There are many myths about the crime of rape, which affect the way the Survivor views herself and is treated by society. It is, perhaps, the only crime of violence for which the Survivor feels responsibility and guilt. One lingering myth, is that rape is a sexual crime, which the Survivor asked for and secretly enjoyed. This is nonsense! No matter what circumstances led up to the attack and subsequent rape, no one ever "asks" to be raped, or to suffer the accompanying degradation and long term emotional effects. Further, profiles of convicted -rapists show that the perpetrator usually experiences no enjoyment of the sex act, but only rapes as an expression of violence to degrade the Survivor. Another myth is that the Survivor should never fight against her attacker. Every rape is different. Fighting can be appropriate or foolish. Submission may be the best course when the rapist is armed with a weapon. However, the Survivor's best defense is to maintain control of the situation, because the rapist, whether a sick or angry person, usually wants to overpower the Survivor both physically and psychologically. The Survivor may try to catch the rapist of off guard, by reacting differently from the rapist's expectations. She should use her imagination. Unless she is fighting for her life, she may go along with the assault until she can see a chance to safely react. The Survivor should go along attitudinally, not sexually. Whatever she does, if it does not help her, she should make sure it does not harm her. By thinking creatively at the time of the attack, the Survivor might extricate herself from the situation and contribute to the rapist's arrest and conviction. Weapons, such as a nail file, rat-tail combs, or tear gas, are often ineffective for the simple reason that they are usually in a purse or bag and not immediately available. The best defense against assault is the study and continued practice of physical defense. The time and money spent is well worth the effort. Society's attitudes about rape do seem to be changing. The police, hospitals, attorneys, and courts are generally more sensitive to rape Survivors than in years past. For instance, today the past sexual history of the Survivor is not normally admissible in evidence during a rape trial. Precautionary Measures A woman should not have to fear for her body and life every time she goes somewhere alone. Realistically, however, women can and should protect themselves from rape by adopting some of the following suggestions. The greatest precaution is simply the use of common sense. At Home
In Town
In the Car
The Emotional Aftermath of Rape Rape traumatizes both the Survivor and her husband or partner. Rape fosters physical and emotional reactions in all Survivors which continue long after the immediate danger has passed. All rape Survivors share certain feelings about themselves and those around them, but the degree to which an individual experiences the emotional reaction varies. A Survivor can take steps to lessen the effect and shorten her recovery. Recovery comes from regaining control over her life and from receiving support and understanding from family and friends. Rape Survivors not only experience difficulties in sleeping but have nightmares and feelings of rage, of shame and of loss. Many Survivors experience fears of being alone and of being around men, and have difficulty with present and future sexual relationships. Often, family, close friends and lovers are not able to deal with the rape, which directly affects the Survivor. Usually rape Survivors resolve their feelings in six to eight weeks, in either a positive or a negative manner. The Survivor can make a positive resolution by communicating with people who understand the nature of the problem, who care about her, and who want to assist her in her resolution. Professional Counselors Are Available To The Rape Survivor Today, the emotional and physical reactions of Survivors of the violent crime are better understood than a few years ago. The rape Survivor has unique crisis symptoms which respond best to early crisis intervention techniques. It is imperative that Survivors immediately use the available community mental health counseling, advocacy and family/friend support. The crisis intervention counselor's goal is to help the Survivor focus on the help she needs, her future decisions, how to protect herself, and how to take positive control over her life. Sexual Assault Survivor--Counselor Privilege A Survivor of sexual assault, whether or not a party, has a privilege to refuse to disclose, and to prevent another from disclosing a confidential communication between the Survivor and a sexual assault Survivor counselor. Evidence Code Section 1035, et seq. A "confidential communication" means information transmitted between the counselor and the Survivor necessary in providing counseling, including the Survivor's prior or subsequent sexual conduct, the Survivor's opinions regarding sexual conduct and the Survivor's reputation in sexual matters. Advice given by the counselor on potential court testimony is not protected. Recommendations In addition to seeking medical help after rape, the Survivor should be aware of:
The Rape Crisis Syndrome Although some Survivors do not experience this syndrome, an awareness of its symptoms may help to guide those who do. The stages of rape crisis syndrome are: Primary Crisis Stage (the rape experience through the following 24 hours). The most common physical reactions are: o coldness, clamminess, numbness (shock);
The most common emotional reactions are:
Note: The emotional reactions appear to be most acute with Survivors who did not know their assailant, or the reason for his attack. Many Survivors who did not see or cannot identify the rapist experience an unfocused fear of all unknown persons and noises--probably because they could not "identify" their assailant. However, rapists are not always "strangers"; they are often acquaintances, friends, neighbors or relatives. Secondary Crisis Stage (second day through sixth week) The most common secondary reactions are:
Note: The inability to reason her way out of these reactions and feelings can be frightening. The professional counselor has techniques to help the Survivor work her way through this crisis experience. Third Stage (post-crisis adjustment, sixth week on) Some reactions may remain, but if the Survivor has had help, the rape will no longer be the only thing on her mind. The rape no longer dominates her life, and she will begin to feel more like her "old self." If her crisis continues past eight weeks, then she may need more intensive help. Emotional Needs Of The Survivor During Court Procedures Questioning, identification and testifying can emotionally drain the Survivor. Many Survivors find it difficult to see the rapist again, to recount their story many times, and to relive the experience through testimony. Many police agencies assign a female officer trained in sex crime investigation to interview the Survivor. The district attorney's off ice has deputies trained to deal with rape cases and Survivors. If a Survivor needs additional support, advocacy services are available. The service may include counselors who give Survivors emotional support during interviews at the district attorney's office and during court appearances. Supportive friends and family can help during this time. The Survivor should not be afraid to ask for support. Finally, many women feel depression, anger and fear if the rapist is not found guilty. For some women the decision to report the rape, assist the police, and participate in the trial seems to help in dealing with such