided to do so and after you have torn down the first few stones of this wall, the relief will be tremendous. For the first time you will know what it means to be on this Path. You will know that in the last analysis this manner of work, and nothing else, is what counts.
QUESTION: Does that mean that whatever we want to do we always have to ask God if this is all right with Him? Do you have to see whether or not it does not deviate from God's law?
ANSWER: I would suggest it be done this way. In the first place, when you are on this path, then you should take an inventory of your own person, as I have often suggested. In order to find out who you are, you must do the following. You must seek your faults; you must seek your qualities or your virtues; you must also seek what you want, what your desires really are. When you have done all that and you begin this constant process of the daily self-analysis of your feelings, then you will automatically get to know in what respect you have deviated from divine law in your emotional currents. Sometimes when you discover the nature of a deeply hidden desire, you will know at once that this is contrary to God's will, even without any special metaphysical knowledge. In other cases, you may have to probe a little deeper and separate the clean motive from the impure one in the same desire current. You can seldom find an answer by viewing the issue in question by asking yourself whether the action you contemplate is right or wrong. None of you would ever consider committing an anti-social act or a sinful act. Therefore, the decisions you are faced with could be right either way in principle. For each individual there is only one right way and many wrong ways possible. So you have to consider your dishonest motives behind the apparently good motives. In other words, the motives that determine the right action or the wrong action for you and not the ethical value of the action itself. As long as you have not found all the motives of the respective desire, then you will not be able to know the right action for you. The right procedere is NOT to ask God to simply let you know whether you should do such and such, thus avoiding the effort and the work of self-knowledge on your part. There may be isolated instances where this can be the right thing to do, but not in general and not when there seems to be a pattern and a conflict involved. The right procedure is to decide wholeheartedly that you wish to find the motives behind the motive, and for that you should pray for God's help. Then He will help you. Is that clear? (Yes.) So the question remains: Find out your real motives. This does not mean that the motive which is on the surface is annulled. The other part that mixes in has to be found and then you will have the answer.
Copyright 1958 by Center for the Living Force, Inc.