Every month, the players and crew will vote on the best of each category. We'll come up with the categories and someone (probably me) will make awards. Here are a few examples.
Obviously, this worked better when the game was SSS and a season 4 game. However, I'm using it for examples' sake. Geez, people! :-D
Well, let's say that we had new romances starting (like Buffy and Xander), and Xander did a really awesome job at it. Everyone could, theoretically, be up for this one.
This doesn't have to be your usual triangles, like this one. It could be Spike/Buffy/Angel, or Willow/Giles/Oz, or whatever. But all of the people in the triangle would win the award.
Of course, there are more. We would have best performance: male, best performance: female, best villain, etc. But I just wanted an incentive for the players.