feelings. Emotional Needs Of The Survivor's Male "Significant Other" Although a great deal is known about the trauma of the rape Survivor, along with ways to help her cope with her crisis, it seems little is known about the effects of rape on the Survivor's male "significant other" - husband, boyfriend, brother or father. By describing the impact upon men, it is hoped the issue of rape will be regarded as a joint concern of both women and men, as well as a community and societal problem. Studies dealing with the male's ability to deal with rape and its consequences theorize that the affected male, like the assaulted female, undergoes his own rape trauma." Because his trauma is obviously less severe than the female's, it is often overlooked or suppressed in the rush to aid and comfort the rape Survivor. However, it is important to recognize the male rape trauma syndrome and, if necessary, provide appropriate individual or "couple" counseling. The rapidity with which the female rape Survivor recovers from her attack largely depends upon the level of emotional support she receives from family and friends. If her male partner cannot handle her crisis, then the situation worsens. Common symptoms of male rape trauma include guilt, rage and resentment. The degree to which a male partner suffers rape trauma, and his capacity to provide the Survivor with emotional support, turns on his definition of rape. For instance, whether a man regards rape as a crime of sex, a Survivor-precipitated crime, or a violation of property rights has a direct bearing on his ability to accept its consequences. In the event his wife or girlfriend has been raped, the man should recognize that he has different, often conflicting feelings which he must acknowledge to her. Even if he feels totally frustrated and helpless, and incapable of dealing with the situation, he can at least admit that fact -- along with declaring his love and support. That attitude will help to ease the immediate crisis. How The Survivor Can Help: Preserve The Evidence If the Survivor decides to report the crime, she should do so immediately. The sooner the Survivor reports a crime, the more likely the rapist will be arrested and prosecution will be successful. In addition and perhaps more importantly, an immediate report is often considered corroboration of the complaint's validity. While waiting for the police to arrive, it is essential that the Survivor:
By not washing or cleaning, the Survivor preserves important evidence. Without this evidence, it is difficult to prove in court that a rape occurred. When the Survivor's testimony is supported by objective evidence, then rape will be conclusively established. What The Police Need To Know Immediately When the Survivor calls the police emergency number, a dispatcher will request the following information:
The dispatcher immediately sends an officer to the Survivor's location and broadcasts the assailant's description to the rest of the patrol force, alerting them to be on the lookout. The Survivor can ask to speak with a female officer. The police make every effort to assign a woman to the case. Frequently, though, the first report of a sexual assault is taken by a member of the patrol division on duty in the area. These uniformed officers can respond rapidly to the call because they are constantly on patrol throughout the community. The officer will question the Survivor about the assault and obtain further information about the assailant. Unless the Survivor prefers to give a complete statement at this time, she will not be asked to discuss intimate details of the assault. Evidence Collection The police officer will want to know the location of the Survivor and the rapist, particularly at the time of the assault. An evidence technician skilled in handling and evaluating crime scenes will search the area. S/he will look for fingerprints, hair, blood, seminal fluid, bits of clothing, and any other indication of the assault. This is why it is crucial not to wash after the rape. The Survivor can greatly assist the officer by pointing out where the assailant was, what he may have touched, and any other physical evidence she noticed. Other Important Help The Survivor Can Give The Survivor may be too upset to recall details immediately following the rape. Once she is calm, she should try to remember as much as she can about the rapist and exactly what happened when he attacked her. It is important for the Survivor to try and remember:
At her first opportunity, the Survivor should write down everything she remembers about the attack. She may have already given information to the police, but as she concentrates, something new may come to mind. Writing down everything will help her if she has to testify in court. Advice For The Survivor Who Is An Illegal Alien Illegal aliens afraid of contact with police or other authorities may fear reporting sexual assault. Questions about citizenship, legal or parole status, are never asked of Survivors of violent crimes; but if the authorities learn of the illegal alien's status during the investigation, the information could be used in a deportation proceeding. The Follow-up Police Investigation Many police departments in the county and the sheriff's department have personnel especially trained in investigating the crime of sexual assault. An investigator assigned to the case will contact the Survivor within a few days after she reports the crime to the police. The Survivor must work closely with the investigators to help them apprehend the rapist. The Survivor may request a female investigator. The Interview With The Sexual Assault Investigator The detective will ask about the force and threats the rapist used against the Survivor, as well as any weapon the rapist used or said he would use. The detective will also ask her to recall anything she said or did to resist the rapist. These details help to establish that the Survivor did not agree to the sexual act, and help to prove the legal elements of the crime in court. If the assailant was the Survivor's former boyfriend or if she knew him, she may be asked the nature of that relationship and if there had been similar attempts in the past. The Survivor will not be asked questions about her sexual history except as they relate to the rapist. A significant percentage of women are raped by men with whom the Survivor has had some form of prior contact, however slight. Thus, the rapist may not be a total stranger. The Survivor will not be asked if she enjoyed the assault or had an orgasm. The detective will also ask questions about what happened before and after the rape. The Survivor must be candid and precise. She should not omit any details, even if she feels they weaken her account because in actuality this may not be the case. However, if she has doubts about the appropriateness of some questions, she should ask the reasons for them, or refuse to answer them without the advice of her counsel. The police officer should be able to explain the reason for every question. Photographs of Injuries The Survivor should report any cuts and bruises she received to the doctor (see Chapter IV on hospital procedures) and the detective. The detective may ask someone to take pictures of the injuries. Usually bruises do not appear for several hours and photographs can be taken later. This evidence may be extremely important after the cuts and bruises have healed and can no longer be seen. The Survivor does not have to consent to have the pictures taken, but she should know that such physical evidence can be very helpful to her case. Pictures Of Rapists (Mug Shots) The detective may ask the Survivor to identify the