Reconciliation

The Theology


of Rev. Keith H. McIlwain


Theology is a field which covers that which is most vast in our universe...the concept of God. It is therefore more than slightly arrogant for pitifully limited humankind to pretend to define the precise nature and limits of God. I certainly shall not try, as all systematic theologians, as noble as they are in their attempts, have failed. It is appalling when folks on the "left" disavow doctrine as being only of historical importance, and not truly living; it is equally appalling when those on the "right" feel that they have figured it all out and can neatly "box in" God and the fullness of the gospel.

My theology is basically derived from the fourth century Nicene period viewed through the historical lens of John Wesley, the founder of Methodism and the father of contemporary evangelical theology. It was during the fourth century that integral concepts such as Atonement, Incarnation, and Trinity were first grappled with by the whole Church, and it was in the eighteenth century that Wesley began the renewal of the Church, a movement which necessarily continues to this day.

I have found the so-called Wesleyan Quadrilateral to be very useful in theological reflection. The Quadrilateral, derived by the great Methodist scholar Albert Outler from Wesley's works, views a four-point method of theologizing, with Scripture, Tradition, Reason, and Experience in dialogue searching for the Truth that is the gospel of Christ.

There are variations in the Quadrilateral, with different theologians emphasizing different points. Process thinkers and charismatics, for example, tend to emphasize personal Experience; "High Church" thinkers tend to emphasize the Tradition of the Church; proponents of Protestant Liberalism generally begin with personal Experience and human Reason.

I alternately view the Quadrilateral in two ways. Normally, I view it in hierarchical fashion, with Scripture as the most important element, Tradition as second, and Reason and Experience battling it out at the "bottom"...all are important, but some are simply more essential. I also view the Quadrilateral as explained by my colleague/teacher George Tutwiler, who supports an "umbrella" view in which Scripture covers the other three points, which are in constant interplay but clearly subordinate to the Holy Bible. Both methods have been useful for me.

As previously stated, I find systematic theology somewhat arrogant. This site is not an attempt to define the boundaries of God or even my conception of God, or, better put, God's revelation of himself. I tend to distrust labels in theology as they can be extraordinarily misleading and counter to the Mission of the Church, but I will use them here in reference to myself to better define this site. I would consider myself an evangelical moderate (some might say "evangelical left"), firmly rooted in the evangelical tradition that is at the heart of Methodism.

I have recently become impressed with the label paleo-orthodox, a term defining a movement led primarily by United Methodist theologian Thomas Oden which seeks to reground contemporary theology in the consensual classic Christian sources. That seems to describe me quite well.

It is incredibly important to the mission of Christ in this world for every Christian to be able to worship with other Christians with whom they may disagree; if it truly is Christ who holds the Church together, how dare we adopt any other stand.

May God use this page to spark dialogue and growth in Christ, and perhaps even to lead some to a knowledge of Christ Jesus the Lord.


BIBLICAL & METHODOLOGICAL FOUNDATIONS:

Holy Bible,
English Standard Version™ (ESV™)

World Wide Study Bible New Testament Translation (John Wesley)

About English Bible Translations

Early Church Fathers
(absolutely essential material)

The Articles of Religion & Confession of Faith
of The United Methodist Church

Explanatory Notes on the Holy Bible (John Wesley) The Wesleyan Quadrilateral in Wesley (Albert Outler)

The Nature of Wesleyan Theology (J. Kenneth Grider)

Wesleyanism & the Inerrancy Issue (J. Kenneth Grider)


CHRISTOLOGY:
Jesus Christ, the Incarnation of God:

The Christ Hymn (Philippians 2:5-11) Colossians 1:15-23

The Emmanuel Prophecy (Matthew 1:18-25) John's Prologue (John 1:1-18)

On the Incarnation (St. Athanasius) Second Paschal Oration (St. Gregory of Nazianzen)

Placing Christ at the Center of All (Maxie Dunnam) The Governmental Theory of the Atonement (J. Kenneth Grider)


CREEDS:
(some are denominationally-oriented but all are useful)

The Shema (Deuteronomy 6:4-5) Romans 10:9

Nicene Creed Apostles Creed

Athanasian Creed The Shield of St. Patrick

Definition of Chalcedon A Brief Creed by John Wesley

United Methodist Social Creed Barmen Declaration (German Protestant Churches, 1934)

A New Creed (United Church of Canada) A Christmas Creed (Ormal Miller)

A Brief Statement of Faith (PCUSA, 1983) An Education Creed (Keith H. McIlwain)

Union in Christ (PCUSA, unofficial, 1999) A Church Action Creed (Leonard Sweet)

A Wesleyan Confession (Karen Covey Moore)


ECCLESIOLOGY & CHURCH HISTORY:

Catholic Spirit (John Wesley) Of the Church (John Wesley)

On Attending the Church Service (John Wesley) The Marks of the True Church (John Calvin)

Preamble to the Constitution of The United Methodist Church

Do I Really Need to Study Church History? (Thomas Oden)

A Church Action Creed (Leonard Sweet)


ESCHATOLOGY:

1 Thessalonians 4:13-18 1 Corinthians 15

Immortality of the Soul or Resurrection of the Dead?
(Oscar Cullmann's masterpiece on the subject)

On the Resurrection (Justin Martyr)

The Millennium: A Wesleyan Interpretation of the Doctrine of Eschatology (George Lyons)


ETHICS & SOCIAL ACTION:

