Not That Sane. V Lakshman. Every Wednesday.

Imagination and its disabuse (June 11, '97)

A few weeks ago, I had the misfortune of watching a documentary on Charles Darwin and, consequently, photographs of the naturalist before he left for the New World. My impressions of Darwin were formed mostly by reading books about him, his theories and a few excerpts from his works. I imagined him as a cross between Michaelangelo's God (in his Ascent of Man -- wise, ageing, bearded) and the stereotypical British colonialist (stocky, dressed in khakis). The documentary disabused me of that imagination -- Darwin, if you are interested, was bald, clean-shaven and dressed like a pastor.

Television and the movies have a tradition of such disabuse. If you have ever watched a movie of a book, not necessarily a classic, you know what I mean. I read Scott Turow's Presumed Innocent before I watched the movie and was sorely disappointed by the casting of the defense attorney, Sandy Stern. In my imagination, he was suave, charming and the consummate foreigner. In the movie, he came across as a hustler.

Television and movies, by relying on a thoroughly visual medium, simply get in the way -- there is very little that you can imagine when it is right there, in two dimensions, in front of you.

A friend to whom I propounded this theory had a ready answer. "Even reality interferes, I suppose," she said, "with your imagination." If I were sane, I would make friends who were too dumb to deflate my hare-brained theories.


Archive of previous columns
Non-technical writings
What is: Not That Sane
Lakshman (homepage) or email me at: lakshman@nssl.noaa.gov 1