rapist from a picture. She will view mug shots of several men to try and identify the man who raped her. The rapist's appearance may have changed considerably from the time the picture was taken and the Survivor might be unsure if the picture is of the rapist. If the Survivor is asked to identify the rapist from mug shots, she will be asked to pick him out of a group of photos of men with similar characteristics (e.g., racial, age, coloring, etc.). The photos will be saved by the investigating officer for use at trial. The Polygraph Exam (Lie Detector Test) Polygraph examinations of Survivors are rarely used; and if so, only when the Survivor's credibility is questioned. The police may ask the Survivor to take a polygraph examination. She does not have to agree to take it, but it may be advantageous to do so. A polygraph machine measures various bodily functions such as heart and breathing rates, and blood pressure. The polygraph expert will ask some neutral questions which have nothing to do with the rape, and some questions concerning the rape. The amount of change in the heart rate, breathing rate, and blood pressure indicates the truthfulness of the answer. Positive results from a polygraph exam can strengthen credibility. The Arrest Of The Suspect If the Survivor knows the rapist or has identified him from mug shots, the police can arrest him as a rape suspect. The detective may also find a suspect based on other evidence that the Survivor or others have given, such as a license plate number or description of his car. After the police identify a suspect, they normally obtain an arrest warrant signed by a judge and based on information supplied by the Survivor and the detectives. The police use this warrant to arrest the suspect. The Line-up After the suspect's arrest, the detective may ask the Survivor to look at the man in a lineup of five or six men. During the lineup, the detective asks the men to turn and be viewed from all sides. This gives the Survivor a chance to concentrate on each man and to compare him to the other men. If she wants the men to do or say something that might help her recall how the rapist looked or sounded, she should tell the detective. Although the Survivor will be in the same room as the men, the lighting is arranged so that they will not be able to see her. If the Survivor is asked to identify the rapist in a lineup, she should be sure to pick him from a group. The Investigator's Report The sexual assault investigator will write a report, and if the assailant is identified, the report will be sent to a deputy district attorney. He/she then reviews the report and determines if there is sufficient legal evidence to bring a criminal charge against the suspect. Juvenile Suspects If the suspect is a juvenile, the rules for an arrest different from those for an adult suspect. The Survivor should ask the detective or prosecutor about any special juvenile procedures and if she will need to attend hearings and give testimony. Survivor's Rights The Survivor Has A Right To Have A Report Taken If a peace officer refuses to take a report of a crime, s/he may be disciplined, according to local regulations which require a crime report. Sometimes, the crime's circumstances tend to disprove the occurrence of a reported crime. But the officer should still make a report, including in it those circumstances which dispute the crime's occurrence. Subsequent investigation should resolve the issue. A separate matter is if the Survivor inaccurately describes the crime that occurred. For instance, if the circumstances indicate sodomy and not "rape" as the Survivor stated, then the officer should make a crime report of "sodomy." The Survivor's inaccuracy should not detract from the reporting process. The Survivor Has A Right To Know The Status Of Her Case An amendment to Government Code Section 6254 (f), effective January 1, 1977, requires local law enforcement agencies to inform Survivors of violent crime of witnesses and statements relative to their case. The Survivor should call the appropriate agency to find out if the case if under investigation, or has been completed. If the case has been completed, (i.e., a disposition made), then the Survivor should be able to find out the disposition, as well as the circumstances and reasons for it. The Survivor Has A Right To Register A Complaint If She Is Dissatisfied If the Survivor is dissatisfied with the outcome of the case, either because no report was taken, or the case was not investigated or was dismissed, then she has a variety of remedies. The Survivor may complain to the Internal Affairs Division of the local law enforcement agency or to the district attorney. Also, she could notify the county board of supervisors or the city council depending on whether the reporting agency was the sheriff¹s office or the, police department. The Decision To Press Criminal Charges The criminal justice system on occasion may not seem to be supportive of the rape Survivor, because a criminal prosecution is not brought for the benefit of the Survivor. It is brought by the district attorney to convict and punish a rapist. Some women do not have an unpleasant courtroom experience, but in any case, much time and energy are required. A woman may be made to feel that she is somehow responsible for the rape, and she must relive this trauma in the courtroom. Many women decide not to press charges for fear of retaliation, while some do not believe that jail is the answer to rape. Some women do not want the rape and their personal lives examined in court. To compound matters, several conditions reduce the possibility the charges will reach the trial stage, such as whether the Survivor was hitchhiking, or was under the influence of drugs or alcohol. A woman may want to press criminal charges because by initiating a court case, she forces the courts and the community to acknowledge that rape exists. Society will not condemn the existence and continuation of rape until the awareness of rape grows. Also, women may want to show that they will not react passively about their safety. Perhaps men would not rape as easily if they knew that women would fight back, both literally and legally. Once the criminal prosecution is concluded, the Survivor should also consider bringing her own personal civil lawsuit against the rapist and others responsible for her injuries. The purpose of a civil suit is to benefit the Survivor and compensate her for the aftermath of rape she has suffered. A civil suit must be filed within one year after the attack. (See Chapter VII on Compensation for the Rape Survivor.) Why Immediate Medical Care Is Important Many Survivors experience a variety of physical symptoms after the attack. Some of these are caused by physical abuse or violence while others result from the Survivor's emotional distress. These symptoms may include soreness, muscle tension, headaches, stomach pains, nausea and sleep disturbances. Common gynecological symptoms are vaginal discharge, itching, burning sensations, and generalized pain. There may be genital abrasions, lacerations or bleeding in the vaginal or rectal area. Even if there is no discomfort or pain, the Survivor should receive medical attention. Many rape Survivors are in shock for varying amounts of time following the rape, and may not be as aware of their bodies and pain as they would be normally. For example, a Survivor may not be aware of internal injury or bleeding for several hours or days or she may not remember part of her rape experience. Because of the apparent shock, the danger of untreated internal injury and the possibility of venereal disease and pregnancy, every rape