United Methodist Social Creed United Methodist Social Principles

McIlwain Sociopolitical Links

John Howard Yoder
(the 20th century's leading ethicist)

The Politics of Jesus (John Howard Yoder)

The Power of Nonviolence (J.H.Yoder) The Morality of Surrender (J.H. Yoder)

Nevertheless: The Varieties and Shortcomings of Religious Pacifism
(John Howard Yoder)

Resident Aliens: Life in the Christian Colony
(Stanley Hauerwas & William Willimon)

Unleashing the Scripture: Freeing the Bible from Captivity to America
(Stanley Hauerwas)

Wesley�s Principals for Social Action (Frank Baker) The Tonto Principle (Stanley Hauerwas)


FREE WILL & "PREDESTINATION":

Nine Questions (James Arminius) Discussion on Predestination (James Arminius & Francis Junius)

Analysis of Romans 9 (James Arminius) On Predestination to Salvation (James Arminius)

The Remonstrants A Biblical Concept of a Just God (Robert L. Brush)

On Predestination (John Wesley) What is an Arminian? (John Wesley)

Finding God's Will (Anthony Campolo) On "Eternal Security" (Gordon Olson)

The Believer's Conditional Election (Daniel Corner)


THE HOLY TRINITY:

On the Trinity (John Wesley) The Trinity is One God (Boethius)

The Trinity (Alister McGrath)


JUSTIFICATION / SALVATION / SOTERIOLOGY:

McIlwain site on the Atonement

Justification by Faith (John Wesley) Salvation by Faith (John Wesley)

The Scripture Way to Salvation (John Wesley)

The Governmental Theory of the Atonement
(John Miley)

Why the Satifaction/Punishment theory of the Atonement is Wrong
(John Miley)

The Governmental Theory: An Expansion (J. Kenneth Grider)

Substitution in Suffering (John Miley) The Atonement (Daniel Steele)

Salvation: God's Provision, Man's Need

A Brief Introductory Sketch of the Grotian Theory of the Atonement (Frank H. Foster)

Analytic Testing of the Penal Substitution theory of the Atonement (John Miley)

The Atonement as a Factor in Divine Government (S.R. Fiske)

The Atonement (Albert Barnes) The Atonement (Dean Harvey)

Historical Opinions as to the Nature of Christ's Atoning Death (Gordon C. Olson)

The Philosophy Of Law And Grace (Kel Good) Therefore Choose! (Jonathan Duttweiler)


ASSURANCE of SALVATION:

The Witness of the Spirit, Part 1 (Sermon #10)
(John Wesley)

The Witness of the Spirit, Part 2 (Sermon #11)
(John Wesley)

The Witness of Our Spirit (Sermon #12)
(John Wesley)

Questions of Clarification for Wesley's Doctrine of Assurance
(Michael Lodahl)


METHODIST / WESLEYAN SPECIFICS:

United Methodist Doctrinal Standards

The Articles of Religion & Confession of Faith
of The United Methodist Church

The Wesleyan Perspective
(a marvelously concise summary)

Bibliography of Wesley Resources

The Methodist Middle
(a pretty fair assessment of where I am right now
within United Methodism)

What a Time to Be Wesleyan! (David McKenna) What is an Arminian? (John Wesley)

John Wesley for Today (Bishop Earl Hunt)


THE SACRAMENTS & CHRISTIAN WORSHIP:

1 Corinthians 11:23-29 The Duty of Constant Communion (John Wesley)

"Do This!":
The Eucharist as a Key to Pastoral Care & Church Renewal

(Keith H. McIlwain)

"Do This; Remember Me!"
(an original hymn text based on the Gospel Eucharistic narratives, Keith H. McIlwain)

By Water and the Spirit
(official United Methodist statement on Baptism)

This Holy Mystery - PDF file
(official United Methodist statement on the Eucharist)

The Book of Common Prayer
(the finest liturgical resource in history)

We Are What We Sing (our hymnody reveals our faith)

John Wesley's "Evangelical" Theology of Infant Baptism (Stephen Blakemore)

The United Methodist Hymnal (1989)
Click to view online edition Click here to purchase a copy

United Methodist Book of Worship (1992)
(official liturgical resources)

Reaching Out Without Dumbing Down: A Theology of Worship for the Turn-Of-The-Century Culture
(Marva Dawn)

A Royal 'Waste' of Time: The Splendor of Worshiping God and Being Church for the World
(Marva Dawn)


SANCTIFICATION / PERFECTION / ORTHOPRAXIS:

A Plain Account of Christian Perfection (John Wesley) A Serious Call to a Devout & Holy Life (William Law)

The Imitation of Christ (Thomas a Kempis) The Practice of the Presence of God (Brother Lawrence)

The Rule of St. Benedict (St. Benedict) Matching Our Walk With Our Talk (Kenneth Cain Kinghorn)

Holiness for a New Millennium (John Oswalt)

The Wesleyan Option for the Poor (Donald W. Dayton)


I will be "filling in" this page with more precise details.

I encourage prayerful reflection, comments, and dialogue.

Links to other sites on the Web

Return to my homepage

THIS PAGE IS A WORK IN CONTINUAL PROGRESS!

last updated 12 May 2005

� 1998 / 1999 / 2000 / 2001 / 2002 / 2003 / 2004 / 2005 mcilwain@penn.com

2 Timothy Banner


This page hosted by GeoCities Get your own Free Home Page


1