JUDGING SHEETS

The Judging forms were obtained from the organisers of the RMIT Band Comp, and the comments and scores have been decifered and transfered here for your enjoyment. The originals are unavailable for viewing here because of memory restictions, but can be obtained by emailing the band.

Originality of Material

• Judge 1: Emphasis on lyrical content, at ecpense of tune. Lyrics funny, stream of consciensness - not planned. Undefinable. Score: 22/30
• Judge 2: Interesting variety. Good try to save a bad situation by changing guitars. Score: 18/30
• Judge 3: Some Good Ideas Score: 20/30

Musicianship

• Judge 1: OK. Not extended. Humour derived from bad tuning, playing. Undefinable. Score: 20/30
• Judge 2: Keep working at it. Score: 8/30
• Judge 3: Became very chaotic at the end. Score: 15/30

Stage Presentation

• Judge 1: Fun, having a good time on stage, and obviously amusing Score: 18/20
• Judge 2: <No Comment> Score: 5/20
• Judge 3: Some of the antics were very distracting Score: 8/20

Audience Response

• Judge 1: V. Good, brought their fanbase with them, seemed to win over the audience Score: 8/10
• Judge 2: Good to see that your families came along. Score: 6/10
• Judge 3: <No Comment> Score: 5/10

Recording Viability (Prospects)

• Judge 1: The act was more visual and would lose impact if recorded. Score: 4/10
• Judge 2: <No Comment> Score: 2/10
• Judge 3: <No Comment> Score: 6/10

TOTAL

• Judge 1: 72/100
• Judge 2: 39/100
• Judge 2: 54/100

Average Scores

• 20/30 Originality of Material
• 15/30 Musicianship
• 10.333/20 Stage Presentation
• 6.333/10 Audience Response
• 4/10 Recording Viabilty
• 55/100 TOTAL

Analysis of the Results leads one to conclude that RPN is a live band with ground breaking music because of it outstandingly original material. Well that is what I see in the results.

(Most of the scores were scribbled over to save hurting our feelings, but we were able to make most of them out.)

Back to RPN Home Page