Survivor must seek immediate medical attention. The rape Survivor's fundamental concern should be for her personal health and well-being. For this reason she should seek emergency medical attention as soon as possible. A Survivor may want her immediate examination from a family physician who is familiar with her medical history. The Survivor may relate better to a physician who knows her, and the physician may treat the Survivor more sympathetically because s/he knows the Survivor. Also, the physician may testify more readily at a later proceeding or trial on behalf of a patient s/he knows and understands. Another concern is medical evidence. Unlike other crimes of violence, medical evidence that a rape has occurred should be collected within 12 to 72 hours after the attack. Even if the Survivor has decided not make a police report, the doctor will collect and record all possible evidence. If she changes her mind later, then this evidence can be used in arrest and court proceedings. If the evidence is not collected within the allotted time by doctors who preserve and transfer it to the authorities, then it is of little use in court. The hospitals listed in this booklet train and instruct their staffs in the care of the rape Survivor and the collection and preservation of evidence. Getting In To See The Doctor If the police take the Survivor to the hospital, they will inform the intake worker, or triage nurse, that the woman is a rape Survivor and needs immediate medical care. If she is cooperating with the police, then the police department will pay for the medical tests needed for evidence. A police officer will assist the Survivor before and after the examination, but not during the examination. If the Survivor comes in on her own, without the police, she should tell the receptionist that she is a rape Survivor. She may bring a friend or a rape counselor to the hospital. If the Survivor prefers to see her own doctor, or to go to another hospital, she may do so. However, some hospitals may not have a doctor on duty, most will not collect the necessary evidence for prosecution of the case, and the Survivor will have to pay all costs. An emergency room provides care to many people and attention is given to life-threatened persons first. Sometimes a person must wait due to the number of critical patients. At other times, the staff may be trying to arrange a few extra moments with the Survivor. Rape Survivors must not let an aide, a nurse, or anyone else clean off her body or assist her in douching before the medical examination. For the same reason, she should not use the bathroom. By refraining, she saves important evidence of the sexual assault. If the Survivor has already bathed, by force or by choice, she should tell the doctor. "Paperwork" Before You See The Doctor The nurse will explain hospital procedures and ask the Survivor about her medical history. The Survivor will then read two consent forms before the doctor examines her. One gives the hospital permission to examine and treat the Survivor. The other indicates whether or not she wants her medical record or any other evidence released to the police. The Survivor can cross out any sections she wishes before signing the forms. If the police have not been called, the nurse will ask if the Survivor wishes to make a police report. If so, the police will be notified immediately. Under no circumstances is a Survivor required to make a police report in order to receive emergency medical treatment. However, every physician and hospital is required by law to report the name, address, type of assault, nature and extent of injury of each Survivor of the violent crime treated. Even so, it does not constitute a formal police report that results in the prosecution of the rapist. The police cannot act, unless the Survivor personally reports the rape to them. The decision not to make a police report is a very serious one that may affect the Survivor's and other women's safety because rapists generally rape more than one woman. Fortunately, more women are reporting rape and cooperating with the police and the courts to control the problem of rape. If the Survivor does not wish to report the crime to the police, she can still help to some degree. Other Survivors may have already reported similar rapes and described a rapist resembling the man who attacked her. A Survivor can ask the nurse, or a rape counselor to telephone the police if she wants to give information without actually reporting. The information may enable the police to arrest the rapist and protect other women. However, one problem is that some police departments will not take these reports. After the Survivor has signed the appropriate forms, the nurse will help prepare her for the examination. She will be asked to remove her clothes and put on a hospital gown. The nurse will remain with her through the doctor's examination. When police departments require their official representative to be present during the examination, they always provide a female. Many police departments do not have such a requirement. Helping With The Assault Determination Examination The following procedures are used during the examination. In all cases, Survivors should feel free to ask the nurses, doctors or counselors any questions she has about the examination procedures. The General Examination The Survivor will be asked about her general state of health and about significant past medical history (i.e., if she is taking medication, has allergies). The doctor will perform a general physical exam which includes recording blood pressure, weight and temperature, and examining ears, eyes, mouth, heart, lungs, response and limbs. The doctor will ask specific questions about the sexual assault. They will include:
The Survivor must tell the doctor what happened so that the doctor may give her proper treatment and obtain evidence of the assault. The Pelvic Examination The pelvic examination is similar to an annual examination and pap smear. The doctor checks external pelvic and internal genital areas for tears, cuts, bruises, or other signs that force was used. He will note these in the medical report. The doctor will insert a speculum and then take smears and cultures from the vagina to test for semen, sperm cells, and venereal disease. If sperm cells are present, the doctor records whether the cells are alive and moving. The movement of the sperm cells helps the doctor confirm when the sexual acts took place. The doctor will need to know if and when the Survivor last had consensual sexual intercourse, to determine if the sperm cells were from the rape. Many doctors will routinely perform a rectal examination during a rape examination. The doctor inserts a gloved, lubricated index finger into the anal opening to feel for tears, or abrasions. If there is evidence of anal rape, then the doctor will take smears and cultures from the anal canal to test for sperm cells, semen, and venereal disease. This test is slightly uncomfortable, and pressure can be relieved during this brief exam by breathing slowly through an open mouth. Other Tests Other possible tests include:
