Sixteenth
South Carolina
C.S.A.
"Ervin Batson and the Crippled Brigade
versus
The "Gentle" Republican Occupation"
Sixteenth
South Carolina
C.S.A.

Corporal Ervin Batson
Company C
Sixteenth South Carolina
"Good Old Rebel"
Music by Dayle K.


Greenville, S.C.
May 17, 1869

Honorable C.P. Leslie, Land Comissioner.

Dear Sir:

We respectfully beg leave to submit for your consideration a plain statment, founded upon fact, and with an honesty of purpose, ask the attention to its merits. In fighting the battles of the South, we thought we in the right path of duty, and as her sons were needed at the front, did not hesitate to place ouselves firmly in ranks. Consequently, we are now without an arm, a leg, or otherwise maimed for life, have our wives, little ones and widowed mothers to support in our feeble way, and as a democratic, moneyless, landless set of men, we appeal to know if in the distribution of lands in this State, under your supervision, we are to be remembered.

If favored with a reply, it will ever be considered a kind favor and acknowledged with the sincerest respect,

By Yours Truly,

Jordan Batson
Joseph Brookshire
J.F. Bramlett
Lefus Vaughn
Ervine Batson


In 1869, Ervin Batson, Jordan Batson, Joseph Brookshire, J.F. Bramlett, and Lefus Vaughn all applied through this letter for relief under the land acts of the Radical Republicans. All of these men were destitute and crippled, victims of the war. The Land Commissioner chose to publish the petition and his response to that petition. All of it, including his rather cold and sarcastic response may seem very reasonable, especially to those of "the bottom rail on top" mentality. It is the kind of response revisionists would point to as equality for all under Radical rule.

The only problem was seven years later in 1876, when Hampton was elected these men had received nothing more than this very public response and the embarrassment of having been exposed as destitute. One, Joseph Brookshire, at least figured out how to improve his lot in life. He was elected to State office on the Hampton ticket. So much for equality under the radical Republicans versus equality under the Democrats. When majority rule returned, it was under the hand of the Democrats and the second half of the War Between the States ended.


Mr. Leslie's Reply

June 23, 1869

To Messrs. Jordan Batson
Jos. Brookshire
J.F. Bramlett
Lefus Vaughn
Ervine Batson
of Greenville, S.C.

Gentlemen:

Your letter addressed to me at Blackville reached me, after considerable delay at Charleston.

You say you fought bravely as Confederate soldiers, and you thought you were in the path of duty. I doubt not that you acted honestly, as I certainly did in contending against you, and I respect you for your courage and frankness. You say: "Consequently, we are now without an arm, or leg, or otherwise maimed for life, have our own wives, little ones and widowed mothers to support in our feeble way and are a Democratic, moneyless, landless, set of men."

I sincerely regret this, and I must express surprise that at the close of the war the Confederate owners in your county of large tracts of land, the half of which they never cultivate, did not personally provide land for each of their soldiers. You were urged by them with glowing promises of lasting honor and large reward; a cause in which you periled life in place of them or their sons. The least that honor or gratitude suggests to me would be a free gift of a small tract of land to every poor, of at least to every disabled Confederate soldier. But perhaps it is useless to ask or hope for even this easy, proper, and cheap, recognition of "valor in the lost cause."

And then you say you are "Democratic, landless men." Do you remember that when the bill to provide for the distribution of lands was before the Legislature, every Democrat seemed to scout the idea of helping the common people to lands and homes, voted squarely against the bill at every stage? Surely, as Democrats, neither they, nor you, can claim anything.

But in general legislation, the Republican Party considers not Confederate soldiers, not Democrats, not Republicans, but citizens. In elections we contend for our men and our principles; -the election over, we act in public measures according to our principles - for all the people. The homestead law, the law relating to mechanics liens, and the law relating to lands were passed for the benefit of all, and particularly the working men.

Meeting you in this broad Republican spirit, I am ready to consider you not as Democrats, nor as Confederate soldiers, but as "landless, moneyless men" sincerely deserving to avail yourselves of the opportunities now for the first time presented in this State. I am ready to do the best I can for you and for all anxious to go up on a little farm, make it their home, and to labor and economize to pay for it.

In seeking for such men I shall not be restricted by "race, color, nativity or previous conditions." This year I hope to put a considerable number of families on lands of the State. But this is simply a beginning. Next year I hope to put a larger number, and the year succeeding a number still larger, and so on until by this means, and by other means, every frugal and industrious man, white or colored, in the State, who wants a home enough to work diligently and faithfully for it, has one; until the Palmetto State is dotted with small productive farms, her waste places built up, and her cites and villages teem with a busy and thriving population.

"In this hope and with this earnest purpose, I am gentlemen, very respectfully and truly yours,

C.P. Leslie
Land Commissioner




This information is taken from
A History of Upper Greenville County
By Mann Batson

This book is available through the author at the following address in softback only. Cost is $23.00 plus $3.00 shipping and handling or a total cost of $26.00. The book is over 600 pages in length and is an excellent history of the mountains. It is the first of three books written by Mann Batson on life in the highlands of Greenville County prior to 1900.
203 Love Dr.
Travelers Rest, S.C. 29690




Follow General Gist to Aftermath Index, or follow the Flag to the Main Index.

1