Subject: Domesticated elephants
The Nation
March 14, 1998

      "Release elephants

      back to the wild" - expert

      by JAMES FAHN

      RELEASING domesticated
      elephants into natural forests
      would be ''the ideal solution'' to
      the problem of unemployed
      pachyderms, according to one
      expert, but it could prove
      dangerous to surrounding
      villagers.

      ''Thailand is probably the only
      country in Asia where returning
      elephants to the wild would be
      feasible,'' said Richard Lair, a
      consultant to the UN Food and
      Agriculture Organisation (FAO).

      ''Wildlife sanctuaries in
      countries such as Sri Lanka and
      India are under a great deal of
      pressure, but in Thailand there
      are conservation areas where
      wild elephant populations have
      been extirpated, or where a bull
      elephant can be introduced to
      prevent inbreeding.''

      But Schwann Tunhikorn,
      director of the Royal Forestry
      Department's (RFD) Wildlife
      Research Division, warned that
      tame elephants returned to the
      wild may end up encroaching on
      crop lands or injuring people
      because they no longer fear
      humans.

      Three ageing domesticated
      elephants were re-introduced
      into a wildlife sanctuary in
      Phayao last year, said
      Schwann. ''We are waiting to
      see how it turns out,'' he added.

      Schwann and Lair, who wrote a
      book for the FAO entitled Gone
      Astray: The Care and
      Management of the Asian
      Elephant in Domesticity, took
      part in a panel discussion on
      Thursday along with Suvit
      Yodmani, president of the Asian
      Elephant Foundation of
      Thailand, which focused on the
      plight of domesticated
      elephants.

      All agreed that the situation
      looks grim for Thailand's
      estimated 3,800 working
      pachyderms, most of which no
      longer have any work, and the
      country's roughly 1,500 wild
      elephants, who are suffering
      from poaching and a loss of
      habitat.

      ''With the decline of the logging
      trade in Thailand, the only viable
      work left for elephants here is
      tourism,'' Lair said.

      The worst kind of abuse from
      tourism occurs when baby
      elephants are separated from
      their mothers at too young an
      age, but this practice no longer
      seems common in Thailand, he
      said.

      Many mahouts take their
      charges to Bangkok, where the
      animals must brave hazardous
      conditions to solicit money from
      passers-by.

      Amid concerns about the
      beasts' health, authorities have
      tried to banish them from the
      city, but that has not proved an
      effective solution.

      ''Bringing elephants into
      Bangkok is horrible and wrong,
      but preventing that has simply
      spread the problem elsewhere,''
      Lair said.

      Attempts to set up sanctuaries
      for elephants have also proven
      difficult to put into practice, Lair
      said.

      Another hindrance to a solution
      is the status of domesticated
      elephants under Thai law. A bill
      passed in 1939 treats them as
      draft animals, and is almost
      solely concerned with the rights
      and obligations of ownership.

      Schwann said efforts are now
      being made to amend the
      legislation.
  1