Not That Sane. V Lakshman. Every Wednesday.

Polling a Tamil movie (May 6, '98)

For a long time, Tamil films have been a good barometer of the mood and tastes of the people. Even though they are dismissed by the elite as escapist entertainment, movies have always resonated with the general population. In the 1950s, movies were optimistic about the direction of the country, but by the 1980s, they had come to potray politicians as wicked, the police as venal and bureaucrats as insensitive and corrupt. That was right in sync with what India, as a whole, felt.

It is debatable whether movies direct the popular perception or whether it is the other way around. However, when movies are made about subjects you know about, they give you an opportunity to find out what the general public believes.

The first half of a Tamil movie that we saw in Dallas recently was shot in the United States -- the grandmother of the heroine needs brain surgery and decides to get it in America. It is very likely that the opinion of Americans and Indians in America that the movie potrays is shared by folks back home.

So, how is the potrayal? Not very flattering to Indian immigrants. Every American (of whatever origin) potrayed in the movie has a sense of fairplay and respect for law and order. The only incidental role that has an Indian immigrant is extremely unflattering; the immigrant attempts to bring the class heirarchies of Indian society into a discussion of whether a surgeon had erred. Going by that movie, then, the general perception in India is that the emigrants inevitably coarsen life wherever they land.

As I said, not very flattering.


Archive of previous columns
Non-technical writings
What is: Not That Sane
Lakshman (homepage) or email me at: lakshman@nssl.noaa.gov 1