Testing For Venereal Disease The Survivor may have contracted venereal disease from the assailant. The doctor cannot diagnose this immediately, but s/he will take blood tests and cultures to aid in the diagnosis. The doctor may offer preventive medication, usually penicillin. (If she is allergic to penicillin, she should inform the doctor so that alternative medications can be used.) If she takes preventive medication, at the hospital, she is unlikely to contract venereal disease from the assault, but she must have follow-up tests. Her private physician or the hospital will arrange for follow-up retesting. These tests are needed because of ten a woman does not have any outward signs that she has a venereal disease. Because gonorrhea and syphilis can greatly harm the body and the reproductive system, and can endanger life, Survivors should be very careful that they are retested at the right times. Also, until follow-up tests show that venereal disease is not present, it is possible to infect someone else through oral, anal, or genital contact. Because of the severe emotional trauma caused by rape, Survivors are often advised to reestablish normal sexual relationships as soon as possible. Prophylactics offer protection during intercourse against venereal disease. A gonorrhea test requires taking a culture from the vagina. It takes four to seven days for the disease to develop to the point of detection. Syphilis is detected by examining a blood sample, and takes about six weeks to develop. Free tests and treatment are available at public health clinics or at women's clinics. The Survivor should contact a clinic or physician for a gonorrhea test within four to seven days after the rape and again within six to eight weeks for a syphilis test. Pregnancy Testing If the Survivor was not using some form of birth control at the time of the rape, she may worry about becoming pregnant. Although it is not certain that the Survivor will become pregnant as a result of the rape, the doctor will talk to her about methods to prevent pregnancy. If she knows or suspects that she is already pregnant, she must tell the doctor. The emergency physician can offer medications which will terminate the pregnancy. This hormone will cause the Survivor to have a menstrual period in approximately three days. It is usually given as a shot since the pill form has to be taken over several days and may cause unpleasant side effects. Side effects include nausea, headache, breast tenderness and warm "flashes." Before the doctor gives pregnancy-preventing drugs to her, the Survivor must give a urine sample to determine if she was pregnant before the attack. No drugs will be given if the Survivor is presently pregnant or chooses not to have them. The Survivor may decide to wait and see if she misses a menstrual period. If so, a doctor 'may give medication to bring it on. However, this does not rule out the possibility of pregnancy. The Survivor should have a pregnancy test soon after the rape occurs. If the test establishes that the Survivor is pregnant as a result of the rape, then she has enough time to think about her options. If she decides to carry the pregnancy to term, then she will want early. pre-natal medical attention. If she decides to terminate the pregnancy, a doctor can perform the procedure early. It is important for her to discuss her choices with her doctor and her counselor. She may also want to talk it over with her family and friends. Before leaving The Emergency Room The Survivor should read or have read to her the medical report, in order to request any important changes or additions. Often bruises do not appear for several hours or days after an injury, but the doctor should note any soreness or tenderness. If possible the Survivor should bring a change of clothing with her, as the police may collect some of her clothing for evidence; (especially underpants and articles with semen or blood stains). The hospital may provide a shower after the examination and panties to wear home. The nurse or the doctor will instruct the Survivor on care of her injuries, venereal disease follow-up information, and medication if prescribed. Many Survivors have difficulty sleeping, so they may want to ask for a low-dosage sleeping medication or tranquilizer. The police may wish to question the Survivor further, and will ask her to come with them to the station. She has the right to make an appointment to meet them at a later time is she feels unable to continue. In any case, the Survivor should read the completed police report carefully and make any needed additions or corrections. She should write down the telephone numbers and names of the police contacts, the investigative officer, the detective who will be handling the case, the doctor who examined her, and her counselor. Survivors should arrange for a safe place to stay for the night. If she was raped in her home, she should arrange to stay at a friend's place, with her family or in a hotel. If she wants to return to her home, she should arrange for a friend or a family member to stay with her. She should contact a hotline or mental health center for counseling and advocacy before or immediately after leaving the hospital or police station, and make an appointment for the next day, or earlier, if possible. Survivors should arrange for transportation from the hospital to the place where she is staying with family, friends, or the police. If she called the police into the case, they will take her from the hospital or police station to her destination. It is important for a Survivor to plan her next few days (go to work, shop, seek counseling, etc.). She should try to continue as normal a routine as possible. Once in safe surroundings she can take a bath, wash her hair, eat a good meal and try to get some sleep. The Decision To Charge The Suspect Very soon after the suspect's arrest, the district attorney's office must review the case to determine if there is sufficient evidence and a reasonable chance of convicting the suspected rapist. If so, a formal complaint is issued (charges are brought against the suspect) and filed with the court. In making this decision, the deputy district attorney (DDA) judges the strength of the case by considering the supporting physical evidence collected in the emergency room, the Survivor's potential as a witness, and the availability of other witnesses. S/he may consider it necessary to interview the Survivor before filing charges. This is often done to verify the accuracy of the information in the police report, to obtain additional information, and to explain what to expect from the judicial process. It is within the DDA's discretion to permit Survivors to have a friend or counselor present at interviews with the DDA. During the interview, the DDA will ask the Survivor to review the details of the rape to help determine whether to file charges against the suspect. The DDA will ask very specific questions. The Survivor should ask any questions that she may have. She may be concerned about personal information that might be brought out during the trial. She should discuss with the DDA how s/he will control this information during the trial. During the interview, the Survivor should ask the DDA to explain words or procedures that she does not understand. Also, she should make sure that she has a name and telephone number to call in case she has additional questions or information for the DDA. Sometimes, the DDA decides not to file charges against the suspect. If this happens, she should ask the DDA about this decision, since the Survivor has a right to know why the case will not go to court. If the Survivor is not satisfied with the decision, she may ask for a review of the matter with the DDA's supervisor. Defense Attorney The accused has a right to have a lawyer represent him at all stages of the proceedings against him. This person is called the defense attorney, and may be either an attorney hired by the accused or one assigned to the case by the public defender's office. Whether the defense attorney is paid by the defendant or by public funds, it is her/his duty to work solely for the defendant's interests. The defense receives copies of