McFadden is given a room in the White House, a communal house with Arthur as its 'warden'. Hubert sees this as preferential treatment to the newcomer, who in his eyes also has a cushy job. McFadden feels uneasy and inadequate about this situation, so when he comes across the other men building a
stockade for the sheep while out on his wanderings, he takes off his jacket and attempts to lend a hand. They refuse his offers of help however. When he picks up his jacket again, he finds something is missing from the pocket.Hubert had taken his chance to go through McFadden's pockets, and has found something of great interest. It is a newspaper cutting. He takes it to Charles in the hope that either McFadden will be asked to leave, or that he can
wangle a room in return for his silence. McFadden also comes to Charles to complain about the theft however, so the story comes out into the open anyway.
They gather to hear McFadden's story. He had been in a prison/hospital when the death struck, and after recovering himself had led a secluded existence in a cottage he had found. He had been in prison for murdering a child - it was this that the press cutting referred to. He had killed the child in a fit
of anger, because she had been frightened of him, and he couldn't understand why.
He believes that the months he spent alone after the death have helped him to come to terms with the crime, and his illness, and that he is now cured. He wants to be with people again.
They decide to let him stay, and Ruth believes that he is cured and represents no danger. Hubert is angry at this, and Greg threatens him not to spread rumours around the community before
everyone has had a chance to hear the official story.
However, Hubert decides to spread a little poison anyway. He tells young John to beware of McFadden, and to run away if he ever talks to him.
Later on, John is playing in the woods, when McFadden spots him. He playfully leaps out from behind a tree, meaning no harm. John looks up at McFadden with terror on his face, and runs away. McFadden looks very confused, and makes his way after John...
Arthur comes
across McFadden back in the White House. He is packing to leave. He has decided he wants to live alone again - he'd hoped that the death would have changed people to be more helpful to one another, but all he has found is bickering and jealousy.
Lizzie is worried when she can't find John. She reports back to the adults. When Arthur arrives, announcing McFadden's departure, they draw the obvious conclusion.
They go after McFadden and bring him back to
the settlement. He tells them the story of what had happened, admits he couldn't understand why John was so frightened, but claims he didn't touch the boy. John is still missing as night falls.
McFadden is kept in the kitchen of Charles house, with a person watching over him 'for his own safety' - he is used to this situation. Greg and Ruth discuss what should happen. Ruth (having not been involved in the Barney affair) thinks their only course of
action is to let McFadden go, as whether he is guilty or not, they have no facilities to keep prisoners. Greg agrees - he doesn't want to go through another murder trial. He decides to let McFadden go at first light, without telling anyone else.
They leave at dawn, Greg promising to see McFadden safely away from the area. As they pass the quarantine quarters, they see John standing in the doorway. His flight the previous day had taken him out of the
settlement, so when he returned he had assumed he had to go into quarantine, and had gone straight there!
McFadden still decides to leave. Charles is annoyed that Greg didn't consult him about letting him go.