QUESTION: How do you determine which is an artificial need and which is a natural need?
ANSWER: Let us suppose that you discover a need to gratify your vanity. You know perfectly well that this is not a necessity for living. One can live very well without this. However, such a discovery cannot and should not be used to moralize with yourself and to try to force the need away. This would only lead to further repression. It it necessary for you to find out why these needs exist. You are bound to find that a real and healthy need has been starved and that the artificial one has taken its place. The fact that certain needs are false should not be accepted just because I say so. The best way to determine the real need from the false need is to consider what the fulfillment of the need brings to you and to others.
QUESTION: What about a strong need for harmony?
ANSWER: In itself it is a healthy need. But if it becomes so strong that in order to gratify it, you forfeit, for instance, your equally healthy and equally legitimate need for self-assertion, your need for independence, your need for success, your need for happiness, and your need for fulfillment -- all of which require a healthy fighting spirit -- then there is something wrong that is most harmful for you. You cling to the need for harmony, thus violating another essential part of your being, resulting in repression, in discontent, in anxiety, in a sense of failure, and in a sense of self-contempt. This is often exteriorated onto others. As long as your need for harmony does not interfere with other needs and you are capable of occasionally relinquishing your need for harmony in order to gratify your other needs, then everything is fine. Only you can be the judge of whether or not this is so. In your further self-finding you are bound to determine this -- and then you can go on from there.
QUESTION: When you touch upon these deep roots, when you are able to recognize what causes this complete twist in your psyche and how it manifests in many areas and then this area becomes very rampant, you become ill and you fight to survive this. How do you combat the severe reactions when you really get to these twists?
ANSWER: When there is such a strong reaction -- such a negative experience -- then something in you still fights against giving it up. This means that a part in you still believes that its existence provides you either with some advantage or with protection. Instead of forcing it away, you should set out to find in what respect you believe that an advantage exists for you in maintaining the twisted condition, and in what way you believe, in some part of your being, that its absence will be a disadvantage of some sort. Your battle -- manifesting in your severe reaction -- is partly due to trying to force it away without understanding the irrational belief of advantage versus disadvantage. As long as such understanding is lacking, then you must experience an extreme anxiety, because the twisted condition has a function in your erroneous unconscious belief. So set about finding it and your battle will cease.
QUESTION: When you begin to realize this deep frustration, this deep aggression you have, which is caused by your neurosis, you become ill before you are aware of it on a conscious level. You unconsciously escape in many ways by not facing the very thing in you which you feel destroys your whole structure. Once you do recognize it, then it does go away to some degree, but then something else even deeper comes up, and you escape once more into this same illness. This is my problem. How do you break this pattern of escaping even into illness?
ANSWER: You mentioned that something even deeper comes up. In this instance, it is the answer of why you battle against giving up the sick, the erroneous solution -- whether it is illness or anything else that offers you an escape. As I said before, the imagined advantage of the false solution pushes to the surface, but the personality is afraid of facing it. Thus, the same process of overcoming resistance has to be gone through again. In this process, it often appears that one finds the same elements over and over again. It is the spiral movement of evolution and of development. As you proceed in this way, you will become aware of the escape and the resistance at the moment it manifests, while previouly you found it only retrospectively. Such synchronization is the only indication of true progress. The negative manifestations do not vanish after having been discovered just once. They will reappear again and again, as you observe them at work, with shorter and shorter intervals between occurrence and discovery, until the two synchronize and then finally vanish. This is the spiral that becomes narrower and narrower, until finally ending at one point. Ignorance of this process often causes distress because you may believe that you have relapsed, and this makes you even more impatient, even more frantic, and even more hopeless. But your understanding of this will enable you to relax and to observe further, so that answers which are still hidden will come to the fore. These answers not only make it easier to narrow the gap between the wrong reactions -- which derive from the negative condition and its subsequent manifestations -- but they will lead to finally giving up the twisted, damaging defense mechanism. Do you understand?