all statements taken by the police. The defendant's attorney or his investigator may contact the Survivor and request an interview. Do not confuse the public defender's office with the district attorney's office. It is also important not to confuse defense investigators with police investigators. The Survivor should always ask for identification and the purpose in contacting her. The Survivor need not talk with any representative of the person charged with the offense. If she does not want to speak with him, she should refuse, but this fact will be raised at trial. If the Survivor chooses to discuss the case, she is free to do so. She may want to consult the district attorney or police investigator beforehand. If she gives a statement to a defense investigator, she may choose to do so at either the police station or district attorney's office, with both the investigator and DDA present at that time. If the Survivor's statement is put in writing, she is not required to sign the statement. If she decides to sign the statement, she should review it very carefully to assure that it is an accurate account of what occurred. The Survivor should retain a copy of any statements she signs. If the defense contacts her, the Survivor should inform the police investigator of the nature of the contact as soon as possible. The Arraignment At Municipal Court Once the case has been charged, an arraignment date is set, and the accused rapist must appear at a municipal court. The Survivor does not have to appear at the municipal court arraignment. At the arraignment, the judge reads the formal list of charges to the accused, who then pleads guilty or not guilty. (Once a suspect is formally charged, he is called the defendant.) The judge makes sure the defendant understands his constitutional rights and that he will be represented by an attorney during the court proceedings. The Survivor does not have--to appear at the arraignment; however, the defendant, his attorney, and the DDA must be present. If the defendant pleads guilty, he will be referred to the Adult Probation Department for evaluation for his sentencing hearing and the judge will set a sentencing date. If he pleads not guilty, the judge sets a date for the preliminary hearing. The Preliminary Hearing A Court Proceeding To Determine Whether Trial Is Warranted After the arraignment, the DDA presents the facts to a judge at a preliminary hearing in municipal court. There is no jury at this stage of the proceeding. The hearing determines whether the prosecutor can show sufficient evidence that a crime was committed and that the person accused is probably the person who did it. The judge will decide whether there is probable cause to warrant a trial. Cases of this type are given priority for preliminary examination and later trial. The court recognizes the seriousness of the offense, and that the matter should be decided at the earliest possible time. This relates not only to the preliminary examination in the municipal court, but also in superior court for setting trial and for the trial itself. A greater majority of these cases proceed to trial than any other felony case. First, usually there are no witnesses to the offense other than the Survivor and the defendant, and second, if the defendant is found guilty, the penalty is severe. 'the Survivor should be prepared to testify not only at examination in municipal court, but also at trial in superior court. The Survivor will be advised by means of a subpoena (a legal notice ordering her to appear in court) of the hearing's date and location. Usually, the DDA will contact the Survivor before the hearing, to prepare her for the court appearance. The Survivor need no longer give her address aloud in the courtroom, although she must give her name and occupation when she is sworn in to testify. In the court proceedings, the Survivor will be referred to as a "witness for the prosecution" or a "witness for the state," because a sexual assault is legally considered a crime against the state as well as against the individual. Therefore, the DDA prosecutes the case on behalf of the state, not on behalf of the Survivor directly. The state becomes the accuser, and the Survivor is a major witness for the prosecution. The accused and his attorney will be present at the hearing. The Constitution provides that the accused person is entitled to a public trial. However, a preliminary hearing is not a trial and the defense can request the exclusion of all spectators. Only the accused can request a private hearing. In a private preliminary hearing, the law provides that the judge may allow the prosecuting witness to have someone present for moral support. The person she chooses cannot discuss the testimony with any other witness. During the hearing, the Survivor as the prosecuting witness will be called to testify. At that time, the DDA will ask questions to establish that there is probable cause to conclude that the defendant committed the crime and should stand trial. S/he will also have to ask if the prosecuting witness has ever been married to the defendant, and if she recognizes her assailant in the courtroom. If she does, she will be asked to point him out. The defendant's attorney has the right to cross examine and to ask for details of the assault. A recent law has made it difficult for the defense attorney to ask questions about past sexual experiences, unless the judge decides they are relevant to the case. The DDA will try to prevent these questions from being ask ed. The DDA may call other witnesses to testify if s/he feels they are necessary. Usually the defense does not present evidence and the suspect does not testify at the preliminary hearing. After both sides finish, the judge determines whether there is sufficient evidence to send the case to superior court for trial. If the judge does not believe there is enough evidence, the charges will be dismissed and the accused will be released immediately. However, most cases are sent to superior court. How The Suspect Can Gain Release Rapists may threaten to attack their Survivors again to discourage them from making a police report. Although threats to return are common, a second attack is extremely rare. Nevertheless, many Survivors worry about their personal safety and whether the rapist will return. They want to know what happens to the rapist if he is arrested, how long he will be in jail, and whether they can prevent his release. If a suspect is arrested after the Survivor makes a police report, he will be held in jail during the prosecution unless:
