"Times change and men change with them" is an expression old, very old. Another institution of the old day that has gone, let us hope forever, is the sectarian debate. The nineteenth century saw the debate on doctrinal lines at its very highest cre
st. It was possibly in the forties that the Brownlow-Payne debate occurred at Lexington, Ky., with Henry Clay as moderator. The "Harry of the West" was equally at home at a horse race or doctrinal debate! Mentioned without regard to chronology, there w
ere the Graves-Ditzler debates, etc., these being among the "siege guns" of the denominations, while all over the country bobbed up debates among the "light weight" exponents, each bent upon not only saving his creed from demolishment but actually setting
it triumphant upon the ruins of all the others. The last forensic battle of this kind having anything like a just claim on public notice, occurred at Slate Springs, Miss., about 1900, a fitting though weak climax to a sort of semi-intellectual-emotional
vagary that had to run its course. Man is said to be a creature capable of development on five distinct lines--mental, moral, physical, social, spiritual, to which I would like to add on occasion, financial. The two debaters wound up the series of word
-battles, the people went home each muttering to himself "I told you so!" A case of "Ephraim is joined to his idols, let him alone." The debaters set out for Eupora to take the train. At the depot they arrived at the "meat of the cocoa-nut--the publish
ed debate and the division of the proceeds! Here they differed radically--almost staged a Kilrain-Sullivan affair, boarded the train and the curtain was rung down on sectarian debating.
Return to Reminiscences of Smithville
Return to Index page