QUESTION: Yes, but it just seems so endless.
ANSWER: No, it is not endless. The spiral movement becomes smaller and narrower, as I just said. But there finally comes a point when a change occurs within, almost as though by itself. A new reaction pattern becomes noticeable, which you started almost unknowingly, as it were. This is the result of a long struggle. But if you do not let up -- and if you go through the seemingly discouraging repetitions, each time finding the same thing anew -- then you will finally experience this automatic, spontaneous new reaction. It is never a forced and deliberate thing. If it is, then it is not genuine.
QUESTION: For instance, when you have a recognition that you cannot be satisfied with second best, while knowing this to be immature and unrealistic, but I can't feel different. It is impossible.
ANSWER: In this case, too, there is an underlying reason missing. You have to accept the fact that this distortion spoils things for you, rather than bringing you advantages. The more you observe and understand this, the sooner you will find that you maintain it because the child in you believes that it will provide you with more happiness. Only the calm observation of which is true and which is not, of which is more advantageous and which is not will finally enable you to relinquish and therefore to change. This change, too, will come as if by itself. The observation of this process -- the understanding of why the psyche retains it -- will produce results, whereas battling against it forcefully will not.
QUESTION: Besides the psychological approach, is it not true that prayer and turning to God, asking for help, is of great assistance to us?
ANSWER: The psychological approach is prayer in action. If you really analyze what happens here, then you will find that in all the distortions that you first find, then acknowledge, and finally understand -- but without self-moralizing -- you do the best thing you can possaibly do to purify yourself. The so-called psychological approach is not in contradiction to the spiritual approach. Of course, prayer is of help and is to be recommened. But I have to give you more than advocate prayer. And you have to do more than merely pray for help. You have to observe your attitude in prayer. This is a deep and subtle thing. If when you pray you find the hidden attitude that you expect God to do it all for you, then your approach to prayer is not only unconstructive, but it also indicates a deeply rooted wrong attitude about life and about your role in it. If you pray for help, but with the realization that you have to do it, that you have to face yourself and eventually change due to full understanding, that you have to want to see the truth, that it depends on your efforts and on your willingness, then prayer is useful -- provided this full intent exists in you. There is a fine distinction between this healthy and right attitude, and the false idea that you just sit and then wait for God to do it all for you. The latter kind of prayer will do no good whatsoever.
QUESTION: But the spiritual approach which you have taught and which has added so much to the psychoanalyitical approach -- I was just wondering?
ANSWER: I discussed in this lectures why it is healthy and good for you in this particular phase of your development to put less stress on the so-called spiritual and more emphasis on the so-called psychoanalytical. For us, it is all one and the same. They are merely different facets, different aspects, different approaches, and different ways to the same end. Emphasis on the spiritual maintained too long and at the expense of such self-finding only leads to escapism and to the false religion I discussed recently. It leads to the wrong concept of God. When you re-read this lecture, then you will understand what I mean. The idea that you neglect God by not discussing Him is utterly untrue. The idea that by focusing your attention on your distortions so as to be able to change them would lead you away from spirituality is also utterly untrue. Common sense will tell you so. If such vague ideas exist, then they could be due to the fear of first digging up and then changing what wants to remain hidden. It may be the expression of a childish hope that merely by speaking about God, about the spirit world, and about its laws you will be able to change without pain and without discomfort. This cannot be done. Further intellectual understanding about spiritual factors would not induce an inner change. But what you are doing now on the Path is bound to bring about an inner change that will bring you closer to true spirituality than all the words you hear in the world from religiour teachers, no matter how true and how beautiful they are. An outer belief is one thing, the inner capacity of living these beliefs is an altogether different question. It takes a great deal more time, more effort, and more pain to achieve the latter. Unfortunately, this is neglected by all religious denominations and by all societies. They still deal merely with the thinking process, which often contradicts and conflicts with the real inner life, the life of the emotions.
December 10, 1961
Copyright 1961, 1978 by Center for the Living Force, Inc.