In our legal system, every accused person is presumed innocent until proven guilty. A person is arrested because he is believed to be the person who committed the crime. Thus, the detective and the prosecutor will often call the person who is under arrest "the suspect," "the accused," "the alleged rapist," or "the defendant." Even if the Survivor knows that the suspect is the man who raped her, he is considered innocent until he confesses his guilt or is proven guilty in a trial. Bail Since any person charged with a crime is presumed innocent until proven guilty, a judge must set bail. Bail is an amount of money the defendant must post if he wants to stay out of jail until his case is decided. The defendant must either pay the entire amount of bail or pay a percentage of the set amount to a bail bondsman, who arranges for posting a bond in the amount of the bail. Bail is used to assure that the defendant will attend all of his court appearances. Release On Own Recognizance (often referred to as "O.R.) Occasionally, a judge may release a defendant on his own recognizance, which means he need not post bail. The judge bases the decision on information about the suspect's background (residence, family, means of support, criminal history). The defendant's release from custody is prohibited until the defendant has filed a signed release agreement. Such an agreement includes the defendant's promise to appear in court on all scheduled dates, and to not leave the state without the court's permission. The judge must believe that the suspect will return for future court appearances in order to release the defendant. In addition the court may consider the severity of a potential sentence as it effects the likelihood the defendant will not return for future court hearings. The Survivor may influence the judge's decision if the suspect cannot post bail and requests release through this procedure. The Survivor should ask the investigator or the DDA if she can include a statement in the report to the judge. The statement should express concern for her personal safety and should mention any threats, violent behavior, or injuries inflicted by the suspect, or by anyone associated with him. Upon releasing the suspect on bail or on his own recognizance, the judge instructs him that he is not to see or talk to the Survivor at any time or in any way. If the suspect or anyone associated with him contacts the Survivor, she should report the circumstances immediately to the detective. Any violation of the conditions of his release can be grounds for the judge to increase his bail or return him to jail. Superior Court Arraignment This process is basically the same as the municipal court arraignment, except that a superior court judge presides. The Survivor does not have to appear at this arraignment. However, the defendant, his attorney, and the DDA must be present. In some limited cases the district attorney may choose to institute criminal proceedings by indicting the defendant. If he selects the indictment course, then the district attorney will not file a complaint in the municipal court. Instead, the DDA will present testimony describing the crime to the county grand jury. If 12 of the 23 grand jurors find that there is probable cause to conclude that this case should go to trial, then the foreperson of the grand jury signs a "true bill of indictment." When the district attorney follows this procedure, the indictment is filed in the superior court and after arraignment, a preliminary hearing (as previously described in the municipal court) will be scheduled. Pretrial Hearing At the pretrial hearing, the court hears various procedural motions, such as discovery motions (disclosure of evidence before trial), motions to suppress illegally obtained evidence, motions for consolidation or severance (in cases where there are multiple defendants), or motions relating to the admissibility of identification evidence. There are approximately 70 different legal motions that could arise during the pendency of any case. The DDA and defense attorney may enter into plea negotiations at this time by discussing the issues presented by the case and negotiating a conclusion, if possible, without trial. The Survivor may have to appear and testify at a pretrial conference depending which motion or motions are being heard and considered. The DDA will notify her in advance if her testimony is required at this hearing. Before trial, the defense attorney may seek a psychiatric interview. However, according to a legislative mandate, effective January 1, 1981, all psychiatric interviews with the Survivor will be forbidden. In the meantime, the Survivor's refusal to submit to a psychiatric interview will be used against her at trial. The Survivor should agree to an examination only if the defendant agrees to such an examination as well. A felony case settlement policy is followed by the district attorney's office. A defendant charged with a felony must plead to a felony charge(s) in the degree which accurately reflects the portion of the defendant's conduct for which there is sufficient evidence required by law for conviction, or proceed to trial. The essential part of the defendant's conduct is the controlling factor in case settlement or plea bargaining. A DDA usually does not agree to the settlement of a case, by way of plea or submission on the transcript, which seeks to include any sentencing representations or commitments. This policy is especially followed in cases involving forcible rape, sodomy, or oral copulation. Plea Bargains A plea bargain is a compromise between the prosecutor and the defense interests whereby the defendant pleads guilty to a crime in exchange for some leniency and the certainty of knowing the exact crime for which he will be punished. The prosecutor is not required to go to trial, the Survivor does not have to testify in an open court, and there is no chance of losing the case at trial. The plea bargain can take many forms. If the defendant was involved in more than one crime, the prosecutor may agree to drop some charges if the defendant agrees to plead guilty to at least one crime. The prosecutor may agree to reduce the charge of rape to a less serious crime. The prosecutor may recommend a lesser punishment to the judge in return for the accused's guilty plea, which would conclude the case except for the defendant's sentencing. This plea by the defendant must be acceptable to his attorney, the DDA, and ultimately the judge. The defendant will not be allowed to plead guilty, unless his plea is acceptable to all parties. Although the DDA will be representing the interests of the State in the case, the Survivor should discuss with him/her the possible plea and sentencing of the defendant to the pretrial date. If the Survivor is dissatisfied with the bargain, she has a right to a full explanation. The Survivor is entitled to:
Pretrial Motions Continuances and Postponements Since courts have many cases to hear, there may be several postponements ("continuances") before the Survivor actually testifies. She will receive a new notice each time there is a postponement. Continuances may be requested by either the defense or the prosecution. Survivors should be aware that the DDA is in a position to object to a postponement. On Relevant Evidence It is extremely difficult for the defendant's attorney to ask questions in open court about the Survivor's past sexual experiences. The law currently requires the defense to file a written document with the court, explaining what it believes the Survivor's background will show and its relevance to the defense. This generally occurs in cases where the Survivor was previously involved with the defendant, and if so, a hearing is held outside the presence of the jury. At this hearing, the Survivor will be questioned about her background. If the judge determines that her past sexual experiences are relevant to the case, she will have to answer the questions. However, if the judge finds that her past sexual experiences have no bearing upon the case, s/he will inform the defense attorney that s/he may not question the Survivor about those matters. The Trial If there is a trial, it will probably occur several months after the rape. The prosecutor will know the trial date in advance. The Survivor should inform the detective and prosecutor where she can be reached because they may want to prepare her for the trial. Such preparations include reviewing police statements and examining pictures and diagrams of the crime scene. If the Survivor has never been to a trial, she may want to become familiar with the surroundings by visiting the courtroom, or by observing another trial in session. At trial, the defendant can choose whether to have the judge or jury hear his case. If he waives the right to a trial by jury and the prosecution agrees, a judge will hear the case and determine the verdict instead of a jury. If he asks for a jury, the defendant's lawyer and the prosecutor will select the members of the jury. Both the prosecution and defense present all the available evidence at the trial. The Survivor's role here will be similar to her role at the preliminary hearing. She will testify to basically the same information and she may be excluded from the courtroom when she is not on the witness stand. Usually, witnesses from either side are not allowed in the courtroom except when testifying. However, the Survivor may bring friends, relatives, or other supportive people with her. It is not easy to testify, but it is not as hard as television and movies portray it. The prosecutor will ask simple questions, knowing the answers in advance. The Survivor's job is to tell the truth clearly and fully. If she does not understand a question, she should ask the attorney to repeat it or reword it. When the prosecutor finishes asking questions, the defendant's lawyer will begin the cross-examination. These questions will be more detailed and may be harder to answer than those asked by the prosecutor. Survivors should pause and think before answering and ask the judge or the defendant's attorney to explain questions she does not understand. As a witness, she should:
If anyone asks a question that the Survivor thinks should not have been asked, she may ask the judge's opinion. If the judge tells her to answer, she must do so. The Survivor may think some questions are arbitrary, but they may be necessary to satisfy the law. She should always ask attorneys to explain questions that she does not understand. If the questioning becomes too intensive while the Survivor is on the stand, she should ask the judge if she could please have a few moments before continuing. The suspect does not have to testify, in which case the jury is told not to hold that against him. After all the evidence is presented and each lawyer gives a final statement, the judge tells the jury what laws apply to the case. The case is' then given to the jury to decide if the defendant is guilty. Types Of Verdicts At the trial, the prosecutor must introduce enough evidence about the suspect's guilt to erase any reasonable doubt in the minds of the jurors or judge. A finding of not guilty does not mean that the defendant did not commit the crime or that the Survivor has not told the truth. It may simply mean that there was not enough evidence for the jury to believe that the defendant was guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. If all the members of the jury cannot come to the same verdict, they are called a "hung jury." In this case, the court will probably order a new trial for a later date. If the defendant was found not guilty, he will be released immediately. If the defendant is convicted, the court will set the case for hearing on the defendant's sentencing. Because other witnesses may be called and because a jury may have to reach a verdict, the Survivor may not be present in the courtroom when the verdict is announced. After the trial, the DDA will advise her of the outcome. The Sentencing Stage The Probation Department If the defendant is found guilty or if he pleads guilty, then the probation department receives the case. It may be weeks or months before he receives the sentence stating his punishment. During this time, the probation officer will prepare an evaluation report which includes an interview with the defendant; the defendant's personal statement; detailed background information; and statements from the police inspector, witnesses, and references. The probation officer will want to interview the Survivor and include her statements in the report. S/he will contact the Survivor (or her parents if she is under 18) by mail and ask to make an appointment. During the interview, the probation officer will ask her to describe the assault and any violent behavior by the defendant. The Survivor's statement is a very important part of the pre-sentence report, because the probation officer will make sentencing recommendations based on information gathered for this report. The Sentence At the sentencing, the judge may or may not follow the probation department's recommendations. The sentence imposed is the judge's decision within the guidelines of the law. The DDA will contact the Survivor to inform her of the details of the sentence. The prosecutor will also recommend a ' sentence. If the Survivor wishes to make a recommendation, she should inform the prosecutor. The prosecutor may suggest that the Survivor write a letter for submission to the judge or that she attend the sentencing in order to express her view. Any letter written by the Survivor should be submitted to the probation officer in advance of the sentencing date. Probation is not a sentencing choice in this type of case; either state prison or a state hospital facility is the only alternative.
Compensation for the Rape Survivor The Survivor may sue the rapist, or other persons legally responsible, for her injuries for money damages, even if the district attorney does not prosecute her case or if the rapist is not convicted at a criminal trial. In a civil suit for her personal injuries, the Survivor need only prove her case by a "preponderance of the evidence." The heavier burden of proof "beyond a reasonable doubt" only applies to criminal prosecutions. In a civil case, the Survivor can ask for money damages in either a court or jury trial. Such a trial is directly for her benefit and, unlike a criminal prosecution, is brought expressly on her behalf against the individuals responsible for her injuries. She may sue the owner of the property where the rape occurred, if his negligence contributed to cause her injuries. The negligent apartment house or motel owner who failed to provide proper security can be held responsible for injuries to the rape Survivor. Other potential persons who have been held responsible for a rape Survivor's injuries include: lock manufacturers, owners and managers of unlighted premises (i.e., parking lots and hallways), locksmiths, architects and building contractors. These people have a duty to protect against known dangers, and at a minimum, to warn of any potential hazards presented to women. The Survivor may represent herself in a civil suit but should hire an attorney, preferably one experienced in handling personal injury litigation. A civil suit must be filed within one year after the rape. For this reason it is important to promptly retain an attorney. Many lawyers offer their services on a "contingency feel' basis and do not charge in advance. If the suit is successful, these attorneys receive a pre-agreed percentage of the recovery. If the case is unsuccessful, the rape Survivor owes nothing. Although most civil suits settle before trial, if her case proceeds to a verdict, the Survivor is entitled to financial compensation for all of her injuries and damages including the following:
The dollar amount of any award would be determined by the judge or jury hearing the case and would be based upon the facts presented by her attorney. In cases where a financially solvent third party is not legally responsible, suing a rapist who currently has no financial resources may not seem worthwhile, but the Survivor can obtain a legal judgment enforceable for a ten-year period, which may become collectable. Circumstances change, and the financial picture of today's rapist could improve tomorro |
|||||||||||||
This document maintained by WEB MAN@ADDR.COM. |